The third item on our agenda is to take evidence on the amendment regulations from Ben Macpherson, who is the Minister for Public Finance and Migration; and Ewan Cameron-Nielsen, who is a team leader in the Scottish Government’s fully devolved taxes policy unit. This is the first meeting of the committee that Mr Macpherson has attended in his new portfolio. I welcome him to his role and congratulate him on his appointment. Would you like to make an opening statement, Mr Macpherson?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014 Amendment Regulations 2020 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ben Macpherson SNP 7
- Bruce Crawford SNP 4
- Murdo Fraser Con 3
- Alexander Burnett Con 3
- Patrick Harvie Green 3
- Ewan Cameron-Nielsen Scottish Government 2
The record
22 contributions
link
Thank you, convener. I, too, congratulate the new deputy convener on his appointment. I am looking forward to working together with the committee for the common good of Scotland in my new role. For clarity, I point out that, as my entry in the register of members’ interests states, I am on the roll of Scottish solicitors, although I am not a member of the Law Society of Scotland.
The Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014, which for the remainder of this opening statement I will refer to as “the act”, enables Revenue Scotland to apply penalties where a person fails to submit their tax return by the due date, which is known as the filing date. In a standard house purchase, for example, the filing date is 30 days after the transaction has completed. The available data suggests that the overwhelming majority of taxpayers submit their LBTT—land and buildings transaction tax—returns on time.
However, where that is not the case, the act provides for penalties to be charged at four separate points, all of which seek to encourage compliance and ensure that taxpayers submit their tax returns on time, or failing that, as quickly as possible. First, an initial £100 penalty is charged if a return is not made by the filing date. Secondly, if the failure to make a return continues for a further three months, daily penalties apply at £10 per day for up to 90 days, which is a total of £900. It is to those daily penalties that the regulations relate. Thirdly and fourthly, the act provides for tax-geared penalties where returns are more than six months and more than 12 months late.
In that context, the regulations that are before the committee amend section 161 of the act to provide that a daily penalty can be charged by Revenue Scotland through a single penalty assessment notice.
Committee members will be aware that the regulations were introduced in response to a decision by the Upper Tribunal for Scotland that was published last July, which related to a scenario in which Revenue Scotland did not know that a return was due until it was submitted. In that case, the Upper Tribunal noted that, for the daily penalties to be valid, the legislation required two separate notices—a notice of liability and a notice of assessment—to be issued. It concluded that a single penalty assessment notice, as used by Revenue Scotland for daily penalties, was not sufficient for those purposes, although the information contained in the single notice was sufficient in terms of what each notice required.
Critically, however, the tribunal noted that requiring Revenue Scotland to issue two separate notices would
“serve no useful function in the case of many LBTT penalties for late returns and, where it is unnecessary, would be potentially confusing for the taxpayer and could involve him or her in making a redundant, additional appeal.”
The tribunal went on to note that, if the difficulties were sufficiently serious, a change to the penalty provisions might be required. We agree with that view, and we introduced the legislation accordingly.
The sole purpose of the regulations is to enable Revenue Scotland to issue a single penalty notice when a return is sufficiently late for daily penalties to apply. The regulations will not change the obligations that are placed on taxpayers nor the number of penalties that can be charged.
Finally, it may be helpful to the committee to note that there are two relevant overall scenarios in which daily penalties are charged. One is a scenario in which Revenue Scotland knows that a tax return is due; the other scenario is one in which it does not.
The first scenario applies when a taxpayer is due to submit a return associated with the three-yearly review of the tax position for non-residential leases. In that situation, Revenue Scotland will know that a return is due because of the effective date of the initial transaction that is contained within the original tax return. As set out in its letter to the committee, Revenue Scotland issues a series of communications to taxpayers in advance of the date on which a return is required and subsequently. All are clear about the daily penalty provisions. Critically, those processes will continue in the future, regardless of the legislation.
Under the second scenario, in which Revenue Scotland is not aware that a return is due, as is the case with the majority of LBTT transactions, it is, of course, not possible to issue a warning letter in advance of the return being made. Although that is the case, the LBTT legislation is clear on the requirement for a tax return to be submitted, and the act is equally clear on the circumstances in which penalties will apply. As such, taxpayers and their agents should be aware of the requirements that are placed on them and the consequences of failing to meet those requirements. It is important to remember that the data indicates that the overwhelming majority of taxpayers submit their returns on time.
Although I recognise that stakeholders have expressed concerns about the use of daily penalties more generally, the changes in the Scottish statutory instrument respond directly to a suggestion that was made by the Upper Tribunal judge, and they have been introduced to avoid potential confusion to the taxpayer.
I hope that that is a helpful summary. I am happy to take questions from the committee.
Thank you, minister. Obviously, we are aware of the context. You have talked about the consequences of someone not submitting a return. The Law Society of Scotland picked up on that in its suggestion that daily penalties are not appropriate for situations in which
“Revenue Scotland do not know that a transaction has happened, and a return is required until the return is submitted.”
Therefore, it thinks that such penalties might not affect behaviour in the way that the Government might expect. What is your reaction to that?
link
I am grateful for the contribution from the Law Society of Scotland. It is important to emphasise that the instrument is a technical amendment that takes account of the comments of the Upper Tribunal judge and seeks to respond to them in order to bring clarity to the legislation as it is and avoid potential confusion for the taxpayer with regard to the duplication of notices and the potential for the duplication of appeals.
