Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Tick-borne Diseases (Treatment) (PE1662)

Thursday 12 September 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:45 Petitions 106 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

106 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome Alexander Burnett MSP, who is attending to participate in this round-table session.

Our final continued petition for consideration today is PE1662, on improved treatment for patients with Lyme disease and associated tick-borne diseases, which was lodged by Janey Cringean and Lorraine Murray on behalf of Tick-borne Illness Campaign Scotland. The petition was last considered in April 2018.

Our consideration will take the form of a round-table evidence session on the petition, in light of the NICE guidelines that were published in April 2018, and what the impact has been in Scotland. I welcome you all here today. The round-table discussion is slightly different from simple evidence taking and I am keen that we have a dialogue across the table rather than members asking questions and witnesses answering. First, I ask everyone to introduce themselves.

Tim Baynes Scottish Land & Estates
link

I represent Scottish Land & Estates.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I am the MSP for Caithness, Sutherland and Ross and deputy convener of the committee.

Dr Sally Mavin Scottish Microbiology Reference Laboratory
link

I am from the Lyme disease reference laboratory up in Inverness.

Rupert Shaw MBE NFU Scotland
link

I am a deer farmer and the regional chair for NFU Scotland in Dumfries and Galloway.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

I am the president of the Scottish branch of the British Veterinary Association.

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

I represent Scottish Natural Heritage.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. To my left, we have the official reporters and the clerks who provide the committee with background support.

I am very keen on there being a flow of discussion and exchanges of different views, and you should feel free to engage directly with one another. If you can help me with managing our time, that would be helpful. We have a good hour to discuss these matters. If you can catch the eye of either me or the clerk, we can organise the discussion in that way. Committee members have a number of questions to ask. Obviously, if your comments have already covered the question we will not feel the need to ask them all.

Our papers show that people have a whole range of challenging issues to deal with, and I am very appreciative of those who have come here today to try to do that. We appreciate your engagement with us.

The committee received a number of written submissions regarding the action that is called for in the petition from many of the organisations that are represented here today. Given that time has passed since then—that was in October 2017—will you outline for us what you see as the current position relevant to the action that the petition calls for from each of your organisations? We want an update on where you think we are in relation to what the petition is asking for.

Rupert Shaw
link

The NFU is very pleased to have been invited to contribute to this. It is great that a centre for expertise is being set up, or has been set up. The first point is that this is a real issue Scotland-wide. If you look at the statistics you will see, for example, that in Dumfries and Galloway we may only have 6 per cent of confirmed cases. However, one of the problems with Lyme disease is confirmation of cases.

In the union, we feel that the environment in which ticks can thrive—the optimum set-up for the tick—continues to increase. By that, I mean that ticks are happy in longer vegetation, ungrazed grass and bracken, and that the increasing combination of those areas in our uplands—the removal of grazing for much of upland Scotland—is providing an environment that suits ticks. The removal of livestock that would have absorbed the burden of the tick has coincided with that at a time when we are seeking to increase people’s access to those areas, without a strategy either to deal with the tick problem or to target information to those who find themselves either working in, or in particular accessing, those areas; often, of course, people bring dogs and other pets, which bring ticks back into the home.

Tim Baynes Scottish Land & Estates
link

We find very much the same situation. We are talking about upland land management, and stalkers and gamekeepers in particular are finding this problem. I echo that the ticks are moving up the hill. That is the common expression that you hear; the tick issue used to be something that happened in the damp, warm bits at the bottom of the hill and now, with climate change, they are moving up the hill and are affecting people, animals and birds at much higher elevations.

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

I agree, from a Scottish Natural Heritage perspective. I think that there is broad consensus on the issue. One of the key issues is the importance of balancing the health messages with making sure that people are still keen to go outdoors and encouraging them to go outdoors. There are key health benefits and economic and social benefits from that. The drive is to get more consistent advice out there and available to people on the associated risk, but proportionate to the risk. The partnership approach that has been developed to take forward that message is key.

A number of pieces of research and work are on-going to look into the issue, particularly around the spread of the disease and from a nature perspective on how wildlife is part of the distribution and spread of the disease.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

From the vet’s point of view, is there something in how we get that information out to people?

