Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

A83 (Rest and Be Thankful) (PE1540)

Thursday 5 March 2020 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:45 Petitions 111 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

111 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The first continued petition for consideration is PE1540, on a permanent solution for the A83. The petition was lodged by Douglas Philand and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that there is a permanent solution for the A83 at the Rest and Be Thankful, so that that vital lifeline route is not closed because of landslides.

I welcome Rhoda Grant MSP and Jackie Baillie MSP for this item.

As members will be aware, last year, we agreed to take evidence on the petition from the Scottish Government. I am pleased to welcome Michael Matheson, the Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity, and, from the Scottish Government, Fiona Brown, head of strategic transport planning, and Jonny Moran, operating company manager.

I invite the cabinet secretary to provide a brief opening statement before we move to questions.

Michael Matheson SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity · Falkirk West
link

Good morning, convener, and thank you for giving me the opportunity to provide you with an update on progress at the Rest and Be Thankful next to the A83.

I am acutely aware of the importance of the A83 trunk road to the communities and the economy of Argyll and Bute. We have continued to invest in this key route: since 2007, we have invested £79.2 million in the maintenance of the A83 trunk road.

Since the decision at the February 2013 task force meeting to progress with the red option measures, the Scottish Government has provided funds of £13 million on landslide mitigation measures and improvements to the local old military road diversion. Those measures have been successful in helping to keep the A83 open for 48 days when it would otherwise have been closed.

However, at my first A83 task force meeting, in November 2018, following concerns being raised by local stakeholders, I announced that the Argyll and Bute region would be one of the first to be reported on in the strategic transport projects review 2 process.

I am glad to report that we have recently reached the first major milestone of the review with the publication of the draft regional case for change report for Argyll and Bute. The publication of the report is the first step in the appraisal process, and it sets out the evidence base that underpins the review. The next steps will see the development of a short list of interventions, which will then be taken through a detailed appraisal later this year.

We continue to explore ways to reduce the risk of impact from landslides in the area. I am glad to announce today that I have given approval for the construction of the next roadside catch pit at the Rest and Be Thankful in the coming financial year, which is valued at £1.9 million. Once it is complete, the phase 1 catch pit will provide an additional 4,600 tonnes of storage capacity to collect debris flow from landslides, to add to the 14,600 tonnes of capacity that is provided by the four existing catch pits.

I have asked my officials to discuss the timing of these works with Argyll and Bute Council, as we have the option to build the pit between June and December 2020 or to delay until after the tourist season and to build it between September 2020 and March 2021.

We have also progressed the programme of planting trees on the hillside, to reduce the risk of landslide. Land purchase at the Rest and Be Thankful has been concluded, and we are working closely with Forestry and Land Scotland to reintroduce the required local-provenance, native vegetation on the hillside. The erection of a deer fence is programmed to commence this summer, with planting due to commence early next year.

I am more than happy to respond to questions from committee members.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. I should also have welcomed Donald Cameron MSP, who is here for our consideration of this petition.

Cabinet secretary, as you might be aware, the petition has been running for almost seven years—it predates many members’ membership of this committee—but, as of yet, a permanent solution, which is called for in the petition, has not been provided. We understand that, over the years, work has been undertaken and substantial investment has been made to keep the A83 open at the Rest and Be Thankful. However, as recently as January, the road was closed again due to a landslip. Is it fair to say that the Scottish Government’s response to this longstanding issue has been piecemeal?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

No, because work was undertaken to ascertain what the long-term solution should be—the red option—back in 2013. The work that related to the red option was largely completed by 2014, with the exception of the tree planting, which is a long-term project. The principal options were assessed at that time, and the red option, which seemed to be the most appropriate approach, was taken forward.

Since then, we have introduced additional mitigation measures—in particular, catch pits, the use of which will be extended, as I said.

Wider strategic transport interventions in Argyll and Bute will be required to go through the STPR2 process, which is exactly what is happening just now. Reporting on the Argyll and Bute area is being accelerated—I agreed in 2018 that Argyll and Bute would be the first region to be reported on in terms of the range of transport intervention options for the region.