Penalty arrangements, including daily penalties, play an important role in encouraging taxpayers to submit their tax returns on time. As I said in my opening statement, although I recognise and am willing to consider the broader points that have been made about the appropriateness of daily penalties in the LBTT regime, that would be a much bigger piece of work. It would require much more significant consideration and consultation, and a much more significant change to the penalty arrangements which were agreed by the Parliament previously. I am open to considering that, but the significance of the regulations today is to make the primary legislation as clear as possible, and to respond to the outcome of the tribunal.
link
Good morning, minister. I remind members of my entry in the register of members’ interests: I am a member of the Law Society of Scotland.
In relation to the minister’s point about the two-stage process, the Law Society has pointed out in its letter that the
“provisions within the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014 provide for ... a two-stage process”,
but
“The Regulations seek to remove this two stage process”.
What is the policy motivation behind moving away from what is in the 2014 act?
link
It makes it more consistent with other elements of the LBTT regime, which do not require a similar process. Also, as I said, it is about responding to the tribunal outcome, in order to avoid the confusion that there was in that case, with the risk of duplication of issuing a penalty notice and, thereafter, a potential for duplication of appeal.
In these regulations, we seek to refine the clarity of the process for taxpayers, in order to make sure that it is as clear as possible in response to the outcome of the tribunal.
link
The Law Society suggests in its letter that
“the focus of a penalty regime should be to influence taxpayer behaviour rather than raise revenue.”
Is it simply a revenue-raising measure?
link
No, it is about providing as effective a regime as possible, so that the taxpayer is clear on the situation in different scenarios; making sure that there is consistency in how the legislation is implemented for LBTT as a whole; and responding appropriately to the outcome of the tribunal.
link
Thank you.
In its letter, Revenue Scotland refers to Adam Smith’s “Wealth of Nations” and the principles of taxation as well as how the legislation applies to the principles of “certainty” and “efficiency”. However, another principle is fairness. The Law Society, in its letter, talks about disproportionate penalties. What does the minister think? How fair is it to pay a fine when no tax is due?
link
The Law Society’s letter speaks both to the outcome of the tribunal and to the wider question of daily penalties. There is a wider point around the appropriateness of daily penalties within the LBTT regime. As I said, that would require much more significant consideration and consultation, and a much more significant change to the penalty arrangements agreed by the Parliament. If the committee has further thoughts and wants to undertake further analysis on that point, that is something to consider, but the legislation before us today is about how we make the scenario as clear and as effective as possible in response to the outcome of the Upper Tribunal.
Just to confirm, is the minister saying that, in future, the Government will introduce legislation so that, if no tax is due, no penalties will be due?
link
For clarity, I am not committing to that at this point. I am saying that the Law Society has raised a wider point that both the Government and the committee may want to consider in due course.
Thank you.
10:15
The reverse of that argument from the Law Society of Scotland is true as well: were there no penalties, people would have an incentive to not pay their tax, so we need to keep the balance right.
link
I hope that if future consideration is given to the latter point, the question will be whether the penalty is proportionate to the responsibility of the taxpayer to submit a return: there would not be a way to make it proportionate to a zero tax liability, because that would mean that no penalty is applied at all. It should be proportionate to the taxpayer’s clear, legal responsibility to submit a return.
Can I check that I understand the issue of daily penalties? Those only kick in some time after an initial £100 penalty has been administered, so even if the tax authority was not previously aware that a return was due to be submitted, the taxpayer already knows that they have done something wrong by the time a daily penalty becomes due.
link
That is correct. There is, first of all, a process to follow for the taxpayer and particularly for the agent acting on their behalf, who has an awareness of the legislation that is passed by the Parliament. The system should be clear that the LBTT return is required to be made within 30 days of the filing date. If a return has not been submitted at that point, the £100 penalty is administered; thereafter, the daily penalties kick in after a period of three or, in effect, four months—a substantial timeframe for opportunities—
link
There is a grace period, after which taxpayers know that the daily penalty is due. That penalty has the effect of incentivising the taxpayer to submit their return—unlike what the Law Society of Scotland argues.
It might be helpful to go back to what the minister has said about the two different scenarios: when Revenue Scotland is aware that a return is due in relation to the three-year review process, a series of communications go from Revenue Scotland to the taxpayer, in advance of the return being due, and in the subsequent period. The £100 penalty would be issued at the appropriate point, when Revenue Scotland would also flag up the date on which daily penalties would fall due. That process is in place for the taxpayer, and their agent should be aware of the arrangements.
The legislation and guidance are very clear on the penalties that would apply, should Revenue Scotland not be aware that a return is due. Until Revenue Scotland is aware that the return is due, it cannot actively issue a penalty.
link
The taxpayer has a responsibility to be aware of their duty to submit a return.
Yes. The legislation and the guidance from Revenue Scotland are very clear on those responsibilities.
It looks as though there are no other questions. Item 4 is the consideration of motion S5M-20744.
Motion moved,
That the Finance and Constitution Committee recommends that the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Act 2014 Amendment Regulations 2020 draft be approved.—Ben Macpherson
Motion agreed to.
10:18 Meeting suspended.
10:19 On resuming—
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Feb 2020 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 4
- 10:00 Deputy Convener Procedure · 5
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
- 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.