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

Yes. It is about awareness of tick-related diseases and tick problems—even simply about the public recognising what a tick looks like. Quite often, in veterinary practice, we have people coming in because they think that their dogs have warts; they do not—they have a tick, which we then remove. It is about getting awareness out there so that people know what ticks look like. A plethora of products is now available for prevention in pets.

Where I live in Forres is a tick-endemic area. We are lucky, in that we know exactly what ticks are. Children at primary school are being told to watch for ticks after long walks and nature walks, but holiday makers and people who are coming into the area are pretty clueless, to be honest. Public perception of the dangers with ticks is not good.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is what we are wrestling with. First, an understanding is needed; secondly, when people have been bitten, we need to ensure that the symptoms can be identified and diagnosed. That is a further area. Do you want to say something about that, Dr Mavin? Where do you think we are in understanding it properly?

Dr Mavin
link

From the testing perspective? It has been quite difficult recently in the media. A lot of misinformation is being put out there, which is not very helpful. I think that social media plays a huge part in scaremongering and misinformation. It is important that the real message gets out there about the effectiveness of testing.

Where we are in the Highlands, most general practitioners are very aware of Lyme disease and look out for it, whereas in other areas they are not so aware. The situation is definitely improving, but there is a long way to go.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We may come on to this in more detail, but there is the issue about having confidence in the testing. From the paperwork, my sense is that there are people who have lost confidence in it and, therefore, may be looking to other places for testing and that there is a confusion there.

Dr Mavin
link

Yes. At the risk of being contentious, there is a large number of patients who believe that they have Lyme disease and a good chance that a lot of them do not. Again, because that situation is perpetuated by social media, people go on and say, “I have this symptom, this symptom and this symptom; therefore, I must have Lyme disease.” When the tests do not agree with them, they are not happy. They then go for private testing to Germany or America, and the laboratories and the tests that are used do not have a lot of credibility in the scientific community. It seems to me that lots of people send their samples there for testing, which costs an awful lot of money; they get a positive result, which they are happy with, but the validation and verification of the tests are definitely under question.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We may return later to how we have confidence in the testing that is being done.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I want to pick up on something that Donald Fraser said. I am a bit concerned about the comment about advice being “proportionate”. No one would dispute the health benefits of outdoor access and all the rest of it, but someone who suffers from Lyme disease might take issue with that kind of comment.

Is your qualification about the risk of catching Lyme disease being proportionate in the advice on outdoor access made on a medical basis? Having contacted around 40 organisations over the summer—I am happy to share that correspondence with the committee—I found that many of them have concerns that not enough is being done. Some might conceive the message that you are giving out now to be very worrying.

10:15

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

The intention is definitely not to underplay the risks and effect of catching the disease. I guess that it is about the best way of getting the message out there about the health benefits of being in the outdoors. We know that there are great benefits to being in the outdoors and that it plays an important part in society. It is about getting across the message in a way that allows the risk of Lyme disease to be recognised so that people are aware of the issues and know how to deal with the effect of getting a tick and, in terms of getting the disease, the medical issues and following that up.

The “proportionate” comment was about taking the issue absolutely seriously but making sure that the other benefits of getting out into the outdoors are not getting lost.

Rupert Shaw
link

From our perspective, it is not just about concentrating messages on the risks or the potential for Lyme disease. Knowing that our tick population is increasing, we would like to see education being focused on prevention against getting bitten in the first place. Obviously, that would be expensive, but it would be very easy for those areas in which we encourage public access. I do something called conservation grazing for the National Trust for Scotland at one of its sites near Gatehouse of Fleet. We could have a sign up that advised people who are walking to wear trousers and a long-sleeved shirt, to avoid going through very long bits of bracken, and to stick to paths. I would like to see some effort being put into the messages on prevention. That piece seems to be missing in our educative efforts.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That would be a useful area that we could explore with the relevant agencies.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

My question follows on from what Dr Mavin was saying about GPs in areas where Lyme disease is more prevalent, especially in the Highlands, where they will look out for the symptoms more than other GPs. The Scottish Government indicated in a submission in 2018 that new NICE guidelines on Lyme disease would be sufficient to enable clinicians to make that initial diagnosis. Has that happened? Do you know much about the new NICE guidelines?