I would not say that our approach has been piecemeal. The red option was agreed by the task force and the measures were completed by March 2014.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You talk about mitigation, but that is not a permanent solution. You had meetings in the first half of last year to consult on the issue, and we are now meandering our way towards some kind of response to that. To me, it feels that unbelievably slow progress is being made around the review. People say that they have to look at this and then they have to look at that, and so on. I am sure that progress is slower than the traffic sometimes is on the A83.

Is there any way of accelerating the process? It does not seem to reflect the urgency of the issue for local people or the consequences for the local economy and its sustainability, which is something that Argyll and Bute Council has flagged up.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The wider mitigation measures will help to provide greater resilience, which is an issue that is highlighted in the petition. As a result of the mitigation measures that have been put in place, there has been greater resilience at the Rest and Be Thankful, but there remain risks, which is why further mitigation measures are being undertaken.

I presume that, when you mentioned a review, you were referring to the STPR2 process. That is a major strategic piece of work across the whole country—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It can be major without being so slow that we do not deal with the problems that it is supposed to address. I find it astonishing that, although you consulted in the first half of last year, you are still pretty vague about when the conclusions will come.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The conclusions of STPR2—for the whole of the country—will be published in this parliamentary session, so they will be published by next spring.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

No. STPR2 is a major piece of work. It is being done differently from how it was last carried out, in 2008, when it was done just at a national level. In recognition of some of the regional issues, we have broken the work down so that there is a regional approach. To help to speed up the process for Argyll and Bute, the necessary work in that regard was brought forward to be undertaken earlier.

That is why the process started last year. The report “Initial appraisal: Case for Change - Edinburgh and South East Scotland - STPR2” was published last week. We are now entering the appraisal process, which will look at what the interventions should be. That information will then be fed into the recommendations for the STPR2 process for the whole country. That is happening at a regional level in the south-west, the Borders and the Highlands of Scotland to ensure that stakeholders have an opportunity to shape and feed into the process and identify the issues in each region.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The STPR2 process will be reported on during this parliamentary term, but stakeholder workshops have taken place and the task force has been in operation for a number of years. What is the feedback from locals about how the process has gone so far?

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I mean in relation to the mitigation measures and what has been happening.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

There will be a variety of views. I chaired the most recent task force meeting, in January, when the principal focus was not on further mitigation measures as such but on issues relating to the bus stop at the top of the Rest and Be Thankful. A variety of stakeholders on the task force have different views on what they would like to see happening—some further mitigation work or alternative routes. I expect that some of them will feel frustration about not seeing further action being taken in a particular way at a certain time. However, broadly, at the most recent meeting, the focus was on public transport issues rather than on the mitigation works at the Rest and Be Thankful, although a full presentation was given on the work that had been done since the previous stakeholders’ meeting.

I ask Fiona Brown to give you a bit more of an insight into the STPR2 engagement process and the issues that that is starting to flush out in the feedback that we have had to date.

Fiona Brown Scottish Government
link

As Gail Ross correctly said, we undertook workshops and stakeholder feedback sessions last year. There was also an online survey.

The feedback has largely been about the resilience of the strategic road network, and people clearly stated that they want something reliable. We are aware of the issues of depopulation around Argyll and Bute and perceptions of a lack of investment due the poor resilience of the network. Those issues came through in the stakeholder consultation.

We also held workshops on interventions based around discussion of a permanent solution for the Rest and Be Thankful and of other fixed-link and ferry options, public transport reliability with bus networks and enhancements to the rail network. A variety of interventions came forward as we looked at the Argyll and Bute region as a whole.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

It is worth keeping in mind that STPR2 is not just about roads but about every form of transport—including ferries, public transport and aviation—which is why a substantial piece of work has to be undertaken. The Rest and Be Thankful element of it will be just one part of that wider review work.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

When you finally manage to get a solution, if the timescales are right—someone else will ask about those—will the latest mitigation—the catch pit that you told us about in your opening statement—form part of that solution? If it is going to cost £1.9 million, will that information be fed into the final cost of the solution, or does it stand alone? Do you have any idea of a final budget for a solution?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The mitigation work that has been undertaken and the additional catch pit that I announced today are separate from and not dependent on STPR2. If we did not have an issue with the Rest and Be Thankful, we would still undertake the STPR2 process in Argyll and Bute, because we are doing so across the country. The mitigation works stand on their own, as opposed to being dependent on any part of the STPR process.

