For consideration of the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020, the minister is joined by James McLellan, who is the head of the fully devolved taxes policy unit at the Scottish Government. I invite the minister to make a short opening statement before we move to questions from the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020 (SSI 2020/24)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ben Macpherson SNP 10
- Bruce Crawford SNP 8
- James McLellan Scottish Government 6
- Alexander Burnett Con 5
- Murdo Fraser Con 3
- John Mason SNP 2
- Alex Rowley Lab 2
- Donald Cameron Con 1
The record
37 contributions
link
The Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020 provides for the changes to land and buildings transaction tax non-residential leases that were set out in the 2020-21 Scottish budget on 6 February.
The order introduces a new rate of 2 per cent for LBTT non-residential leases where the net present value, or NPV, of the rent that is payable under the lease is above £2 million. That measure moves LBTT into line with the three-tax-band structure for leases in the rest of the United Kingdom. It will raise an additional £10 million in 2020-21, which will be important additional revenue to help fund public services in Scotland.
We do not expect the change to have an adverse impact on the market. The Scottish Fiscal Commission’s analysis suggests that any behavioural impact from the measure is likely to be small, with fewer than 10 transactions lost as a result. Some 95 per cent of transactions will be unaffected by the change, and it will apply only to leases that are entered into after the effective date. Therefore, the new rate will not apply to any further returns that are made in connection with the three-year review, assignation or termination of a lease where the effective date is between 1 April 2015 and 6 February 2020.
The latest reports on the commercial property market in Scotland suggest that, overall, the market is healthy, and the tax increase should be set in the context of other financial considerations. For example, the cost of leasing in Scotland compares very favourably against leasing in comparable cities in England. We will of course continue to monitor the impact of the tax change.
The committee will be aware that this is the first time that the provisional affirmative power has been used in full, with the order coming into effect almost immediately—on 7 February, the date after the Scottish budget was published. We have taken this approach in response to feedback from stakeholders on the changes that were made in the budget of 2019-20 and to mitigate the risk of forestalling. In its submission to the committee on the changes in the 2019-20 Scottish budget, the Law Society said:
“We therefore suggest that it would have made more sense either to make the changes effective from Budget Day (12 December) or to make them effective from a date later than 25 January 2019 to allow taxpayers to take into account the impact on transactions.”
We have listened to such feedback from stakeholders and responded accordingly.
Even with the limited period of around six weeks between the announcement of the changes in last year’s budget and their coming into effect, we saw a forestalling impact, so forestalling is an important consideration. Introducing the change with near-immediate effect, as we would do in this instance, should address that risk.
I hope that that is a helpful summary of what is before us, and I look forward to taking questions on the order.
I refer to my registered interests in property.
My first question is to get an understanding of the operation of the tax rate. To be clear, it will apply if the rental value is £2 million if the lease is for a year, £1 million if the lease is for two years, or £100,000 a year if the lease is for 20 years. Is that how it works?
link
If the overall value is more than £2 million, the rate will apply.
So if the rent is £100,000 a year and a 20-year lease has been signed, which will take the total rent to £2 million, it will apply. Is that correct?
There is guidance on the Revenue Scotland website on how the calculation of the NPV works, but what you are saying is, in effect, correct. There are three stages to a calculation of whether the value of the rent is more than £2 million. The first is the NPV calculation, in which you apply a discount rate to calculate the value today—the present value—of the rent that will be paid in the future. You then look at the terms of the lease—for example, whether it is one year or two years. Finally, there is the amount of rent payable. If you do not know that at the time, an estimate is done. Those three factors combined provide the NPV.
On transactions being lost because of behavioural response, will it not be fairly simple for people who would otherwise enter into a long lease simply to reduce it from—say—20 to 19 years, and avoid the tax that way?
link
First of all, it is a sunk cost; it is not a recurring cost that will be onerous on those leasing for business in a cyclical way.
James McLellan will come in on the avoidance point.
We will look to monitor that. The SFC has calculated an estimate of what it thinks that the potential behavioural effects could be, which it has noted is subject to a high degree of uncertainty.
Are you able to provide more information on the 284 transactions that will fall into the new band? I would like to know what the ratio of annual rent to length of lease is, in order to see how many could avoid the new rate.
link
As officials have said, we will continue to monitor that. The analysis from the SFC is on its website, where the committee can look at it in detail. It is important to emphasise that the SFC’s analysis and forecasting propose that the new rate will raise significant revenue of approximately £10 million per annum for public service provision.
I hope that we share your confidence in the SFC’s forecasts for LBTT.
My question is on that same point, because I am struggling to understand a little bit. Mr Burnett’s suggestion was that people would restructure their leases. Those transactions would not be lost; they would simply be rearranged and, therefore, less tax would be paid. However, if I understood the minister and our papers correctly, the SFC is suggesting that some transactions would be lost. That would suggest that a lease that might have gone ahead will not go ahead. Am I understanding that correctly? Is that your understanding?
link
Yes, but the proportion is 10:1, in that £1 million could be lost in revenue from the leases lost, but there will be a £10 million gain from the change. The cost benefit analysis is clear. Again, it is important to emphasise that it would be a sunk cost for business at a time when Scottish commercial property is in a successful place and the market is buoyant, particularly considering all the external factors that have had an impact on the economy over the past 12 months and before.