Dr Mavin
link

Yes, we refer many of our users to the NICE guidelines. We get a lot of phone calls in the laboratory looking for advice on the management of patients and we always refer them to the NICE guidelines. It is good that we have the guidelines now, because there is good evidence behind them and we are quite confident in the message that they put across. GPs and clinicians as a whole now feel much more comfortable because there is something that they can go to in order to see best practice.

Unfortunately, however, we see repeatedly that people are not given the right antibiotics to start with. From the test forms that come through with the samples, we see that they have been on different antibiotics from the ones that they should have been on. Also, we often come across cases where it seems obvious to us what the patient’s complaint is, but it has taken a while to be picked up, so there is definitely still a message that needs to go out. The NICE guidelines are good for patient management, but I would say that they are not much used as a teaching guide. More teaching is still needed.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

This may have been covered previously, but do we know whether Lyme disease is covered in training for GPs, or in their continuous professional development, so that they know what to look out for? It is all very well having guidelines, but a lot of GPs may not refer to them, may not know about the symptoms or may give the wrong antibiotics, leaving the disease in the body for longer and thereby making it more difficult to treat.

Dr Mavin
link

I am afraid that I am not aware of what is in the syllabus for teaching GPs.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I would quite like to explore that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is one area that we can explore with the Royal College of General Practitioners. We will collate issues from this conversation that we can flag to various bodies.

Dr Mavin
link

We are about to start a major European project called NorthTick, in which we are forming a network with colleagues from other North Sea region areas in Norway, Sweden, the Netherlands, Belgium, Germany and Denmark. Raising awareness is part of that project. We are planning to work with GPs in Highland as a start. We will hold educational conferences and measure the management of treatment before the conference and again afterwards to see whether it has made any difference. As part of the project, we are also looking to hold conferences for landowners and the different high-risk occupational groups to educate them on the risk of tick-borne diseases and what they can do about it. We have been given about €570,000 for three and a half years to carry out the project. A lot of the issues that have to be addressed will be looked at as part of the project, which is a good start.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

That is just GPs in Highland. How can that be rolled out to the whole of Scotland once the project is finished?

Dr Mavin
link

I do not know that. That will need to be looked at.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Perhaps looking at the gap between the NICE guidelines and other information is a role for Scottish Government.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It has been interesting to listen to the evidence from around the table and compare it to some of the evidence that we have heard over the piece. We have heard anecdotal evidence that, once you come down from the Highlands, there are GPs who will not accept that a patient’s symptoms can be Lyme disease because they are not in the Highlands, but we know that that is not the case. It is interesting to listen to the different inputs here.

Dr Mavin spoke about people searching for the diagnosis of Lyme disease. We have heard evidence of exactly that. There is a conflict because of a lack of recognition of Lyme disease in Scotland, certainly in the Lowlands. Those who are suffering are then seeking advice from what they would say are better systems elsewhere. In gathering evidence, we see there is a lot of conflict.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is not unusual for people to feel that they are not believed. If a condition is not recognised, and not treated, there are consequences.

How is awareness raised on a consistent basis so that it is not just at the mercy of whoever happens to be proactive in a particular area? Do you have suggestions about how that could be done?

Tim Baynes Scottish Land & Estates
link

We have tried to do that. For instance, we have included a bit of information about Lyme disease on the “Welcome to the moor” information boards that we have for people coming on to moorlands. There is a little picture of a tick to show what it looks like and some basic advice—”Beware of ticks”—but it is very difficult to know how much to say. One view is that we do not want to put people off taking access to the countryside, which is absolutely right, but on the other hand, we want to alert people to the dangers. There is a dilemma and we do not know what to say on the information boards that would cover it. I wonder whether we might work towards some sort of consistent standard advice that could be given to access takers that would cover both the dangers and, as Rupert Shaw pointed out, the best thing to do, which is making sure that they do not get bitten in the first place by taking sensible precautions.

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

The dilemma is making sure that the messages are right for the audiences. A lot of work has been done on the messaging. For example, work has done by the national access forum and the NHS to get the message out about the prevent, understand and treat approach. There is a range of means of messaging, working with different professional audiences, particularly those who work in the countryside. We have been trying to get the messages across for a long time to raise awareness and understanding of the issues. We are still working on consistency to get the messages right.