09:15

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning, panel. I visited the Rest and Be Thankful with the committee in a previous session of the Parliament to see the improvements to the old military road and the barriers that were put up. Given the condition of the hill and its level of instability, do you think that the catch pit that has been mentioned is enough, or are more barriers needed?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The original recommendation was to pursue the red option that was set out back in 2013-14, and the bit that is outstanding from that is tree planting on the hillside. It will be 10 to 15 years before we start to see the benefits that will come from that programme. However, the land has now been purchased and the planting work will be progressed.

The geotechnical advisers have indicated that the hillside has a dynamic nature in that, over the course of the years, its behaviour has changed. As a result, areas that previously presented no issue now do. That is why further mitigation measures have been put in place, which are over and above those that are set out in the red option.

There is no doubt that the biggest recorded landslide on the hillside was back in October 2018, and the mitigation measures worked on that occasion. They delivered what they were intended to do, which was to divert the landslide and prevent the closure of the road. Therefore the benefits of using such measures, alongside catching debris with nets, have been identified. There are occasions when the mitigation measures have worked and have done their job, as I mentioned in my opening statement. However, greater resilience could be provided by establishing further catch pits, which is why I have announced that catch pit 1 will be introduced.

I have also asked officials to explore areas in which resilience could be improved even further by considering whether we should undertake further catch pit work on other aspects of the road. They are reviewing that at present, with advice from the geotechnical specialists on where any additional catch pits should be located so as to provide the greatest resilience. When incidents have occurred, the mitigation measures have delivered what they were intended to deliver, which is why I want to consider where we might undertake more of them if they could provide greater resilience in the future.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

You mentioned that the land has been purchased, the deer fence is going up and tree planting is planned. How soon will that planting take place? You said that it would be a 15-year project.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Tree planting is due to start in the spring of next year, and we are working with teams from Forestry and Land Scotland to progress that work. Part of the challenge has been in procuring the land. Once the deer fence has been put in, the planting can take place. I understand that such work needs to be undertaken at certain times. For example, fencing is done largely during the summer months, whereas planting tends to be done in the spring.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

Another improvement that has been highlighted is the upgrading of the old military road, which serves as a diversion when the A83 is closed. Will you provide an update on that work and say how many times it has been successfully used as a diversion from the A83?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The old military road has been used as a diversion route on around 19 occasions. The upgrading work on it has been completed and the resurfacing has been carried out. I am not sure whether Jonny Moran has anything to add to that. Is there any outstanding work there?

Jonny Moran Scottish Government
link

Nothing is outstanding just now. The last significant piece of work was undertaken at the Arrochar side of the old military road. We provided definitive improvements by widening the road by a significant amount, which cut down the journey time under convoy from 17 to 11 and a half minutes and gave better access and egress. As the cabinet secretary mentioned, the road is surfaced to a high degree and Police Scotland and Bear Scotland inspect it whenever it is brought into use.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

Is the forestry road still used as an alternative there as well?

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

The road on the other side.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Do you mean the one on the Lochgoilhead side? Has that been used as a diversion route, Jonny?

Jonny Moran Scottish Government
link

We identified a number of issues in the early stage of the study, in 2012-13, when we considered that road as a potential diversion. We undertook a pros and cons exercise and decided that the old military road was a better road to use.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

Is the forestry road out of the picture altogether?

Jonny Moran Scottish Government
link

Yes. That road has not been used as a diversion.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

It is just a forestry road, so it is substandard as a trunk road.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

It is a way through, though.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Michael Russell had suggested that road.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Yes. It was one of the options that were considered in 2013.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

You are saying that the military road will be the alternative, if it is needed.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

When I was a councillor in Argyll and Bute Council, I served from 2012 to 2016 on the committee that had oversight of roads and infrastructure, so I know a lot about the matter. Argyll and Bute Council decided at the time to look more seriously at the blue option, which involved a road on the south side of the Croe. The Scottish Government overrode that option, but I still think that it would00 be sensible to move the main road across to the south side of Glen Croe.

