The third continued petition is PE1733, which was lodged by Peter Ritchie on behalf of the Scottish Food Coalition, and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to make the right to food part of Scots law.
Rhoda Grant MSP has joined us to hear our consideration of the petition. Elaine Smith MSP and Sarah Boyack MSP were present the first time we considered the petition, and Elaine Smith has highlighted that she intends to explore introducing a member’s bill on the issues that are raised.
In its consultation on proposals for a good food nation bill, the Scottish Government proposed a statutory requirement on Scottish ministers and specified public authorities to have regard to relevant international obligations and guidance in developing statements of policy on food. However, in his submission, the petitioner states that he remains of the belief that the right to food should be incorporated in Scots law through such a bill
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
As I said when we first considered the petition, I have been supportive of the issue right from the start and have spoken on it in the chamber a number of times. The difficulty that we have is that, for a while, we did not know whether the proposed good food nation bill would ever happen. We now have a commitment to it. We do not know what will be in it, but the Government has told us that the right to food will not be in it, which I find slightly disappointing. I note that the petitioner has welcomed the national task force and the human rights framework. The First Minister’s task force has also said that human rights will underpin all our policy.
The Government has said that the right to food will not be in the good food nation bill, so I am not sure that the committee can do any more with the petition. However, I am reluctant to let it go. There certainly needs to be a watching brief kept on the issue in some shape or form. I know that other committees might not always thank us for doing so, but I wonder whether we should pass the petition on to one of them to do that. I know that the rural committee has considered the concept of a good food nation bill. However, if the issue is seen as being more of a human rights one, perhaps the Equalities and Human Rights Committee should consider it. The matter is too important for us simply to close the petition and let it go.
Thank you. I am sure that the official reporters will write that into the record.
We acknowledge the issues, and there is clearly interest in the petition, not least that of the deputy convener, but I agree that the committee cannot do much more with it. There is no doubt that the subject will be debated in Parliament, so we urge the campaigners to recognise that they will have a role through engaging in the consultation. In addition, a number of MSPs have expressed an interest in the subject. The question is whether we should close the petition or refer it to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, which would have it while dealing with the good food nation bill.
I very much support the petition. I welcome the idea of a good food nation bill, but I am disappointed that the Government has ruled out including in it the right to food that the petitioner proposes, because what we do around food is not adequate under human rights legislation. That said, it will be open to members to seek to amend the bill to include such a right.
I agree with Gail Ross that if we refer the petition to the committee that will take the lead on the bill, that will, at the very least, encourage it to take evidence on the right to food and consider whether it should be included in the bill. I think that the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee will, if it takes such evidence, be convinced that it should support an amendment to include the right to food in the bill. If this committee can do no more on the petition, referring it to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee would ensure consideration of including in the bill what the petitioner is looking for.
We will refer the petition to the rural committee—with its Sunday title—and highlight to it the issues that have been flagged up, recognising that the subject will be addressed through legislation from the Scottish Government. Is that agreed?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.