Rupert Shaw
link

I am afraid that I have a slightly different view. I feel that this is an issue at quite a high level. Among organisations working in the countryside, you will find the knowledge—and I have brought these leaflets in to give to your evidence packs—but at any agricultural show, for example in Dumfries and Galloway, where we have a large tick population in the uplands, you would struggle to find any information being pushed out. The information that exists is often action group leaflets, so if you do not live in an area where the Lyme Disease Action group is active and pushing information out, or if you are not seeing the Borreliosis and Associated Diseases Awareness UK leaflets, the information is not available, because it is not being put out on a Scotland-wide public health basis. There are just one or two actors doing it. There is huge variation in the level of knowledge. Anecdotally, there will be parts of my region where people will say that cattle can suffer red water disease, which is a sign of chronic tick infestation, but that is not read across into the primary schools to warn children off from going up the hill.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I echo that. It is about consistency. When we write to a lot of organisations, they will say that they produce some leaflet or there is some information available, but when you drill down into whether the message is getting out there, you find that it is not, and that is a concern. There are no consistent guidelines and there is no check on how information is being delivered to make sure that those whom we want to encourage to use the outdoors are receiving it. There seems to be no report on that and no analysis.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I was going to ask a question earlier and then thought that it was maybe a stupid question, before I remembered that there is no such thing as a stupid question. Then Rupert Shaw touched on it and I was glad about that. We are discussing ticks and Lyme disease in humans here, but could we have an example or two of how ticks can affect pets, livestock or other animals? I imagine that that could also be quite a big problem from a veterinary or farming perspective.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

I can give you some experience from practice, which is basically that Lyme disease is always on our differential list for arthropathies in dogs, but there is one very big difference: the lifespan of a dog is 10 to 12 years, compared with the lifespan of one of us, who will hope to live until we are 80 or 90. We tend to approach the arthropathies, or arthritis, as a group, so we very rarely specifically diagnose it. Also, most pet owning is a private arrangement and if we start testing for Lyme disease, or rheumatoid factor or all sorts of other causes of arthritis, that starts to cost the client money, so there tends to be a block on how far we would go with a diagnosis. We tend to treat symptomatically with painkillers. There may well be dogs out there with Lyme disease that we do not know about, as it is not something that we routinely test for. If we are suspicious of something that may be Lyme disease in a younger dog that has a temperature or swollen joints, we may well just reach for an antibiotic and go for doxycycline, which is the antibiotic of choice for tick-borne disease. However, that is not good practice, because we should not just be grabbing an antibiotic, as it is not a one health agenda approach. That is where we come back to the testing, because even the veterinary side of testing is not believed to be adequate and give reliable results. It is a very difficult position.

We do a lot of education in practice. If people from Ayrshire or Lanarkshire come up on holiday and they come in with a dog with ticks, we often use that opportunity to educate the public. As vets, we very much use our role to sell the little plastic tools to people and to say, “If you get a tick, that is how to remove it.” We do a lot of the background education because people do not know what the ticks are.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is appropriate to bring Maurice Corry’s question in now.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

This is a question for Kathleen Robertson. The BVA has advocated a one health agenda approach under which the relevant stakeholders can work collaboratively to tackle the disease, and you touched on that just now. To what extent has the co-ordination been effective between the different sectors? That follows on from what Rupert Shaw was saying about information on the hill.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

I am not entirely sure. We would have to refer that back to our policy group at the BVA to see how it has interacted with the other professions. Certainly we would be keen to work with the NHS on an educational basis.

10:30

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

You are not aware of any co-ordinated effort on this.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

Not specifically, no.

Dr Mavin
link

There is a Lyme disease sub-group that is co-ordinated by Health Protection Scotland. Dominic Mellor, who is a vet by trade, is on that group, so there are vets involved in the health protection message.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Rupert Shaw and others have made the point that there is not a consistent message and that you will get the information only if you are fortunate and have a campaign group locally. Who is responsible for getting s consistent message across? Where should that responsibility lie?

Rupert Shaw
link

My understanding is that Lyme disease is the most common insect-borne disease across northern Europe, which is no doubt why there is European money available to look at other locations. This is a public health issue. We have to accept that there are difficulties in diagnosing the disease, mostly because the symptoms could be a number of other things—it could be problems with the heart because of a range of cardiac issues and so on. Also in a farming context, an animal that is being raised as a beef stirk, for example, will be culled at two years old. We do not have a true handle on the amount of disease there is. We know that we have a rising tick population. I feel that the education piece is a Government responsibility.