The whole issue had an enormous impact on the Argyll and Bute area, particularly on the economy and the businesses, on tourism and so on. There is concern about the old military road—the pre-planned diversion route. For health and safety reasons, that road has been deemed an old hill climb route, which I remember well. It will no longer be that, but has been considered safe enough for a relief road. However, people still feel that a number of issues remain around it.

Can you reassure those who feel that economic impact that the problem with the A83 is a priority and that you agree that the Argyll and Bute area must be kept open for business? The feeling is that the Scottish Government is not giving enough priority to the issue. As the convener has said, despite what is in STPR2, the Government needs to consider it a major issue. We are not getting anywhere at all by adopting a sticking-plaster approach and repairing the road. Other options should be considered.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Are you referring to work that needs to be done on the old military road, or in Argyll and Bute in general?

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

First, there is a question about the old military road, which could not be put in operation the last time a landslip happened, with 1,000 tonnes of rock and earth coming down on the Arrochar side of the Rest and Be Thankful. The hydrology had changed, because the trees had been harvested, which created a problem. Will we ever solve it? To do what you say is to take a sticking-plaster approach. The relief road is insufficient to satisfy the business community in the Argyll and Bute area that is reliant on economic activity and is trying to stem the depopulation.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I am trying to understand—are you referring to the incident that took place at the end of January?

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

That was one incident, but there is a general feeling—

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I am trying to understand the specific point that you would like me to address.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

The point is that the relief road is insufficient to meet the demands of a closure of the A83 main road and to take the resulting traffic, which causes problems for our communities. That is the point.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I appreciate that that is the case, which is why we are undertaking further mitigation works on the Rest and Be Thankful in order to provide greater resilience on the main road itself. The ultimate objective needs to be that we are not reliant on the relief road. It should be used only when it is required and it has been upgraded to enable that to happen as efficiently as possible. For example, works have been undertaken to widen the road at the lower end to assist in speeding up the convoy system, which has been successful. The temporary measure is certainly not a long-term solution, which is why further mitigation works are necessary, in order to provide greater resilience on the main trunk route.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I am going to put you on the spot here, cabinet secretary. Measures have been put in place and additional measures will be put in place to mitigate landslides, but given the condition of the hill, can there be a permanent solution?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I think that we can get greater resilience. I cannot assure you that we will not have problems in the trunk road network with landslides. I will give you an example. Fairly recently, on the A82 north of Ardlui, I was caught up in the impact of a landslip on to the road. There was debris on the road in October last year as well, just north of Tyndrum, and the Highland main rail line was also washed away. All of that took place within a short period of time due to intense rainfall, and those landslips required significant work to be undertaken.

Just the other week, up on the A82 in Glencoe, there was a landslip on an area of the road. We have had landslips during intense rainfall where debris has gone on to the road and work has required to be undertaken. The advice that I receive from engineers, geotechnical specialists and meteorologists is that we should expect more of the types of intense weather periods that we have had. As a result, we might start to experience problems in areas of our transport network where we historically we have not had any. Part of the work that we are doing with STPR2 involves thinking about measures that we can put in place to mitigate some of those problems, which affect rail as well as road. For example, there have been significant problems on a number of occasions on the Highland line to Fort William with landslips and wash-away caused by the unprecedented intense rain.

We will have to manage such problems as best we can, but I cannot give the kind of guarantee that Mr Torrance implied. We have a trunk road network of over 2,000 miles and some areas are more vulnerable than others, so we need to take forward mitigation in those areas. However, the weather changes that we have been experiencing are having an impact on our transport network. Some committee members will have experienced that in their constituencies. We have to look to manage that as effectively as we can.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I want to go back to the point about timescales. We received a submission from Argyll and Bute Council in which the council stated:

“There is ... no commitment from the Scottish Government to deliver that permanent solution or on timescales. Our understanding is that decisions on the funding of regional and national projects has not been accelerated. If a project is identified for the Rest and Be Thankful it will have to compete for inclusion in the project programme which will span 10 years. The funding decisions, we are led to believe, are at least 2 years away.”

