Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Budget (Scotland) Act 2018 Amendment Regulations 2019 [Draft]

Wednesday 13 March 2019 Finance and Constitution Committee About 11:00 Subordinate legislation 39 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

The next item of business is to consider the draft Budget (Scotland) Act 2018 Amendment Regulations 2019. We are joined by Kate Forbes, Minister for Public Finance and Digital Economy, and Scott Mackay, head of finance co-ordination in the Scottish Government, whom I welcome to the meeting. Before we formally consider the minister’s motion, we will take evidence on the regulations.

I invite the minister to make an opening statement.

Kate Forbes SNP The Minister for Public Finance and Digital Economy · Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

The spring budget revision provides the final opportunity to formally amend the Scottish budget for 2018-19. This year’s budget revision deals with four different types of amendments to the budget: first, a few funding changes; secondly, a significant number of technical adjustments that have no impact on spending power; thirdly, some Whitehall transfers; and, finally, some budget-neutral transfers of resources between portfolio budgets, including a modest budget redirection to ensure that we maximise our available budget. The net impact of all those changes is an increase in the approved budget of £3,576.2 million, from £40,505.9 million to £44,082.1 million. Members will have the numbers in front of them.

Table 1.1 on page 5 of the supporting document, “Scotland’s Budget Documents: The 2018-19 Spring Budget Revision to the Budget (Scotland) Act for the year ending 31 March 2019”, shows the approved budgets following the autumn budget revision and the changes sought in the spring budget revision. The supporting document to the spring budget revision and the brief guide that was prepared by my officials provide background on those changes.

The first set of changes reduces the budget slightly by £3.3 million and comprises funding that has been allocated over a number of lines, as detailed in the brief guide, and is offset by the repayment of £175 million of farmers loans financial transactions. The second and most significant set of changes comprises a number of large technical adjustments to the budget. Those technical adjustments are mainly non-cash and therefore budget neutral, as they cannot be redeployed to support discretionary spend elsewhere, and have a net positive impact of £3,303.8 million on the overall aggregate position. It is necessary to reflect those adjustments to ensure that the budget is consistent with the accounting requirements and with the final outturn that will be reported in the annual accounts.

11:00

By far the largest of those adjustments relates to an increase to the annually managed expenditure provision for future national health service and teachers’ pension costs, which flows from the outcome of the appeal court ruling on the judicial pension scheme and firefighters’ pension scheme discrimination claims. The ruling has significant implications for future costs of unfunded schemes and we have had to adjust the non-cash AME budget by £2.3 billion to meet the potential future costs of remedy. The UK Government is expected to appeal the case further and, although the final position is not likely to be resolved for some time, the adjustment is made on the basis of legal opinion on the probability of a successful appeal.

With regard to Whitehall transfers and allocations, there is a net positive impact on the budget from a number of transfers of £275.7 million, the most significant of which are the transfers of £157.3 million from the Department for Work and Pensions to fund the devolved responsibility for carers allowance and £78 million from the Treasury in respect of the agenda for change health pay award.

The final part of the budget revision concerns the transfer of funds within and between portfolios, with which committee members will be familiar, to better align the budgets with profiled spend. The main transfers between portfolios are noted in the supporting document and the guide.

As we approach the financial year end, we will continue, in line with our normal practice, to monitor forecast outturn against budget and, wherever possible, seek to utilise any emerging underspend to ensure that we make optimum use of the resources that are available this year and manage the necessary carry forward to meet additional spending commitments, as disclosed in our draft spending plans.

In line with the budget process review group’s recommendations, my officials have included in the brief guide that was sent to the committee an indication of the forecast outturn position at 31 January. That is the latest position that was available when the brief guide was prepared and it has, I hope, given the committee the best view of the emerging position. Provisional outturn figures will be announced by the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work in early June. I hope that colleagues have found the guide helpful, although, as always, we are open to suggestions of ways to make it even more helpful.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I will start off on that point. It is helpful that the guide was introduced as part of the budget process review and that the information is now available. You will appreciate that there is still a challenge for the committee, whether in the area of underspends or the Scotland reserve, given the continually moving picture, although we appreciate why that is the case. In order to carry out our scrutiny role more effectively, when the final balance of, for instance, the reserve is published in June, will you be able to provide the committee with a table that details all the movements in the reserve throughout the year, to make the information available to us? Although I recognise that more movement may yet transpire, can you say at this stage how much of the reserve will be available to meet any of the potential shortfall that may come from the reconciliation process in relation to income tax and the fully devolved taxes once the outturn figures are available in July, which will be an important moment?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

In principle, I am happy to provide the committee with the final figures. With regard to the committee getting its head round the figures that are in front of us, members will be aware that the position changes regularly. We were keen to give you the most up-to-date position, but we recognise that it means that reconciliation can be a challenge. I am happy to commit to provide more information.

You mentioned the devolved taxes and the need for reconciliation. With the first reconciliation due next year, as the brief guide states, part of the forecast residual balance is devolved taxes income of £136.2 million, to ensure that we are prepared for reconciliation.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

Is the £136.2 million in the reserve for that purpose, if it turns out that the estimate is correct?