Tim Baynes Scottish Land & Estates
link

It almost has to be, partly because of this dilemma of how alarmed to make people. There needs to be a very careful message and it probably has to come from the Government.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does Scottish Natural Heritage have a view on this, or do you think that it is broader than that and is maybe a health issue?

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

It is a health protection issue largely. SNH obviously has a role as a partner in getting the right message across but, when it comes to who has the wider lead, I think that it is a health protection issue. We all have a part to play.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It is interesting to hear what Kathleen Robertson said about issues with pets. Anecdotally, we hear that there is a rise in the tick population. Every time I come back in with my dog, I look him over.

You touched on how to remove a tick. I think that not many people understand that you cannot just pull it out—it does not work that way. There should be more done around education about Lyme disease and the problem with ticks than just acknowledging the problem. It is a growing issue.

The petitioner suggests that there are five genospecies in Scotland, all of which could be pathogenic, but there is no testing system that would cover all of them. What are the panel’s views about that?

Dr Mavin
link

That is slightly misleading, because one of the species that the petitioner is talking about is Borrelia miyamotoi, which is a newly emerging species of Borrelia. Borrelia is split into two types: Borrelia that causes Lyme disease and one that causes relapsing fever. Those are two quite different diseases. Borrelia miyamotoi, which has been mentioned, causes relapsing fever. Testing is developing for that—it is a newly recognised disease and it is still a relatively rare condition, but we now offer the testing in the reference laboratory. That is something that we have worked on over the past year because we are now funded; we are an official reference lab so we have more resources.

Dr Mavin
link

Yes, the work is funded centrally.

We now offer a molecular test for Borrelia miyamotoi that is mentioned in our user’s guide. We have written to infectious disease consultants and various laboratories throughout Scotland so that they are aware that testing is now available.

The other strain of Borrelia that has been mentioned—Borrelia valaisiana—is thought to cause very few cases of disease worldwide. It is very rare; although it is present in ticks in Scotland, we are not sure how much disease it causes. There are just a few case reports. The blood tests that we use cover the main pathogenic strains in Scotland and we are confident that we pick those up. We are not sure about valaisiana, but there is a lot of cross-reaction, so if we detect antibodies from one strain of Borrelia the likelihood is that we will pick them up from other strains, as well.

This year we have changed the molecular testing for the Borrelia that causes Lyme disease; we now cover more strains. We are confident that we can detect Borrelia valaisiana using our molecular assay, although that is helpful only in certain situations. If a person has a rash and we take a skin biopsy, we can detect it there. If a person has neurological symptoms—there is a range of brain-related symptoms—we can detect it in the spinal fluid. If a person has joint problems, we can detect it in the joint fluid. However, it is quite restricted to specific conditions.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Is Q fever recognised as a tick-borne infection in Scotland?

Dr Mavin
link

No. I am not aware of its incidence in Scotland, or even that it is present.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

My question has been partly answered. The NICE guidelines include recommendations for research, including in areas relating to the most clinically effective and cost-effective treatment options for different clinical presentations of Lyme disease, and on laboratory tests to diagnose initial and on-going infection and to determine re-infection in the different presentations of Lyme disease in the UK. Are you aware of any new research that is being done since the establishment of the NICE guidelines?

Dr Mavin
link

I am about to start some more research using the European funding that I mentioned. A few years ago, I did a PhD on trying to distinguish between current infection and past infection, which is the holy grail in laboratory diagnostics for Lyme disease. Nobody has come up with an answer yet; I am working on that. It is a possibility, but it is still unknown. Various groups are working on that. Using our blood test, when someone tests positive we do not know whether the symptoms from which they are currently suffering are down to their having recently been infected with Lyme disease, or we are picking up the fact that they were infected 10 or 20 years ago.

