Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Restriction of Liberty Order etc (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2019 (SSI 2019/423)

Tuesday 21 January 2020 Justice Committee About 12:00–12:15 Subordinate legislation 46 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

46 contributions
Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Agenda item 4 is evidence on a negative instrument. I refer members to paper 2, which is a note by the clerk.

The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee considered the regulations at its meeting on 7 January and agreed to write to the Scottish Government to ask for more details on why they were brought into force just three days after they were laid, thereby breaching parliamentary rules. Details can be found in annex A of the clerk’s paper and in the response from the Cabinet Secretary for Justice at annex B.

I welcome back Humza Yousaf, Cabinet Secretary for Justice, and his officials. Graham Robertson is the Scottish Government’s electronic monitoring policy manager, and Craig McGuffie is a principal legal officer. I invite the cabinet secretary to make some short opening remarks.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

As members probably know, there is an existing legislative requirement for Scottish ministers to prescribe the equipment that can be used for electronic monitoring. We are obliged to specify that equipment in a Scottish statutory instrument as one of the stages of parliamentary oversight of the electronic monitoring service. In practice, we discharge the obligation by setting out in regulations a brief description, with, as members can see, the model numbers and equipment that can be used.

We always intended to produce regulations in January 2020 as a result of the introduction of new equipment in the forthcoming new electronic monitoring contract. This was a planned stage in preparation for the five-year contractual period. Before Christmas, however, we had to move to prescribe equipment faster than we had initially planned to, and we brought forward the regulations in breach of the 28-day rule. That was driven by the increased number of court orders that G4S was receiving for which there had to be electronic monitoring. At the time, we saw the highest level that we had ever seen in Scotland of electronically monitored court orders, such that, even with the decrease in the number of home detention curfew licences, which are monitored, there was potential pressure on equipment stock levels.

Our acting to prescribe a broader range of equipment meant that the stocks of new equipment that G4S had ready and waiting to deploy for the new contract would be used earlier, in conjunction with the current equipment. We believe that acting to prescribe that equipment was necessary and that it was a prudent contingency to ensure continuity in this important service, particularly in light of recent changes to HDC.

The regulations have no impact on the move towards the introduction of GPS. They do not enable any equipment to be used for GPS at this stage; rather, they allow for a slightly updated set of home monitoring units and tags with different model numbers to be deployed to carry out the same radio frequency monitoring that already takes place.

As the convener said, the regulations are subject to the negative procedure, which requires an instrument to be laid before Parliament at least 28 days before it comes into force. In order to bring the regulations into force ahead of the Christmas recess, we had to breach the required 28-day period. There is precedent for such an approach to be taken where there is a pressing reason for it. Of course, a breach of the 28-day rule does not affect the validity of the regulations, and the committee has a 40-day period in which it can annul them.

We wrote to the Presiding Officer to explain why we were unable to lay the regulations 28 days prior to their coming into force and, as I said, we informed the committee. I am more than happy to take questions from committee members on the regulations.

12:15

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I understand the case that you make, cabinet secretary, but it is a question of parliamentary oversight. The DPLR committee says that it is

“still ... unclear when exactly the Government were made aware of the potential shortage”.

Are you able to help the committee understand when precisely before recess the Government became aware that there would be a shortage, and how much time elapsed after that date before it first informed Parliament of the situation?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I must correct Liam Kerr on a couple of points. First, there is no shortage of stock. The stock was supplied by G4S, but staff were unable to use it because the model numbers were not prescribed in regulations. The new regulations include the updated unit numbers.

I have been told about the technology and why the new tags are different from the tags that are currently used. They are not new technology—they do not use GPS technology per se. There is no shortage. The issuing of court-mandated restriction of liberty orders was at its highest-ever level, and we faced a situation in which, although the stock was in place, the model numbers of the devices were not prescribed in an existing SSI—as members can see, the SSI that is before them literally specifies the unit and model numbers—so G4S staff were unable to use them.

In answer to Liam Kerr’s substantive question, I have here a table that shows the percentage change in the number of individuals who are under the electronic monitoring regime. The number of those under home detention curfew in November, December and January remained relatively static, in the 30s. The largest increase came as a result of court-mandated RLOs, where there were increases of 4.1 per cent in November and 7.4 per cent in December.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Forgive me—I know that the committee is tight for time. My question is simply this: do you recall when you were made aware of the potential shortage?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I am getting to that. My point is that the changes that I described started to become known in November and December. A submission was sent to me on 10 December seeking to have the regulations brought forward and laid on 17 December. We laid them on 17 December, and they came into force on 20 December.

