Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Scottish Landfill Tax (Standard Rate and Lower Rate) Order 2019 SSI 2019/58

Wednesday 13 March 2019 Finance and Constitution Committee About 11:00–11:15 Subordinate legislation 19 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

Item 4 is to consider another piece of subordinate legislation. We are again joined by Kate Forbes, the Minister for Public Finance and Digital Economy, who is accompanied by Ewan Cameron-Nielsen from the Scottish Government finance directorate. Before we come to the formal consideration of the minister’s motion, we will take evidence on the order. Again, I welcome the witnesses to the meeting and I invite the minister to make an opening statement, if she wishes.

11:15

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

The order specifies revised amounts for the standard rate and the lower rate—the figures are in front of members. The proposed rates will have effect from 1 April 2019. Members will wish to note that they match the UK landfill tax rates for 2019-20 as set out in the Finance Act 2019, because we want to avoid any potential for waste tourism—that is a new phrase that I learned this week—to emerge as a result of material differences between tax rates north and south of the border.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

I am interested in the underlying policy and rationale for the taxation rates and in the Scottish Landfill Tax (Qualifying Materials) Order 2016, although I appreciate that that is a sister instrument. There is a recycling business in my constituency called Brewster Bros, which is an aggregates supply company. It recycles and reuses things such as waste soils and inert waste, which attract the lower rate of landfill taxation.

To put it simply, I understand that dumping soils remains—in the company’s words—too cheap and that the applicable lower tax rate contradicts the approach of the circular economy, as it is easier to dump soils. I appreciate that soils are less polluting than other materials and that it is unusual for people to argue for increased taxation but, given that we do not want to waste any resource, does the Government have plans to review the number of bands and the qualifying materials that slot into the taxation rates?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

We keep all that under review. Your point touches on the key issue that the tax tries to achieve two objectives—it is perhaps the only tax for which we want a reduction in the revenue that it raises, because that would demonstrate that the tax was having the intended impact of reducing landfill.

It is clear from the figures over the past decade that total landfill volume has fallen. The SFC’s forecast for the next five years shows decreasing revenue from the tax, which demonstrates the intended impact. However, in light of the objectives of the tax, we will certainly keep the rates under review. One reason for changing the rates this year is to ensure that we achieve the objectives—to ensure that materials are not just moved across a border but that we reduce the overall amount of landfill.

The example that you gave touches on the key objectives of the tax, which are to bring in revenue and to reduce landfill. We know that landfill volume is decreasing, which is good, and we know that the revenue forecasts are decreasing, which is—ironically—good. However, we need to keep an eye on unintended consequences and particularly on the impact on companies’ behaviour.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

I appreciate the minister’s point that the situation is kept under constant review, but will a more granular look be taken in the short to medium term at unintended consequences?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

That must be done in conjunction with the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform. She and Mr Mackay will meet again in the not-too-distant future to discuss how their portfolios are managing the tax to ensure that it reaches its objectives.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I neglected to bring Alex Burnett into the previous discussion—forgive me, Alex.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

My question for the previous session was answered.

We support the aims of the landfill tax, but an unfortunate consequence has been an increase in fly-tipping. How will the additional revenue go to bodies, such as councils, that have to deal with that?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

As with all sources of revenue, funds are redistributed to local authorities. I recognise that, on such an issue, a partnership approach must be taken with local authorities, because they often manage and do the collections.

The Scottish Environment Protection Agency has a key role when it comes to fly-tipping. It launched its campaign in the middle of last year to raise awareness of fly-tipping and make clear what the fines are for it.

Other public bodies in Scotland, working well together, also have a role to play. Revenue Scotland has developed a reputation for better compliance because it works so closely with SEPA. On landfill tax in particular, the levels of compliance are improving significantly because of that partnership. That is probably the key way in which we will get a grip on fly-tipping, as well as through resourcing local authorities.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

You mentioned the Fiscal Commission forecasts on landfill tax, which are based on a central assumption that the ban on biodegradable waste going to landfill in 2021 will be implemented.

You will be aware that, late last month, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities expressed serious doubts about that. It thinks that it is unlikely that the ban can be achieved in the expected timescale. If the ban is implemented, that will continue to reduce the revenue from landfill tax; if it is not, more revenue may be raised but the policy objective will not be achieved.

What assumption is the Scottish Government working on? Is it working on the assumption that the ban will be fully implemented in 2021 as planned? If that happens, revenue will take a big hit, but one of the consequences will be more recyclable waste going to incineration, which does not have a place in a truly circular economy either.

The UK Government has indicated that it intends to consider the option of introducing a tax on the incineration of waste. Is the Scottish Government considering that option and has it discussed the potential for a necessary transfer of powers to implement such a policy?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

There are a lot of questions in there, but I will try to take them one by one. First, I am aware of the points that Patrick Harvie raises. The ban has been set out in legislation since 2012, so it is disappointing that, although local authorities have had significant time to prepare, there is still uncertainty about the readiness of some councils.

We know that 14 local authorities have long-term solutions in place, including major authorities such as Glasgow, Edinburgh and Dundee. Other authorities have interim solutions in place. Our focus is on trying to work with the authorities that do not have a solution in place to identify ways to comply with the ban as soon as possible, such as using collaborative procurement and improved recycling.

Some of those questions are for the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform. However, I can say that our intention is still to implement the ban, as set out in legislation since 2012. That was reflected in the Scottish Fiscal Commission’s most recent forecast. We continue to work with COSLA and local authority waste management services to try to address that challenge. However, our policy still prioritises waste reduction, which is reflected in the forecasts.

On additional taxes, as far as I know, we have a rolling programme of work looking at further devolution of taxes and how we can improve our current tax regime. Any changes in the area have to be made in collaboration with the environment secretary. It is one of those areas where we can achieve multiple policy objectives if we work together closely.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Given that you are concerned about waste tourism as a possible threat, I presume that, if the UK Government looked at a wider disposal tax, there would be a real need for Scotland to have the power to do the same.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Absolutely. Again, it is about those unintended consequences as a result of having only partial devolution of taxes, when we have full devolution of environmental policies. If we were hamstrung by not having the tax powers to be able to control waste tourism, for example, that would significantly hinder our environmental policies and objectives.

Adam Tomkins Con Glasgow
link

I do not understand the language of being “hamstrung”. Ever since the Calman commission and the introduction of section 80B of the Scotland Act 1998, this Parliament has had the power to create new taxes; we already have that power.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

As I just said, the Scottish Government is carrying out a rolling programme of work on how we can improve our current taxes and increase the devolution of taxes. The point that I was trying to make is that, if we have two portfolios that are both trying to achieve two similar objectives, they have to work together and the tax regime has to reflect the environmental policy objectives.

Adam Tomkins Con Glasgow
link

Right, but, just to be clear, it is not about future devolution of powers that the Parliament does not yet have; it is about the Government exercising powers which the Parliament already has.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

It is about making sure that we use our current powers but, in relation to Patrick Harvie’s point, if the UK Government was to introduce a new tax—a good example at the moment is its consideration of a digital services tax—our priority would be to look at what impact that would have on Scotland and to respond appropriately.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

As there are no further questions, we move to consideration of the motion on the order, which is motion S5M-16045.

Motion moved,

That the Finance and Constitution Committee recommends that the Scottish Landfill Tax (Standard Rate and Lower Rate) Order 2019 be approved.—Kate Forbes

Motion agreed to.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I thank our witnesses for their contribution to the discussion. We will publish a report to Parliament setting out our decision on the order later today.

Meeting closed at 11:27.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Scottish VAT Assignment Evidence session · 122
  2. 11:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
  3. 11:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.