Good morning, and welcome to the sixth meeting in 2019 of the Finance and Constitution Committee. As usual, I ask everyone to ensure that their mobile phones do not interfere with proceedings.
Agenda item 1 is a round-table evidence-taking session on Scottish VAT assignment. I warmly welcome to the meeting Mark Taylor, assistant director, Audit Scotland; Charlotte Barbour, director of taxation, Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland; John Cullinane, tax policy director, Chartered Institute of Taxation; Professor Graeme Roy, director, Fraser of Allander institute; John Ireland, chief executive, Scottish Fiscal Commission; and Dr Paul Mathews, senior analyst, Office for Budget Responsibility. I am grateful to you all for coming along to help us with an area that might, on the face of it, seem technical but which, when you start digging, becomes quite complicated. I am sure that you will be able to give us a significant amount of help in this morning’s discussion.
I intend the discussion to be as free flowing as we can make it, but it has been structured around three themes. If you want to contribute, please catch either my eye or Jim Johnston’s eye, and we will make sure that you can get in and say your piece. We need everyone’s contribution to be as successful as possible.
The three areas for discussion are: first, how VAT can be assigned to Scotland effectively; secondly, the robustness and transparency of VAT assignment methodology; and, thirdly, VAT forecasting and risks to the Scottish economy. It is inevitable that our discussion will flow across those areas. If I feel that we have exhausted an area, I will move on to the next.
I invite Willie Coffey to start the discussion on our first theme of how we assign VAT effectively to Scotland.




