Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exclusions and Exceptions) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020 [Draft]

Tuesday 21 January 2020 Justice Committee About 11:45–12:00 Subordinate legislation 24 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

24 contributions
Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Agenda item 2 is consideration of an affirmative instrument. I welcome Humza Yousaf, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, and his officials: Philip Lamont, who is head of the Scottish Government’s criminal law, practice and licensing unit, and Douglas Kerr, who is a legal adviser at the Scottish Government’s legal directorate.

I refer members to paper 1, which is a note by the clerk. I also refer members to the late submission from Police Scotland. I invite the cabinet secretary to make a short statement on the instrument.

Humza Yousaf SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Glasgow Pollok
link

Thank you, convener. Please accept my apologies for the delay in getting to the committee meeting this morning. Thank you for rearranging some of your agenda to allow me to come at a later time than scheduled in order to speak to this draft affirmative order. I will briefly explain the policy behind the order, and then I will explain what the order does. After that, I will be happy to answer any questions that members may have.

The overall policy objective is to ensure that the backgrounds of constables, potential constables, police custody and security officers and armed officers are appropriately vetted in Scotland. It is of course important to maintain public confidence in the integrity of those undertaking such roles. The order provides increased flexibility for Police Scotland, and other police forces operating in Scotland, to use a greater range of information relating to a person’s previous offending behaviour when they are being vetted.

That will aid the decision-making process in relation to the appointments for such roles, as well as decisions made in relation to disciplinary proceedings against serving constables. Ultimately, it is to ensure that those who wish to serve as constables and police custody and security officers are fit to serve, and to ensure that constables continue to be fit to serve. It will also mean that the vetting of armed forces police will be treated in the same way in Scotland as it is in England and Wales.

In more detail, the order will allow all spent convictions that are received at any age, and all spent alternatives to prosecution when a person was aged 18 or over, to be considered as part of disciplinary proceedings against a police constable who is appointed after the date of commencement, and also in disciplinary proceedings against an existing police constable for convictions or ATPs given on or after the date of commencement. It will also allow all spent convictions received at any age, and all spent ATPs given when a person was aged 18 or over to be considered when vetting constables, police custody and security officers, persons appointed as police cadets to undergo training with a view to becoming constables and naval, military and air force police.

There are saving provisions that mean that the changes in the order do not apply in respect of a person whose application for recruitment is being considered at the time when the order comes into force. The changes in the order also do not apply in respect of existing convictions of police personnel. Where the saving provisions apply, the law as it is today will continue to apply.

The Scottish Government has discussed the changes with Police Scotland, which is keen for them to be made. We believe that the policy changes contained in the order reflect the reasonable expectation of the public that those charged with the substantial responsibility of upholding law and order should be held to a higher level of conduct and integrity.

I am happy to answer any questions that members may have.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am fully supportive of the proposals, but there is a significant “however” to that. Does the cabinet secretary acknowledge that, as the proposals stand, they do not recognise the current operation of the Scottish police service? The highest standards will apply to constables and those providing custody arrangements. However, given that support staff are involved in highly sensitive functions such as criminal intelligence, forensics, forensic accounting and information technology, and that there can be direct entry at chief officer level, the order covers only a portion of those who do sensitive work in Police Scotland.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I know that Mr Finnie will understand my views on this, given his experience. I speak with Police Scotland regularly to decipher where gaps may exist and it has told me that, after the changes that were made a number of years ago, certain gaps need to be filled. I think that Police Scotland has directly responded to the committee to say that.

John Finnie’s point is important, and I am happy to take it away and reflect on it. As he suggests, that issue is not something that the order will address, and he is absolutely right about the sensitivity of the information that is available to support staff. However, it is not only about the sensitivity of information. The reason why it is important to introduce the measure for constables and the others who I have mentioned is because of the powers that they have—in particular, the warranted powers—which support staff do not have. There are differences, but I am generally happy to reflect on Mr Finnie’s point.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I have a couple of further points to make.

There does not seem to have been consultation. The cabinet secretary says that there have been discussions, but why was there no consultation with the Scottish Police Federation or the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents? Surely, it would be good to get their ringing endorsement. Similarly, there are no impact assessments. A human rights impact assessment would have been an important element of the proposal.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I am satisfied, as is Police Scotland, that the order is within human rights obligations and, in particular, article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Correct me if I am wrong, but my understanding is that neither of the organisations that John Finnie mentioned has written directly to the committee. They had the ability to do so if they had concerns. Equally, they could have approached me about any concerns that they had about the order, but they have not done so.

12:00

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I would be astonished if they took exception to it. For completeness, do you acknowledge that what has taken place is not consultation? There have been discussions.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

There have been discussions, if we are getting into the semantics of it.

From my conversations with the organisations that John Finnie mentioned, I know that they have a shared endeavour in ensuring that the police force has the best people. It is important to say that, if the order is approved, it will not introduce a blanket ban. If somebody has previous alternatives to prosecution or convictions, the order will simply allow those to be part of the consideration. It does not mean an automatic barring from the police service. To get a holistic picture, the order is important. I often have differences with the Scottish Police Federation, but I think that we share a desire to see the best people possible in what is one of the most trusted jobs in the country.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

You say that the transitional arrangements will ensure that there is no retrospective application. However, it will be difficult to ensure that that is the case and that, for instance, retrospective reference is not made in some future misconduct hearing.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

The saving provisions will help to protect from that scenario. In future, if someone is convicted after the date of commencement, or if there are disciplinary proceedings, of course they can be taken into account at that time. The saving provisions protect people from the scenario that John Finnie mentions.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