The analysis is based on continued buoyancy and the fact that only very small amounts will be paid as a result of the change. For example, the additional tax payable on a £5 million lease would be £30,000, which represents just 0.6 per cent of the discounted rents payments. Even on a lease of £10 million, it would be £30,000, or less than 0.3 per cent. In comparison to the sums for those transactions, it is a small sunk cost in the process of the lease agreement, but there will be a significantly positive benefit in terms of revenue for public service provision.
I accept all that and, if there is an extra £10 million, that is great, because it can go into the police or wherever. However, I am still intrigued as to what those 10 transactions—which I accept are an estimate—could be. Is it a business that might have come to Glasgow but will go to Birmingham instead; or is it a lease that might not be renewed? I accept that it is a small number, but
can you give us any examples of what the transactions that we are losing might be?
link
The analysis was done by the Scottish Fiscal Commission. I would not want to speak on its behalf, but officials have had direct liaison with it. In order to help you understand its analysis fully, I will ask my official to speak to that point.
The published analysis that the committee has seen does not break down those 10 transactions by category. We can certainly follow that up with the Scottish Fiscal Commission and come back to you.
Given the data that is available and the small number of transactions that we are talking about, I suspect that it would not be possible for the Fiscal Commission to provide that level of granularity and accuracy. We can certainly take the question away, but I suspect that the Fiscal Commission’s analysis will show that it is a broad category of loss transactions that is made up by a number of the scenarios that you have set out.
10:30
The Fiscal Commission has made a forecast. It cannot possibly know the type of company that would enter into a lease at any stage.
Would it be fair to say that we will not know until next year how reliable the Scottish Fiscal Commission’s forecast is?
You never know; it is a forecast. Sorry, James, would you like to respond to that question instead of me?
We will have outturn data at the end of the year, which we will be able to compare with the broad forecast. It will be very difficult to tease out whether those 10 transactions were lost in all that.
Mr Burnett’s point is that, if we start seeing behavioural change as a result of the change, the £10 million might never come to fruition, but we will not know that until we see how the new tax rate beds in.
Indeed—it might be more. It is a forecast.
link
As an aside, minister, I was heartened by your characterisation of 0.3 per cent of the total cost as being very manageable, because that is the sum total of our budget ask to the Cabinet Secretary for Finance. I am sure that she will get that message loud and clear from you later today.
In relation to what you said about the policy objective, I take it that there is no broader policy objective, and it is simply an unadulterated revenue raiser.
link
There is a policy objective to bring consistency between what we have in Scotland and what there is in the rest of the United Kingdom. What we are proposing to do is exactly what has been done in Wales. I appreciate that in England, the rate goes up to 2 per cent where the value is more than £5 million, rather than more than £2 million.
The Scottish property market is currently highly attractive. For example, for a 25,000 square foot prime office in Glasgow, the rent is £1 million less over a 10-year lease than it is for comparable premises in Manchester. For a 5,000 square foot zone A retail unit in Edinburgh, the rent is £2.25 million less over 10 years than it is for comparable premises in Birmingham. Therefore, we have a very competitive environment up here. We believe that, in order to sustain the public service provision, which business benefits from hugely, the £10 million in additional revenue will help in the wider budget.
I emphasise again that it is not a recurring cost. It is a sunk cost: a one-off payment that is made when a lease is entered into.
link
Thank you. You have now said two things this morning that hearten me, because you said that it is a policy objective of the Scottish Government to bring taxes into line with the rest of the UK, which we would like to see you follow through on.
Was a business impact assessment done, or was any consultation undertaken, prior to the measures being introduced?
link
Yes. As I said in my opening statement, there was engagement with key stakeholders on how changes were made in the previous budget. There was also engagement with the Law Society of Scotland and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland on the matter.
The timing of the legislation and the process by which it was introduced reflect feedback that we had from stakeholders. There was no prior consultation on the changes to rates and bands, because of the forestalling risks that the minister set out at the outset. That is consistent with the approach that we have taken and the approach that has been taken across the UK to tax changes in this area.
link
When I talked about the rest of the UK, I emphasised the point that there is a divergence, as the 2 per cent rate will apply on values of more than £2 million rather than £5 million. I make that point for clarity, Mr Fraser.
Well recovered, minister.
The Law Society makes two specific points about wording. I think that you have seen its letter. Do you have any observation on those points? It says that the instrument should say “contract” not “contracts”. It also suggests making a change so that the instrument refers to contracts that have been
“concluded prior to 6 February”.
link
I have not seen that submission. James, do you want to answer that?
We have seen the letter from the Law Society. The legislation is as drafted and there is no indication that its drafting will undermine the transitional provisions that are in place. We welcome the submission from the Law Society of Scotland and we are happy to reflect on it for future changes.
It is good to see that a lawyer has now joined the Finance and Constitution Committee.
link
Another one.
Indeed.
As there are no further questions, we move to item 6, which is consideration of motion S5M-20926.
Motion moved,
That the Finance and Constitution Committee recommends that the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020 (SSI 2020/24) be approved.—Ben Macpherson
Motion agreed to.
The committee will publish a report to the Parliament setting out our position on both statutory instruments in the coming days. I thank the minister and his officials for their evidence today.
Meeting closed at 10:37.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Feb 2020 →- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 4
- 10:00 Deputy Convener Procedure · 5
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
- 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.