Is that right?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The decisions around funding will be part of the capital spending review, which will take place this year and feed into the STPR2 process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So the STPR will report next year, just before the Parliament closes down for the election.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is Argyll and Bute Council wrong in thinking that the funding has not been accelerated?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I think that the council is confused if it is talking about funding being accelerated. The STPR2 assessment process has been accelerated and the report will be published as a complete review. Decisions will then be made about where funding is to be prioritised and what projects will be taken forward over the course of STPR2.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a process over which you have complete control, so it is not something that you are at the mercy of. As cabinet secretary, you have control over the timescales.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Yes, we have control of the timescales, but I think that Argyll and Bute Council, in its submission to the committee, is wrong or has misunderstood the process. The STPR—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Has the council perhaps misunderstood what “accelerated” means?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Yes, because the process was to assess what is required in Argyll and Bute. That was very clear.

09:30

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So you have accelerated the assessment but not the funding that would deliver the change. Is that right?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

No, because STPR2 was always due to be published in this parliamentary session—nothing has changed in that timeframe.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So nothing has changed in terms of accelerating the funding that would make a difference to the A83.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

We have not completed the assessment yet. Once STPR2 has been completed, the funding decisions will be made.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will invite some of our guest members to ask questions. The first member to indicate was Jackie Baillie.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I welcome the fact that the cabinet secretary got stuck on the A82 because, as he will know, I have been pursuing investment in the A82 and the A83, both of which are in my constituency.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Oh, you got past—but my point stands nevertheless.

I was at the task force meeting in June 2019 at which we considered the STPR2 process. It would be fair to say that we heard from local people about the need for a permanent solution, and that the majority of them favoured a completely different trunk road being established. I am keen to pursue with you and your officials whether the permanent solution is likely to be mitigation on the existing route, given that you have invested so much in it already, or whether you are open to developing a completely new trunk road.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The STPR2 process will involve looking at all options, including alternative routes into Argyll and Bute, and we will not rule out options because of the mitigation work that we are undertaking on the A83 at the Rest and Be Thankful. That mitigation work stands on its own two feet and is being undertaken in its own right. If the STPR2 appraisal identifies that we should look at other options for Argyll and Bute, that process will stand on its own two feet as well. I assure the member that the mitigation work does not mean that we will not look at other options for Argyll and Bute.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

That is helpful.

I want to pursue the issue of lead-in times, which the convener asked about. People who are often stuck at the Rest and Be Thankful or who have to use other routes will want to know when the process is going to end. Whatever option you land on, when is it likely to be realised? I understand the timescale that you have outlined, but I am keen to know, if you approve a particular course of action, when it will happen. Will you prioritise funding for the project, given the obvious need?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

We are still implementing provisions in the first STPR, which was introduced in 2008. Largely, it is a 10-year programme of work, but some of the projects can take longer than 10 years for delivery, just because of construction. For example, if the STPR2 process identified the need for an alternative trunk road route to the existing route through the Rest and Be Thankful—not just because of the challenges that we have had there but because of wider economic and population issues in Argyll and Bute—and even a fixed link to the Cowal peninsula, which has been proposed, it would take an extended period of time to introduce that. A major trunk road project of such scale can take eight to 12 years to go through the assessment process and the technical phase and into the actual execution and delivery.

That is why, even if we accept that something else should be undertaken, the A83 at the Rest and Be Thankful will remain critically important to maintaining access to Argyll and Bute, and that is why I have asked for further consideration to be given to additional mitigation measures that can be put in over and above what has been planned to date. For example, that might mean further catch pits, which have been successful where they have been installed. Even if we agree to an alternative route, we will still be dependent on the A83 for an extended period.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I want to push you on the funding prioritisation. I accept everything that you have said about the delivery times of major projects, but the economic impact and the rate of depopulation of Argyll and Bute is worrying and I am therefore concerned that 10 years seems like quite a long timeframe for a permanent solution to be found.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I recognise that, but identifying the rate at which various projects progress will be looked at a national level. I suspect that, if I asked you whether the priority should be the A82 or the A83, you would say that it is both.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