I should say that officials had a regular contract meeting with G4S in mid-November. It was at that meeting that they were told that it looked like there was already an increase in November. Of course, it was prudent to wait and see whether that increase continued for the next few weeks. It did, which is why, in early December, I received a submission seeking to have the regulations laid sooner.

Again, I emphasise that that approach was prudent. I do not accept that there has been any attempt—as has been spun by members, Liam Kerr included—to evade parliamentary scrutiny. As I said, I am happy to appear before the committee, which is of course able to annul the regulations in the 40-day period if it wishes to do so.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Thank you. I am not sure that I suggested that you were attempting to evade parliamentary scrutiny; I appreciate that you have come forward to address the matter. Perhaps we can discuss that another time.

You told the DPLR Committee that the increase was unexpected, and I understand the argument that you have put forward. However, by way of example, I highlight that the presumption against short-term sentences was brought in last summer. One would have thought, given that the stated aim of that legislation was to increase the number of people who are out on electronic monitoring, that if that legislation was effective, there would be more people coming out and requiring these pieces of equipment. Was the situation therefore entirely unexpected, or could it have been better planned for?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

Again, I go back to the figures. To some extent, the substance of what you say is not incorrect: that the introduction of a presumption against short sentences would lead to a potential increase in the use of alternatives to custody. However, I have two points to make. First, we can look at the months immediately following the introduction of the presumption against short sentences. Although we saw an increase in August, September and October, it was nowhere near on the same scale as the increase that we saw in November and December. There was a much higher increase during those months.

It is really a question of a prudent balancing of risk. We knew that revised HDC guidance was coming through. HDC numbers are still low—there are 29 people on HDC this week. However, there was a concern that if the numbers continued to grow over the festive period at the rate that they grew in November and December, and if the revised HDC guidance made a significant difference to the numbers—which it has not yet done—we could be in a position where G4S’s stock, which would be needed, could not be used. I do not think that we could have predicted the increase in November and December. That is potentially something for us to reflect on in the future.

However, when we choose to commence certain provisions in the Management of Offenders (Scotland) Act 2019, we will not have to go through the process of prescribing the serial and model numbers in the future. I hope that we will not be in this position again.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am supportive of the regulations and welcome the number of court-mandated restriction of liberty orders. I am interested in schedule 2. Was it a requirement of the contract that the company that won the contract should provide its own equipment?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I may look to my officials to answer the question about the discussion that took place when the contract was awarded on the type of equipment that would be used. I reiterate that the equipment is not a new type of technology. Having asked about the technological difference between what is being prescribed in the new regulations and what is in other regulations, my understanding is that the new regulations simply prescribe an updated version of the equipment—for example, the frequency that it uses can go through thicker walls.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am very cynically trying to see whether there is any likelihood of the situation happening again. What is the lifespan of a tag? Do we know?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I could not tell you off the top of my head.

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

The regulations prescribe several different bits of equipment. The tags last for a good few months before the battery expires and they have to be swapped out. The home monitoring units are plugged into a power source, so their lifespan is a bit longer.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Is it longer than the duration of the contract?

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

Yes, home monitoring units are able to continue between contract periods.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

If the contract is renewed—if the work is not taken back into the public sector, which would be a fine idea, cabinet secretary—will the fact that G4S Monitoring Technologies manufactured the equipment and devices influence the contract decisions?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

No. When we take the tenders forward, it will be for those bidding to demonstrate that they will be able to provide the necessary equipment. There are no favours given to any company. A company will not be looked on favourably just because they can supply their own equipment. I will pass over to my officials, who have more knowledge of the contract.

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

During the procurement exercise, we set out the standard to which the equipment must be manufactured and providers come forward and bid for the contract. Some bidders supply the equipment in-house and others partner up with other people to supply it. We are looking for both the service and the equipment.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Can you explain why regulation 2(2)(b) says:

“omit the entry for ‘Serco Geografix’”?

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

That removes equipment from the previous contract. Prior to 2013, Serco provided the equipment. That is when the regulations were updated.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Is there a relationship or connection between the holder of the contract and the equipment that can be used in that contract?

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

Yes.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

No, convener, it does not. That means that it is a contractual requirement that the company that provides the monitoring service also provides the equipment.

