To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide further clarity to comments by the Deputy First Minister that schools could adopt a part-time learning model for the whole of the next academic year. (S5T-02270)
Official Report · Chamber
Schools (Part-time Learning Model)
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 7
- Jamie Greene Con 3
- Iain Gray Lab 1
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 1
- Willie Rennie LD 1
- Jamie Halcro Johnston Con 1
The record
14 contributions
I indicated on Sunday that we do not want the blended learning model to go on for a moment longer than is required for public health reasons and that we want young people to be back having face-to-face learning for 100 per cent of the school week as soon as it is safe to do so.
Ensuring that our children and young people have the highest-quality education is of critical importance. To that end, our regular three-weekly reviews of the coronavirus regulations will include specific consideration of the evidence and data relating to transmission in schools and among young people. Where that suggests that specific safety restrictions can be lifted or eased without putting pupils or teachers at undue risk, we will take that course of action.
My inbox is full on this matter, as I suspect is the case for other members. Parents around Scotland were justifiably concerned and angry this weekend. They are concerned about how they can possibly return to work with their children being educated only part time and they are angry that no one in the Government can give them clear answers to fundamental questions about their children’s education next year.
Instead, we have had mixed messages, confusion and a chronic lack of leadership. On Sunday morning, the cabinet secretary told broadcasters that part-time schooling could last all next year, only to be undermined by the First Minister a few short hours later.
On behalf of parents, and to help the cabinet secretary clear up any confusion on the matter, I have a simple question. Knowing that we cannot rely on a vaccine for the virus being available any time soon, by what date does he believe that schools will return to normal?
As I made clear in my first answer, I want schools to return to normal as quickly as it is safe for that to happen. The Government is working with its local authority partners through an agreed framework, which has been discussed and agreed with the teaching professional associations and representatives of the parental community, to ensure that we have a workable approach to sustain the learning of children and young people, part of which will happen in school and part of which will happen at home, supported by a range of digital learning support that is available just now and will be strengthened as we approach the resumption of the school term in August.
As I said in my earlier answer, we will bring to an end blended learning when it is safe to do so.
I acknowledge that this is a challenging period for parents. However, I too have had communication from many parents about the importance of ensuring that our schools are safe places for children and young people. I am sure that members will understand the importance that I have to attach to ensuring that our schools are safe places for the education of children.
The cabinet secretary is saying, in essence, that he cannot give a date. However, the First Minister was able to say yesterday that the blended model will
“not ... last a year or anything like it”.
What exactly does that mean?
Parents and pupils need more detail, but we are getting two competing messages from the Government’s two most senior ministers.
Since the education secretary does not know whether, or when, schools will fully reopen, perhaps he can answer some questions to which he should know the answer. How much additional classroom capacity could schools deliver if social distancing was reduced to 1m? How many additional teachers have been recruited since March to deal with his plans for blended learning? Will he guarantee to members that children will be able, next academic year, to access the same breadth of subjects as was available to them this year?
The blended learning model is the product of an agreement between the Scottish Government, local authorities, the teaching professional associations and parents. It has been worked on for some weeks since the lockdown began, to ensure that we had an agreed framework that could be deployed locally to maximise the impact and effect of education on young people.
On school occupancy, answers vary around the country, as Mr Greene will know. As I explained to the Education and Skills Committee on Friday, some schools operate significantly below full occupancy and, in many cases, will be able to deliver almost a full timetable for children and young people. At the other end of the spectrum are schools that have much more significant rolls, which may be close to capacity, or even, in some circumstances, over capacity. They have to manage very carefully the accommodation that is available to them.
The strategic framework put in place the facility for, and the requirement on, local authorities to maximise available accommodation and staff resources. That is what we expect of local authorities, and it will vary because of the options that are available around the country. In the plans that come forward from local authorities, we will be looking for detail on how they are maximising the use of accommodation and the recruitment of staff.
The General Teaching Council for Scotland is contacting registered teachers who are not currently teaching, to assess their availability to support the expansion of learning models around the country.
The Scottish Government produced a detailed route map for the reopening of economic and social life. It is not perfect, but at least it is a timetabled plan towards normality for every part of Scotland. Why on earth, therefore, was there no route map for a return to full-time school for every pupil in Scotland—as is, after all, their right?
Mr Gray has obviously not been reading carefully enough, because that is precisely what the strategic framework does. It underpins the importance of restoring full-time education for young people, at the earliest possible opportunity, when it is safe for us to do that for staff and pupils. If Mr Gray is prepared to be cavalier with the safety of staff and pupils, he is welcome to that view, but it is not one that I share.
link
The cost of providing blended education will be different for each local authority, and we do not yet know how long the approach will last. Can the cabinet secretary provide a best estimate of the educational and financial impact for each month in which blended learning remains in place in Scotland? Will local authorities be permitted to end blended learning and return to normal when they consider it appropriate to do so?
The assessment of financial issues will flow from the development of local authority plans to deliver the blended learning approach around the country. That commitment was given in the strategic framework that the Government published in May and the issue will be the subject of detailed discussion as we assess and consider the plans that individual local authorities put forward. Mr Gibson is correct to say that plans will vary from area to area across the country.
link
The mammoth effort to get our health service ready for the virus and to protect our businesses from the virus has not been replicated in the context of young people’s education.
If the Scottish Government is asking parents to return to work, the Scottish Government has an obligation to make provision for full-time childcare. If school hours are cut in half, childminder provision is cut back and grandparents are not allowed to look after kids, who exactly is going to look after them?
Mr Rennie does a disservice to the educators the length and breadth of the country who have done a significant amount of work to deliver learning in the extremely challenging circumstances that we currently face. If Mr Rennie will not pay tribute to the teachers who are delivering that education, I am very pleased to do so, to make sure that teachers understand that the Government appreciates and values the contribution that they are making in difficult and challenging circumstances.
The route map that the Government set out indicates clearly the relationship between the resumption of economic and work activity and the resumption of school activity in the country: they must go hand in hand. That is the design of the route map, and further details on that will be shared with the Parliament by the First Minister on Thursday.
Bruce Adamson, Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, said:
“We know the home based learning that they have been doing just doesn’t work. It is no substitute whatsoever for a real-life, school-based education.”
He went on to say that the proposals for blended learning are
“heavily based on home learning”,
which is
“going to have a real impact on children’s right to education. So we need to do much better.”
Does the cabinet secretary need to do much better?
As I indicated in my earlier answers, the Government has formulated a framework for the resumption of full-time schooling, in partnership with our local authority colleagues, the professional associations and parents, to make sure that we resume learning as early as we can do.
I have accepted publicly—I did so in front of the Education and Skills Committee on Friday—that blended learning is not as good a model as the education delivery model that we had in place before Covid.
We have to resume full-time education as early as we possibly can do. However, I have to deal with the reality that the scientific and clinical advice to me just now does not enable us to restore full-time learning in schools. We will do that at the earliest possible opportunity. I am sure that the Parliament understands the importance of our listening to and following carefully the scientific and clinical advice that is available to us, because the safety of children and staff must be paramount in the decisions that we take.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 16 Jun 2020 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (Review) Questions · 18
- Schools (Part-time Learning Model) Questions · 14
- Protests (Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Greenhouse Gas Emissions Statistics (2018) Statement · 30
- Covid-19 Fiscal Implications Debate · 71
- Corporate Insolvency and Governance Bill Bill debate · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.