To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the violent scenes that took place in George Square, Glasgow, at the weekend. (S5T-02272)
Official Report · Chamber
Protests (Glasgow)
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sandra White SNP 3
- Humza Yousaf SNP 3
- Ken Macintosh 1
The record
7 contributionsI was completely appalled by the shameful scenes that took place in George Square last Sunday, first because there is never any excuse for violence or intimidation, and secondly because our police officers have been on the front line in keeping us safe during this pandemic, and for them to have to face the disorder that we witnessed on Sunday is simply unacceptable.
The scenes were very much in stark contrast to the peaceful Black Lives Matter demonstrations that took place in Scotland the week before.
I remind everyone that we continue to be in a crisis situation and that mass gatherings of people put at risk the lives our citizens and front-line public service workers. The First Minister and I have been crystal clear in supporting everyone’s right to protest, but we have called on those who wish to do so to consider alternative ways to protest, such as through social media and digital means.
The minister will be aware of Tommy Ga-Ken Wan, a Scottish-Chinese gentleman who is a photographer in Glasgow. He was racially abused and punched on the head. According to Tommy, the police threatened him with action if he did not leave. A staff member for The Herald, who was also there, said:
“Went along to #GeorgeSquare today—folk patrolling the perimeter threatening people who are taking photos ... After being approached by a few men I deleted most of my pictures”.
Can the cabinet secretary outline what action the police can and should take in such circumstances and why no action was taken on Sunday against those thugs?
I was deeply moved by Tommy Ga-Ken Wan’s comments and the story of the disgraceful incident that he had to face. As someone who has also publicly faced racist abuse, I know how hurtful it can be. I read his account in the Glasgow Times this morning. I was deeply moved by it and ashamed that we live in a country where someone has to suffer that racial abuse. I offer solidarity to Tommy during this difficult time.
Over the years, including before I was justice secretary but particularly during my time in this role, I have spoken about hate crime to Police Scotland’s most senior police officers—chief constables, deputy chief constables and assistant chief constables. There is zero tolerance for hate crime in any form.
With regard to the specific incident that Sandra White raised and the disappointment that Tommy expressed in his story, the chief constable is accountable for police operations. Therefore, if Sandra White has not already done so, she should write to the chief constable, who will undoubtedly respond. If Tommy is equally unhappy with Police Scotland’s actions in regard to this particular incident, he can also make a formal complaint about it. If he is not satisfied with the response to his complaint to Police Scotland, he can make a complaint to the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner in relation to the handling of that complaint. There are avenues to take that forward.
I have written to the police, but I have not yet received a reply. I have already spoken to Tommy—I would not put forward anything that he had not agreed to—and I have offered to speak to him again.
Those people were thugs. I witnessed police officers, helicopters, mounted police and police motorbikes and vans, and the whole square was closed down to ordinary people walking about.
Although the people were thugs and their actions were criminal, there is more to it. That intolerance comes from people’s ignorance of the history of slavery and colonisation. I ask that this subject be taught in our schools, as part of our school curriculum. A good place to start would be the television programme, “Slavery: Scotland’s Hidden Shame”, which is presented by David Hayman. I ask the cabinet secretary to speak to the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills, because the events stem from ignorance about what happened all those years ago.
I agree with Sandra White’s characterisation that the individuals involved were thugs—there is no getting away from that. In my opening remarks, I specifically made the point that the scenes in Glasgow on Sunday were in stark contrast to the Black Lives Matter protests in Scotland the previous weekend.
With regard to Sandra White’s substantial point, the Deputy First Minister and I have had that conversation. He can give her more details, but the curriculum for excellence allows the opportunity for the slave trade and Scotland’s role in it to be taught in our schools. If there is something further that we can and should do in that regard, the Deputy First Minister would be happy for me to say that we could actively explore that.
What I would say is that, for all the negatives—there are many of them—that have been raised by the Black Lives Matter movement, there is a silver lining, in that we have been forced as a nation to confront that part of our past in a way that I do not think has happened in my lifetime. I suppose that the message that I would send is that we should not waste that opportunity and we should ensure that we educate not just ourselves but future generations on the role that Scotland played in the slave trade.
I apologise to James Kelly and Patrick Harvie, who have been waiting patiently to ask a supplementary question. We have run out of time.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 16 Jun 2020 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (Review) Questions · 18
- Schools (Part-time Learning Model) Questions · 14
- Protests (Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Greenhouse Gas Emissions Statistics (2018) Statement · 30
- Covid-19 Fiscal Implications Debate · 71
- Corporate Insolvency and Governance Bill Bill debate · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.