Dr Mavin
link

The result can be negative if the person is tested too early in the infection. In our experience, it can take eight to 10 weeks to develop a positive blood test. When people are tested early, we always recommend that they send a second sample later in the course of the infection. If the person has had symptoms for 10 to 12 weeks or more, the likelihood of a false negative is very low. That is the area that is disputed, unfortunately, by some of the patient groups. I am not saying that it will not happen, but the likelihood is very small.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I believe that the World Health Organization is doing a classification review of diseases and symptoms and that there was a deadline for submission, which has just passed. Has the Scottish Government, or have any doctors or medical professionals that you know of, made any submissions that we could ask the Scottish Government about?

Dr Mavin
link

I am a member of a European group called ESGBOR—the European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases group for the study of Lyme Borreliosis—which is a group of clinicians and researchers throughout Europe. The classification review was more about internationally recognised read codes that clinicians can use to determine the various symptoms of Lyme disease. That has been looked at by the group, but I cannot comment on it specifically.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I have a question for Dr Mavin. You said that a blood test will be most effective after 10 to 12 weeks of infection. We have had a lot of evidence that early diagnosis is key to recovery. How does that work with the 10 to 12-week period?

Dr Mavin
link

There should be a clinical diagnosis that should be relatively easy to make if a patient presents with a tick bite and a rash. There is a misconception that it needs to be a bull’s-eye rash: that is not the case. We say that it can be any spreading rash—so, a rash of more than 5cm. If a rash is spreading after a tick bite, the patient should be treated straight away and should not be tested, because of the worry that a negative result will come back and the patient will not then be treated. We press the message that patients should be treated early for Lyme disease without testing.

The difficulty is when patients do not present with a rash but with neurological symptoms. Education is still needed about that because, ideally, a lumbar puncture needs to be done because we need to test the spinal fluid of a patient. That is quite an invasive test and is not something that everybody would want to allow.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are being told that there is an increased incidence for all sorts of reasons. Do you have the resources sufficient to match your capacity to test with the increase?

Dr Mavin
link

Our testing numbers have gone through the roof. We have extra resources now that we are a reference laboratory. That has been great and has allowed us to accommodate the increase in testing. Because there has been so much media interest this year, we have been incredibly busy; it has been ridiculous. My worry is that that will continue.

I would say that 80 to 90 per cent of the tests that we do come back negative—tests of people who have had a tick bite and are worried but show no evidence of symptoms. There is a lot of worry out there among the public, so the minute that a person has been bitten by a tick, they panic and want to be tested. I can understand that, but it is a strain on the laboratory, because we are only a small laboratory in which there are only a few of us working.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is a challenge in getting consistent information out to people without alarming them to the point at which they create demand that makes it more difficult for people who are really in need.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

It is also important to recognise that not everybody knows that they have been bitten by a tick. I have had Lyme disease and I did not know I had been bitten. I had a rash that was spreading and I went through antifungal creams, steroid creams and all sorts with the GP, before he eventually decided to try doxycycline. I had been on another antibiotic. It is a trial and error diagnosis in many respects. It is also very important to say that not everybody is aware that they have been bitten, so we need to get that awareness out there.

Dr Mavin
link

We try to promote awareness that it is not just about the tick bite—the people who have potentially been exposed are a large proportion of the population. We would never say that people should rule out Lyme disease because there is no definite tick bite. The person could have been bitten under in their hair, behind their knees, on their back or somewhere else that they might not notice.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

It is important to say that although we have talked a lot about uplands, where I live we get ticks in the garden. They are not just in the hills and the uplands; they exist where children play, in parkland, especially in areas where the grass has not been cut. Where there is long grass, there is tick vegetation. That is very relevant.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You are saying that there are ticks where grass grows longer. Is that happening more?

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

Yes.

Dr Mavin
link

Yes.

Rupert Shaw
link

The tick has evolved to be brushed on to an animal: it has no ability to jump. The tick needs longer vegetation, which it sits on until wildlife—a deer or whatever—brushes past it. In the absence of long grass, there will not be a tick burden because they are not able to jump high enough. They are in lank vegetation such as bracken, famously. There has been an increase in such vegetation and unmanaged areas of grass—for example, uncut verges, which is definitely because we have seen cutbacks on such spending. We have mentioned uplands not because uplands are the preferred habitat due to their height above sea level, but because the NFU’s position is very much that destocking of our uplands and hills has definitely reduced the opportunity for ticks to go on livestock rather than on the humans who access such areas.