If I asked people in the south-west of Scotland whether the A77 or the A75 should be the priority, they would say that both should be prioritised. We have to look at all of those competing issues. When the process is accelerated, the identified projects for Argyll and Bute will be the first to come to me for consideration for inclusion within the STPR2. The projects will have to be looked at against all the other competing demands and the risks that have to be taken into account.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Will the STPR2, which will be announced before the election, identify what is going to be done, as well as timescales?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

It will identify the projects that will be taken forward in those respective areas.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So it will be like a wish list, but I presume that it will not identify timescales until later on.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

No, it is not a wish list. The wish list is the process before that, if you like. I will ask Fiona Brown to say a bit more about that. The next phase of that will bring all the different types of interventions through and we will then consult on them. As part of that appraisal, we will work that into a shortlist of projects that could realistically be taken forward to meet the purpose for which they are intended. That is what will be contained within STPR2. Those are the projects that we would be looking to take forward. It is not a wish list.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is the core work that you will be doing over the next period.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is helpful. Please forgive my ignorance.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I will push you on the STPR2. You have said that the Rest and Be Thankful has priority within the local Argyll STPR2 plan. Where will the Argyll plan sit within the national STPR2 plan? It may be project number 1 within Argyll, but it could be project number 8 within the whole of Scotland.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I cannot tell you that until the process has been completed and all the different competing interests and issues have been highlighted. We will then have to assess which projects to prioritise and on what basis. I cannot tell you whether it will be the top priority in both the Argyll and Bute plan and the national STPR2 plan, because we will have to consider all the various interventions that will be highlighted in Argyll and Bute and across the country.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

It is not that there are no guarantees; I am just saying that I cannot tell you what the priorities are until the process has been undertaken and we have completed a review of all the options across the country. As I say, I am sure that people would say to me that the A82 and a bypass at Fort William are priorities, or the work that needs to be done on the A82 between Tarbet and Ardlui. Those are all priorities but, once we have carried out the process and we have identified all the different priorities, we will have to assess which of those projects to progress earlier in the programme.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I am really trying to get some information for the petitioner. This petition is probably one of the longest-running petitions in the Parliament. From the evidence that we have heard in today’s meeting, we are no further forward. I can just imagine not only the petitioner’s frustration, but the frustration of everyone who uses that road regularly.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I would not accept that, because one of the things that the petition was looking for was greater resilience on the A83 at the Rest and Be Thankful. A significant amount of work has been undertaken to deliver that. It has not given them the permanent solution that they believe is the best option, but the red option has delivered greater resilience on the route.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Can you tell me which alternative routes are being seriously considered and appraised under STPR2?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The case for change report that was published last week sets out that it has been agreed that there is a case for further change in a range of areas in Argyll and Bute. The appraisal process will start to look at what those options are, and there will then be a public consultation on those options to arrive at the final shortlist. Can you explain a bit more about that, Fiona?

Fiona Brown Scottish Government
link

At the moment, we are sifting the long list of options to arrive at a manageable list of options that we will appraise. We are looking to publish the shortlists in May, and they will include the options for Argyll and Bute. We could share the long list with the committee if that would be helpful. We are undertaking that process across the country in relation to thousands of interventions, and we are getting that number down to the hundreds. Those will be sifted against the objectives that we set out in the case for change reports. That work follows on from the national transport strategy and the sustainable investment hierarchy, the objectives that we have for the country, what has come through from engagement and the strategic transport investment.

We imagine that, of the hundreds of interventions that we arrive at after we narrow down the thousands that are on the long list, there might be 20-plus interventions relating to Argyll and Bute. That is a similar figure to other regions. That is what we will be looking to publish in May. We will then appraise those options to determine which ones deliver us the best outcomes, as the cabinet secretary outlined.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

When do you expect that the tree planting that has been done will make a material difference?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Well, I am not a forester. I was going to study forestry, actually, but I chose not to, believe it or not—there is a bit of useless information for you, convener.

It is a long-term project. I am told that the benefits that we will get tend to occur in the 10 to 12-year period, when the trees start to take real root and hold the ground much more effectively. It tends to be a long-term project to give greater stability to the hillside as a whole.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

That is a very long-term project.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Anybody who wants to study forestry goes up in my estimation.

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning. I am sorry that I arrived late.

