The next petition for consideration is PE1704, by Duncan MacGillivray, on improving targets and outcomes for autistic people in Scotland. The clerk’s note provides a detailed summary of the submissions received since our first consideration of the petition in September. Those submissions are included in our meeting papers. Members have before them a copy of the petitioner’s response to those submissions. His response is also available on the petition web page.
In his submission, the petitioner states that he was
“very disheartened at the poor response from other stakeholders”,
noting that only 12 of the 32 local authorities responded to the committee’s call for their views on the action called for in the petition. He adds that the content of those 12 responses highlights the
“great disparity across Scotland in the nature and quality of autism support and services”.
The petitioner also considers that some of the responses from local authorities were defensive. He notes that many of those who responded referred to assessment processes that have
“promising titles but ... are vague and unclear in what they actually mean or entail”
and which are also unclear in terms of an indication of their effectiveness. He considers that it must be acknowledged that views from service providers have a bias towards their own positive portrayal.
The petitioner notes that a number of responses acknowledged that there require to be
“real measurements of the impact of the Scottish Autism strategy”,
and he considers that the provision of carer needs has been affected by the Carers (Scotland) Act 2016, which allows local authorities discretion to assess criteria for support. He refers to that as
“a subtle but highly significant change in supporting carers and families”
that has, in his experience,
“produced a reduction in support”.
The petitioner also highlights his concern that service users and autistic people appear to have a lack of voice. He provides an example of autism strategy events being scheduled in venues and at times that were prohibitive in terms of the ability of parents, service users and carers to attend. He also observes that, where it was possible to attend events, those events
“were always top heavy with professionals”.
Other issues that the petitioner identifies in his submission include concerns that there are insufficient resources across local authorities to provide the required level of support, which is exacerbated by a shortage of educational psychologists as well as a lack of courses to increase the numbers of those professionals.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