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

They must provide equipment to do the monitoring, but they do not have to produce it in-house and can partner up with other people to provide it. In this case, G4S provides the equipment and the service.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

When I was Minister for Transport and the Islands, we expected that, whether a contract related to the railway or ferries, companies would have all the necessary equipment to bid for and successfully run that contract. I am struggling to see where this one—

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Maybe not, given that you have train-leasing companies. I am trying to establish—

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Let the cabinet secretary finish. Cabinet secretary, please be brief. We have fallen behind and have another important panel to hear from. If everyone could be brief, that would help.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

It would be helpful if John Finnie could get to the crux of his concerns, so that we can address them.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Is the entry for Serco Geografix omitted because it is obsolete or because there is a new contract?

Graham Robertson Scottish Government
link

Serco has no role in the current contract, so the legislation has been updated to remove equipment that is no longer used.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. Perhaps I will write to the cabinet secretary on that point.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

Cabinet secretary, for three reasons, I do not accept your explanation that you could not have foreseen the circumstances that required the regulations to be brought before Parliament earlier than planned. As has been mentioned, the presumption against short-term sentences was coming into play. In your letter, you indicate that, in December, administrative changes to HDC were coming in, which would increase the number of people released on HDC. Further, if we look at the trend through August, September, October and into November, the table provided shows increases in HDC. There are three clear reasons for an increased trend. It is a glaring oversight that, with all that evidence in play, you and your officials were not able to anticipate that the regulations would require to come before Parliament earlier.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

Mr Kelly’s attempts to spin the situation into being the result of our lack of foresight is mistaken for a number of reasons—largely down to his misunderstanding of a few of the things that he mentioned. I will take them one by one.

I already mentioned the point about the presumption to Liam Kerr. The table that I provided demonstrates that, compared with the previous months, the increase in November and December was unprecedented.

There are two further substantial and important points. The table that I provided also disproves James Kelly’s HDC theory. In every month from April, the HDC trend decreases. From October to November, there is a slight fluctuation of two, from 36 to 38. However, HDC levels remain at among the lowest levels that we have seen since the regime came into place. That disproves his theory that we should have had that foresight because of changes in HDC. HDC numbers in November and December were far lower than they were in July, August or September. The trend was decreasing—not increasing—so he is wrong on HDC.

There is, at best, ignorance of how the contract works. It would not have made sense to bring in the regulations before the award of the contract. Is James Kelly even aware of the award of the contract at the end of October? The conversations around the regulations took place in November. If he was aware of that, he could not have made the point that we could have brought in the regulations in September or August. Was he aware?

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I must stop you. We have another panel to hear from. Members might want to recommend that we write to the cabinet secretary on the matter. However, for the moment, I thank the cabinet secretary for attending.

12:29 Meeting suspended.

12:30 On resuming—

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Item 5 is consideration of the Restriction of Liberty Order etc (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2019, following the evidence that we heard from the Cabinet Secretary for Justice. I invite members’ views on whether they wish to make any recommendations in relation to the regulations.

Members seemed to have a lot more questions to ask, so I suggest that we write to the cabinet secretary. We should liaise with the clerks and members should decide what questions they want to ask. We do not have to decide on the regulations today if members do not wish to do so and if they want further information. The committee has until 3 February to report to Parliament on the regulations.

I am in members’ hands. Do members want to make any recommendations to delay the regulations and get further information, or are they happy not to make any recommendations in relation to the regulations?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I think that we are going over old ground. The questions that are being asked are about the process; I do not think that anyone has an issue with the substance of the regulations. I think that we should let the regulations through.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

I do not disagree with the measures in the regulations. However, it is extremely unsatisfactory that the session was cut short. Certain things that the cabinet secretary said in response to me were incorrect, and I was not able to correct the record.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We can write to the cabinet secretary and you can ask him exactly what you would like to ask him. We have another panel ready to give evidence on the Children (Scotland) Bill, and they have been inconvenienced—they should have been heard more than an hour ago, and it is already likely that their session will be cut short.

On that basis, do members wish to write to the cabinet secretary to get further information? I am happy for us to do that—we have the time to do so. We can revisit the regulations on 3 February. If anyone has any questions, please give them to the clerks. Do members agree with that procedure?

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am happy to agree. Members should also write separately.

Members indicated agreement.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you.

Are we agreed that the committee does not wish to make any recommendations in relation to the instrument?

Members indicated agreement.

12:32 Meeting suspended.

12:33 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 Children (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 104
  2. 11:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 24
  3. 12:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 46
  4. 12:45 Children (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 30
  5. 12:45 Justice Sub-Committee on Policing (Report Back) Evidence session · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.