I am supportive of the order. However, I am interested in exploring what has brought about the need for change. Police Scotland’s background checking and clearance are extensive, so I expect that it would have access to any spent convictions. You mentioned in your answer to John Finnie that there are gaps and those are behind the need for the order. Can you give more detail on the reasons why the change needs to be made?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

It is a good question. One of the easiest ways to do that would be to give you an illustrative example, to help to spell it out. Police Scotland was helpful in checking that this illustrative vetting example is accurate—I stress that it is illustrative. Say that an applicant is 37 years of age and that the police information reveals that, at age 17, the individual was convicted under the Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995 for possession of an offensive weapon, and received an admonishment. At the age of 20, they were convicted of perjury and got six months’ imprisonment. At age 21, they were convicted of assault and fined £500. At age 30, they received a fixed-penalty fine for antisocial behaviour and breach of the peace, and the fine was unpaid. At the age of 33, they got an antisocial behaviour and breach of the peace fixed-penalty fine, and again that was unpaid.

All that criminal history that I have just outlined is spent and the convictions are protected. As such, the applicant does not need to disclose any of that history, nor, under the current regime, could the applicant be penalised for it. That is an illustrative example of a considerable criminal history, and none of it can be taken into account because of the changes that the Scottish Parliament agreed to making to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 that covered employment as a whole. As I have said, over the years, gaps that are similar to the one that I have suggested became apparent when Police Scotland approached us.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

Are you saying that, in the illustrative example that you gave us, the background checks that Police Scotland would carry out might not bring that information to the fore?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

My officials can correct me if I am wrong, but my understanding is that the frustration for Police Scotland is that, although it would have access to and know that information from its criminal history databases and the police national computer and so on, legally, because of the decisions that Parliament has made to change the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, Police Scotland would not be able to use that information in consideration of an application.

We would all agree with that illustrative example. That is just one example; I could give many more. I think that we would all agree that the well-understood threshold that we have for other employment is probably not the correct threshold for employment by Police Scotland.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

Are you saying that the information would be available, but that the police would not formally be able to use it as part of the decision-making process?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I am saying that legally—not formally—the police would not be allowed to use it as part of the vetting process. If they did so, they would be contravening the law as passed by Parliament.

I should say that there are checks and balances. I look to my colleagues to correct me if I am wrong but, if somebody is rejected by Police Scotland, they can appeal the decision and it can be looked at again by a senior officer to check whether all the consideration that took place was appropriate. Potentially, there could be a legal challenge if the police had used such information.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

If somebody was rejected and they believed that they could demonstrate that Police Scotland had used such information to inform the decision to reject them, there might be an issue.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

As John Finnie and James Kelly have done, I confirm that I am supportive of the proposed changes.

To an extent, cabinet secretary, you have already addressed the issue of the proportionate use of the power, which I had intended to ask about. Although we are not talking about people automatically being debarred, the lack of prior consultation is regrettable, as John Finnie highlighted. You are absolutely right that the Scottish Police Federation and others could make representations, but leaving it up to organisations that might have concerns to spot that secondary legislation is coming through and raise concerns with the committee does not appear to be good practice.

You have said that you will reflect on the matter, and I strongly encourage you to do that, because an assumption appears to have been made that everybody is on board and therefore that due diligence has been done. We will see how the measure is applied. It is true that there is an appeals process but, given the potential human rights implications, that due diligence could probably have been done better.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I take the points that Liam McArthur and John Finnie have made in the spirit in which they were intended. We will reflect on those points.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am not in a position to argue with the list of offences that you outlined, but I am sure that that is a very extreme example. Would such a criminal history not already be picked up?

Paragraph 65 of the Government’s memorandum on the order states:

“Further, all their decisions are recorded; applicants who are refused vetting are informed of the reason for this (where police operations and the data protection rules allow)”.

That is an important caveat. The reality is that, as with refusal on the grounds of criminal intelligence, the reason for refusal would not be disclosed to the applicant. If they had a string of convictions, the police would just decide that they were not suitable because of their conduct, and that would be the end of it.

I support the tidying-up exercise that is proposed, but I think that the Government is gilding the lily a bit.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

Although I am not from the legal profession, I recognise that any potential for legal challenge needs to be addressed. In the scenario to which John Finnie refers, all that it would take would be for one applicant to think that they had been discriminated against because of an alternative to prosecution. I can see scepticism in Mr Finnie’s eyes. However, it would take only one such case.

As someone who has been a minister for seven and a half years, I say to Mr Finnie in all seriousness that, whenever there is a vulnerability that means that there is a possibility of a legal challenge, it is a minister’s responsibility to tidy up the legislation, where that is appropriate and necessary. I would not necessarily disagree with Mr Finnie’s assessment of the order as a tidying-up exercise, but I think that it is necessary and I look forward to receiving his support for it.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Agenda item 3 is formal consideration of the motion on the draft Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exclusions and Exceptions) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020. If necessary, we can have a formal debate on the motion. The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee has considered and reported on the order and had no comment to make on it.

I invite the cabinet secretary to move motion S5M-20332.

Motion moved,

That the Justice Committee recommends that the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exclusions and Exceptions) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2020 draft be approved.—Humza Yousaf

Motion agreed to.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We will have a brief suspension to allow for a change of Government officials.

12:10 Meeting suspended.

12:11 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Children (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 104
  2. 11:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 24
  3. 12:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 46
  4. 12:45 Children (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 30
  5. 12:45 Justice Sub-Committee on Policing (Report Back) Evidence session · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.