I am glad to hear that you are looking at the totality of the travel options into Argyll and Bute, because one of the issues that I come across is that the extreme weather that closes the Rest and Be Thankful can also have a knock-on effect on ferries—for instance, those to Rothesay or Dunoon. It is hugely important to consider everything, because people can be literally cut off.

I echo the frustration that I have heard when I talk to people about the issue. I am going to Dunoon tomorrow and one of the things that I will be asked is when there will be a permanent solution. It strikes me from what we have heard that that appears to be as remote as ever. Can you give any reassurance that a permanent solution will be found?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

In terms of an alternative route or in relation to the mitigation on the Rest and Be Thankful?

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am talking about any permanent solution.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The STPR process is designed to flush that out in greater detail and to identify, if there is need for a permanent solution, what that solution should be. To do that, in the holistic way that you just outlined, we would need to consider all the issues in Argyll and Bute around all modes of transport in order to provide greater connectivity in the region as a whole.

I say to people in Dunoon that the STPR process is a thorough, detailed and evidence-based one. It is open to the community to engage with it to shape what the findings and recommendations are for Argyll and Bute. I give an assurance that it is an open and established process that should identify whether any permanent solution is necessary and what that should be.

09:45

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

People see big infrastructure projects in central Scotland, such as the Queensferry crossing, or in the north, where the A9 is being dualled, and they feel—I think with some justification—that smaller, less significant projects such as the A83 and the A82 perhaps get less focus from the Government. How do you respond to that?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I do not accept that, although I understand it, because I hear it in most parts of the country. If I go to the north-east, people tell me that there is not enough infrastructure spend in the area. Local authorities in the Edinburgh area tell me that there is a need for greater infrastructure investment in the roads here. In every part of the country to which I go, there is a perception that other parts of the country are getting more infrastructure investment.

When we undertake major infrastructure projects, we must do so in an evidence-based way and target resources to deliver the best outcomes for the investment that we make. I appreciate and recognise the frustrations that you describe, but I would not say that one area is favoured over any other. I receive challenges regularly—almost weekly—from local elected members, including members of this Parliament, about the need for further investment in particular constituencies or regions of the country. We try to use the STPR process as the means by which we can identify the issues and challenges and the most effective way to address them, in an open, fair and transparent way.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am conscious of time. There are two final, brief questions.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

My question is for Fiona Brown. In your review of the options, how strong an option is, first, a new road up the middle of Glen Croe, and secondly, a tunnel through the shoulder? Those options were discussed in 2013.

Fiona Brown Scottish Government
link

At the moment, in the long list of interventions, there is an intervention to improve the A83 alongside its existing alignment, that is, in the glen itself—

Fiona Brown Scottish Government
link

I cannot say whether it is strong at the moment; it is an option. There are also options to the north of the glen and to the south, across the Cowal.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I will end the discussion on a slightly different note. We have had feedback from Argyll and Bute Council that digital connectivity in the area is very poor. The council says that that impedes the response to landslides, when they happen, as well as the ability of members of the public to access traffic reports. What plans are there to upgrade the digital connectivity in the area?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Argyll and Bute has benefited from the digital Scotland superfast broadband programme, which has significantly improved digital connectivity in the area. However, there is much more still to do, which is why the reaching 100 per cent programme is being taken forward.

Argyll and Bute is in the northern lot of the R100 programme, which is the subject of challenge from one of the bidders. There is a process in that regard, and I am limited in what I can say about the matter. The commitment in the R100 programme is that people who do not have full access to fibre broadband to premises by the end of 2021 will be entitled to make use of a voucher scheme, to support them in getting something to their premises—we set that out recently in Parliament.

We are making progress, but there is still more to do. The R100 programme should help to close the gap significantly in the years ahead.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. We have reached the end of our questions for the cabinet secretary.

The committee needs to consider where we go with the petition. We have heard a lot today, and we should perhaps take an opportunity to reflect on what we have heard, and give the petitioner and others a chance to respond to what has been said, before we make a final decision. Do members agree that, at a future meeting, we will reflect on the evidence that we have heard?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and his colleagues very much for their attendance.

09:49 Meeting suspended.

09:52 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 111
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  4. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  5. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 11
  13. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  15. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.