The next continued petitions are PE1660, on a Scottish Legal Complaints Commission review, by Bill Tait; and PE1661, on reform of regulation of the legal profession in Scotland, by Melanie Collins. Members will recall that we previously agreed to join the petitions together for future consideration on the basis that they raise similar issues.
At our last consideration of the petitions, we agreed to defer further consideration of the petitions until the findings of the independent review of the regulation of legal services had been published. Although the review findings were published in October last year, the Scottish Government only provided its response to the recommendations of the review towards the end of June this year, meaning we have not had the opportunity to fully consider the petitions again until now.
The primary recommendation of the review is that
“there should be a single regulator for all providers of legal services in Scotland. It should be independent of both government and those it regulates.”
In response, the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs explains that views on that recommendation are “polarised”. The Scottish Government intends to issue a public consultation to inform the development of a new statutory framework for a regulatory system for Scotland
“with a view to introducing a legal services bill to Parliament to bring about necessary changes to primary legislation.”
The petitioners have provided their written views in relation to the independent review, expressing their disappointment that the review did not engage with consumers directly. Members have also been provided with a number of written submissions in hard copy from people with direct experience of the issues that are raised in the petitions.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?