The next item on the agenda is consideration of continued petitions. Petition PE1652, by Irene Baillie, which we last considered in November 2017, is on abusive and threatening communication. The petition calls for a change in the law with regard to abusive and threatening communications sent from a mobile phone, to deem the owner of the phone responsible for any communications sent from that device.
The clerk’s note provides a summary of the current position, following Lord Bracadale’s review of hate crime legislation in Scotland and the subsequent debate held in Parliament in June 2018. The Scottish Government has recently launched its consultation on Lord Bracadale’s recommendations, which closes on 24 February 2019.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
There is merit in waiting for the conclusion of the consultation. I would be loth to close the petition at this time. In the first instance, we should contact the Scottish Government to seek information on whether the conclusions of Lord Bracadale’s review address the call for action in the petition. The petitioner clearly has a valid argument. We may all have been subject to such communication in this occupation. I have a lot of sympathy with the petition.
I was interested in what Lord Bracadale said about online activity and the need to prove who had sent messages to meet the requirement for corroboration. He specifically said that that posed challenges. However, the review goes on to state:
“The question of whether corroboration should be abolished generally, and whether any safeguards would be needed if that were to happen, is currently with Ministers.”
It is important that we do not close the petition until there is further consideration of that as part of the consultation and ministers have been given the opportunity to comment on it.
We want to highlight to the Scottish Government that although we are not clear whether the consultation will address any of the detail of the petition, it should be alive to the petition.
I am interested in what would happen in similar circumstances in other parts of the United Kingdom. I can see the logic of deeming a person to be responsible if there is consistent behaviour over time from their mobile phone to your mobile phone. However, if a coercive person has taken your mobile phone and is using it to send messages to somebody else, you would be liable for that. I am sympathetic to the petitioner’s case, but we need to tease out which part of the issue is a result of Scots law and which part is because it is a complicated crime that is difficult to deal with.
Are we agreed that we should not close the petition until the consultation is closed and that we will write to the Scottish Government on the issues that we have highlighted?
Clearly, the corroboration issue is the salient point. I think that we are still waiting for the petitioner to comment on the final report of the independent review. It would be good to get the petitioner’s view on that.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.