10:45

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Farming practice has changed and there are areas that are not being farmed in the same way that they would have been before. I have heard people in my area of Glasgow say, “We do not cut the verges anymore because it is much nicer if it all goes wild”, which means, “We do not have the money to cut them, so let us rationalise it somehow”. Does that mean that in some communities the risk is increased?

Rupert Shaw
link

Yes, if you create an environment that is ideal for how a tick operates—an environment that allows it to be at height on damp vegetation. We have heard that the tick is active above 3.5°C and in damp air, so Scotland and other similar northern European countries are the ideal habitat for it. The tick has evolved to be brushed on to a person or an animal going past. Yes, we are creating an environment that suits the tick.

Dr Mavin
link

A number of studies have been done. One of the most effective prevention measures is cutting grass and removing leaf litter. In our local town, they have stopped cutting the grass in all the parks and I am deeply concerned about that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is an important area to pursue.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I am glad that we have moved on to the tick itself. Have the witnesses heard anything about any work—we can ask the Scottish Government about this—on reducing tick numbers? While I have been involved in the petition, I have come across one person who mentioned garlic-based licks for animals, which result in the ticks dropping off sooner, reducing their lifespan and their mobility. Has any member of the panel heard about any work on that? Can we ask the Scottish Government whether it has done any work on it?

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

Some work was done about 10 years ago to look at the effectiveness of that type of method, but it was not conclusive. Small mammals are particularly important in the earlier life stages of the tick and larger mammals are important in the later stages, when the ticks become sexually reproductive. We use acaricides, for instance, to dip sheep to prevent tick infestation. The application of acaricides in wild mammals requires ethical issues to be considered, as well as the practicalities of how you would apply it and how you manage it, given that some of the mammals are food sources. There are quite a lot of challenges there, not least the effectiveness of the method.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I have a follow-on question about our habits in cutting, or not cutting, vegetation. My cousin worked with the Forestry Commission and he has Lyme disease. He is in his 40s and he is unable to work anymore. That is one element. I also understand that down at the track, when they did not cut the grass in the middle of the park, one of the kids got bitten and got Lyme disease. You are absolutely right that there is financial pressure on our councils, but not cutting grass in the park is creating a habitat for the ticks. It is as simple as that. You would not think that just some long grass on a running track would be a habitat, but it is.

Rupert Shaw
link

I feel duty bound to point out that the answer is not to cut all our grass, either. There is grazing by livestock—I mentioned a number of organisations that do what they call conservation grazing. There are other options. For us, however, it goes back to what we hope will be a key strand of what is decided as a result of this petition—prevention, through people wearing appropriate clothing and suitable signs being provided. There will not necessarily be money for cutting or grazing everywhere. We have to see investment in the messaging about what is appropriate clothing in areas where we know there is a tick population.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

This is probably a very simple question. How do the ticks get on the grass? We know that they shift on to animals, but in the very first place how do they get there? Are they carried by birds, or what?

Tim Baynes Scottish Land & Estates
link

They climb up the grass, or the vegetation.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Yes, but are they born in the grass? How do they develop? A caterpillar obviously becomes a butterfly. Is the tick something that is left, and by what?

Dr Mavin
link

Yes, they are carried by animals and birds anywhere. The adult females go into the undergrowth and produce thousands of eggs. Then they just disseminate, whether on animals or by just gradually crawling out.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

One of the awareness issues is about making people realise what to do when they have been bitten by a tick but not to scaremonger. You have 24 hours to examine yourself and remove the tick, because it is during the 18-to-24-hour window when the saliva exchange and the blood exchange happen that the risk is there. It is a matter of getting that message across. If you have been out for walk in an upland, woodland, or long-grass area, when you get home that evening, before you go to bed, check yourself. Social media would be brilliant at putting the message out to people just to check. The message is not that people should think, “Oh, I have been bitten by a tick—panic”; it is to be sensible about it. Last week, there was a big joke about the police grab bag. Why do we not have a toolkit for ticks? It is just about making people aware. There is a wee plastic tool to get them off and when you go for a walk in the countryside, it becomes second nature to have it with you.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I am listening to what has been said. Some of the petitioners waited a decade before they had the diagnosis of Lyme disease, which is obviously what has driven them to lodge the petition. I get a sense that, certainly since we have been working on this petition, there has been an exponential rise in testing and understanding of this issue. Do we need to look at the education of our medical profession and of the public with reference to pets? I know that the BBC picked this issue up in the programme that it made about Lyme disease and I think that it is planning to do a follow-up. Are we suggesting that the Government taking control of that sort of media and information stream is the best way to deal with the issue?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are coming to a natural conclusion. I would like each of our witnesses to make any last points that they want to make. If they had one ask of the Scottish Government to address the issues in the petition, what would it be? We have a sense of that already, but I will go around the witnesses one by one and invite any final comments that they want to make. Please mention anything that we have missed.

