The next continued petition is PE1693, by Graeme Harvey on behalf of the Lowland Canals Association, on an independent water ombudsman. We first considered the petition in September, and we have a note from the clerk that summarises the submissions that have been received following that meeting.
The submissions from the Inland Waterways Association and the Royal Yachting Association Scotland express some support for the establishment of an independent water ombudsman as called for in the petition. The Inland Waterways Association expresses its support on the basis that the Waterways Ombudsman carried out the function between 2005 and 2012. The Royal Yachting Association considers that there is an argument for the establishment of an independent water ombudsman, but with a broader remit than that proposed in the petition.
Both submissions consider that current Scottish Government funding is not sufficient for Scottish Canals to carry out its functions efficiently. The Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity’s submission addresses those concerns, highlighting the additional funding that has been provided to Scottish Canals in recent years.
Scottish Canals and the Scottish Waterways Trust do not support the action that is called for in the petition, on the basis that it will result in an additional layer of regulation and is not the best use of public money at this time. The cabinet secretary indicates that the Scottish Government does not consider the establishment of an independent ombudsman to be the most appropriate way to address the petitioner’s concerns. He adds that, although no specific cost analysis has been undertaken, significant resource is likely to be required to set up and run such a body.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