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

That is the forecast of the surplus tax receipts that we are holding in the reserve.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Good morning, minister. Following up on the convener’s question, I am looking at the forecast residual balance for 2019-20 in the table in annex C of the brief guide. The forecast balance of £300.2 million is broken down in that table. You have just explained the £136 million of devolved taxes income. There is also £85.5 million of balance set aside to fund spending commitments. Can you explain what those spending commitments are?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Yes. Members will be aware of recent coverage of the teachers’ pay dispute. The balance that is set aside for future spending commitments will likely be used to support known pressures such as the teachers’ pay agreement.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So it is not tied to a specific ask at the moment but is a kind of float to deal with things that might arise in future.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

In the spirit of managing our finances prudently, we recognise that, during the year, there will be emerging challenges that need to be met. That is reflected in the residual balance.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you. I have one more question. The figure for financial transactions is £78.5 million. Where does that arise from? Is it Treasury Barnett consequentials?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

After allowing for additional spending commitments of £47.5 million in 2019-20, those financial transactions are—

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

Principally, it is repayments of farmers’ loans that are going into that balance.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I presume that there are restrictions on what that money can be used for.

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

Yes, and activity is in hand to explore how we can best deploy it in 2019-20.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

I have a small question on the residual balance in the reserve. Does the £300 million include the £54 million that was transferred to the reserve as part of the information that was released by the cabinet secretary at stage 3 of the budget?

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

That is the balance of the additional consequentials that were received very late on as a result of the UK supplementary estimate. We tried to show the net position in that table, so the £300 million effectively includes that remaining balance.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

That is clear. It is obviously included in one of the other lines, so where is it?

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

Under the 2019-20 spending commitments, the table shows the £313.5 million of expenditure commitments in the budget bill and the stage 2 additional funding of £94 million, which gives £407.5 million. We have brought in those late additional budget consequentials, offsetting them against the additional spending commitments, which leaves the pot that is shown at the bottom of that section. We brought in the full amount to arrive at the remaining balance.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

I am not trying to be awkward; I just want to understand it. You say that you have “brought in” that amount, so where is the £54 million included in the table?

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

It is the difference between the £148 million that was brought in and the £94 million that was already allocated. The balance of £54 million is effectively supporting wider expenditure. The way that it is reflected is that it just comes down into the balance.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

It has been deducted from that line. Okay, that is fine.

In terms of portfolio movements, there was £43 million of underspend or credit in relation to capital housing receipts. Can you give us the background to that?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

That is income from repayments of financial transactions for the year. They are shown as negative expenditure, so they look like a reduction in expenditure. They are currently estimated at £43 million, which is made up of £29 million of shared equity receipts, £10 million of charitable bond receipts and £4 million of other FT receipts. Estimates for the year have been made from the various trends to date and known scheduled repayments.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

It is income from repayments of FTs, so it is shown as negative expenditure. It looks like a reduction in expenditure, but it is presentational in terms of it being income from repayments of FTs.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

Sorry but, if it is income, I still do not understand why it is being shown as a negative.

Scott Mackay Scottish Government
link

That is just the way that income is shown; it is reflected as a minus. The idea is that the income offsets expenditure, so it allows further expenditure.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow
link

Okay—I understand.

In the enterprise budget, a £56 million underspend has been released elsewhere. What is the reason for that?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

I will go into detail on that. It is a mix of transfers, so I will go through each aspect. On the resource reductions, there is £6 million of underspend in relation to enterprise zones, as a result of the full construction and operation contract not being expected to be in place between Scottish Enterprise and Strathclyde until after a stage 4 review in late January 2019, which was later than initially forecast. That is offset by £5 million, which was deployed to the innovation and industries programme to cover the costs of a fire recovery fund.

In terms of the capital financial transactions, there is a reduction of £55 million, which is a release of £28 million of emerging or planned underspend in FTs in relation to the Scottish-European growth co-investment project and the European investment fund; and there is another £25 million of FTs that is a transfer to the communities and local government portfolio in relation to investment in the Scottish partnership for regeneration in urban centres—or SPRUCE, as it is more commonly known. That transfer of funds is for the first building Scotland fund investment into SPRUCE, which is seeking to complete a number of commercial and industrial property investments by using that investment this year.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I want to ask about the £3 million receipt from the UK Treasury for policing for the presidential visit. Is that a fair and accurate estimate of the policing costs for that visit? Do we have to claim that? I remember a bit of discussion about whether Police Scotland was able to reclaim that money.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

It is a Whitehall or UK Government Treasury transfer to cover those costs. You will remember some of the noises at the time of the presidential visit. I cannot remember what cabinet secretary it was who wrote to say that, as the presidential visit was not at the Scottish Government’s invitation, the costs should be covered by the Treasury. The transfer recognises that commitment.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

As there are no other questions, we move to item 3, which is consideration of the motion. I invite the minister to move motion S5M-16046.

Motion moved,

That the Finance and Constitution Committee recommends that the Budget (Scotland) Act 2018 Amendment Regulations 2019 draft be approved.—Kate Forbes

Motion agreed to.

Bruce Crawford SNP The Convener · Stirling
link

I thank the witnesses for their contribution. It was a useful discussion and we will publish a report to the Parliament later today setting out our decision.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Scottish VAT Assignment Evidence session · 122
  2. 11:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
  3. 11:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.