Donald Fraser Scottish Natural Heritage
link

I do not have anything to add. Communication and awareness are pretty key. We are a Government agency. We are happy to contribute to that messaging. Given what we have heard today, one of the key things is getting a consistency of approach across the piece to make sure that we get the right messages out there.

Kathleen Robertson British Veterinary Association
link

It would be very useful if the approach were Government led and involved all the stakeholders. If I were to say anything, it would be education, education, education.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Where did we hear that before? Happy days.

Rupert Shaw
link

This is a Scotland-wide issue and, therefore, I want the Government to take ownership of the education function. Media campaigns come and go, but this is an enduring problem for us and it requires enduring education. It should be part of the curriculum at school, and so on.

Dr Mavin
link

I think that we would benefit from a national strategy. I was involved with the Canadians, who have set up a five-year plan for how they will target Lyme disease, which is looking at education and awareness and the extent of the problem within the tick population—the percentage of the tick population that is infected with different tick-borne diseases—and trying to pull everything together. There are lots of groups doing different bits of work; there is no cohesiveness. I believe that having a national strategy would deal with that problem, but it has to be resourced—and that is the problem.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If we cannot afford to cut the grass, we do have a problem.

Tim Baynes Scottish Land & Estates
link

I echo everything that has been said. The issue is relatively recent and given that there is this whole horrible thing about ticks being bloodsucking insects, the education and awareness raising should be fairly matter of fact. We should say, “This is a problem, but ticks are not vampire insects and there are sensible things that you can do to guard against it.”

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I would want reassurance that the problem is not out of control or completely frightening. Without that, there could be unintended consequences such as people becomingly increasingly anxious and not going for walks, or, when they go for walks, getting anxious about what has happened to them and feeling that it is something outwith their control. We have highlighted an important issue, and the problem is more significant than I had realised, with the crossover between the natural world and the medical world. The issue is not just poor diagnosis, and we are hearing from the witnesses that there are practical things that can be done, that the problem is not beyond us, and that we can address the issue.

I do not know whether members want to add anything. We will want to reflect on today’s evidence, which has been extremely useful. I am grateful to everyone for coming along. The session has been useful for education, which we will reflect on at a future meeting.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I thank the committee for continuing to consider the petition. At the risk of repeating what I said last time, I would add that this is a huge and growing issue in Scotland, which we do not seem to be fully on top of. I think that there is a real responsibility for Scotland to get in front of this.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will address the issue again and look at what we will do with the petition. In the meantime, we could ask the Scottish Government to respond to the asks that have been made, particularly the idea that there needs to be a strategy. We want some comment. I do not know how cross-cutting the Scottish Government is on the question of the update of the NICE guidelines and their relevance to Scotland with regard to Lyme disease.

We will also write to the Royal College of General Practitioners to ask about training with regard to Lyme disease. We will want to come back to the area of prevention, because that is about where responsibility lies. As we have heard today, there is a range of areas in which one could intervene and it is a question of how all that is brought together. My sense from the meeting is that the Scottish Government is seen to have a pivotal role, so we will want to get a response on that.

Thank you very much for your contributions today. Having a round-table session is always a bit more challenging, but it has worked very well. We appreciate the contributions that you have all made. If, on reflection after the meeting, there is further information that you want to give the committee, we would welcome it. Indeed, if you are following the petition as it goes through the process and you feel that you could make further input, we would very much appreciate that. We can see that this is an area of interest not just to the petitioners. From what we have heard today, we can see that the issue is significant.

Meeting closed at 10:59.

  1. 09:15 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  3. 09:15 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  4. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  5. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  8. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 106

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.