Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

National Scenic Areas (PE1655)

Thursday 22 March 2018 Public Petitions Committee About 09:45–10:00 Petitions 18 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

18 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition is PE1655, by Christine Metcalfe on behalf of Avich and Kilchrenan community council, on Scotland’s national scenic areas. When we considered the petition on 14 September, we took evidence from the petitioner and agreed to write to the Scottish Government, Scottish Natural Heritage and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. The written submissions that have been received are included in our meeting papers.

The Scottish Government states that it has no plans to review either the process for designating or the extent of national scenic areas. In response to the committee’s question about how, or whether, its policy on wind farms affects its position with regard to national scenic areas, the Scottish Government states that its policy is to support the deployment of onshore wind while protecting the environment. It adds, in response to a suggestion that Parliament be regularly updated on the cumulative impact of wind farms, that it considers that this is not something that could be

“readily or meaningfully quantified as a national impact for reporting purposes.”

Scottish Natural Heritage acknowledges some of the issues that are raised in the petition, including that the current suite of 40 national scenic areas remains as it was originally designated. It acknowledges that NSAs represent an important natural asset, but notes that one purpose of the designation is

“intended to manage landscape change, not prohibit development.”

It considers that reviewing or revisiting the existing suite of NSAs is not a priority at the present time.

In their first submission in response, the petitioners express their surprise at the Scottish Government’s position. They argue that to use an energy policy as a reason not to review the current process for designating NSAs is irrelevant, particularly as pressure on the landscape from wind farms

“would not have been envisioned in the 1970s.”

The petitioners consider that Scottish Natural Heritage’s ability to fulfil its task in this context has been “seriously weakened”, and say that they believe that there is much to be gained in terms of economic, environmental and social benefits by having more NSAs and national parks.

In their more recent submission, the petitioners refer to a report by Mountaineering Scotland, which they consider demonstrates how visitor numbers have fallen in areas that host wind farms. The petitioners suggest that it is difficult to have an entirely accurate idea of the number and impact of wind-power developments in Scottish national scenic areas, but consider that the UK Government’s renewable energy planning database provides “a good insight”.

Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?

10:00

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I represent an area where there is a heavy proliferation of wind farms. Not a surgery goes past at which I do not hear some kind of representation about that proliferation. It looks as though New Cumnock will be completely surrounded by wind farms. I have a lot of sympathy for what the petitioner is saying about NSAs. I should state that I am not against wind farms, but I think that the petitioners have a point in that wind farms seem to be taking over a lot of the countryside.

I know that there is a suggestion that we might close the petition, but I would prefer that we keep it live, but not in this committee—maybe in the Local Government and Communities Committee, through its scrutiny of the Planning (Scotland) Bill.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are we conflating two issues—concern about the proliferation of wind farms and the purpose of national scenic areas, with one being seen as a means by which to stop the other? It may be a convenient thing to argue, but I presume that national scenic areas exist in their own right and are not simply a way of managing our energy policy.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

What concerns me is whether the fact that an area is a national scenic area is taken into consideration.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The argument from the petitioner is that designation as a national scenic area protects an area from wind farms. I think that there is an issue about the cumulative effect of planning development, which I hope will be considered again during the passage of the Planning (Scotland) Bill.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

As a former member of a planning committee that was constantly faced with such issues, I have to say that it is a very emotive issue. One of the problems is that an NSA can have a wind farm erected on the edge of it. The argument would be made that the wind farm affects it but is not in the NSA. It is a massively complicated argument that does, in a way, conflate the issues when they are talked about side by side.

The response from the Scottish Government is very clear: it is not going to review the designation and number of NSAs. The issue is about how it all fits together with the planning strategy, which is currently under review. The issue needs to feed into that and to be part of the conversation and that review. I am not sure that the committee can do a lot more. There is a huge lobby for protecting our scenic areas, and Scottish National Heritage plays a big part in that.

As always, there has to be balance with everything else. The lobbyists often take a position and do not worry about the wider overall strategy. The subject needs to go into the pot with looking at the wider strategy. Our looking at it in single track is not going to get it very far.

I am in favour of referring PE1655 to the Local Government and Communities Committee to add it to its scrutiny of the Planning (Scotland) Bill. If it wants to refer the petition back to us at some point, that will be its choice, but at this stage I think that it belongs there.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that there is only one-way traffic for petitions; another committee cannot send a petition back to us.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

The petitioner can always re-petition us, but I think that the Local Government and Communities Committee is where PE1655 belongs now.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I think that it is clear from the Government’s response that there is no appetite to increase the number NSAs or national parks. I am minded to close the petition simply on that basis, given that the Government seems to be digging its heels in. However, if it is the overall view of the committee that PE1655 should be referred to the Local Government and Communities Committee, I would be happy to go along with that.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I think that we should close PE1655 because of the Government’s quite clearly stated view. Scottish Natural Heritage does not consider a review to be a priority, so it is not adding weight to the petitioners’ call. If the petitioners are made aware that the planning review is going on and that they could input to that, that is as much as we can do. I am not particularly keen on moving the petition elsewhere. It should be closed.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

On second thoughts, if we were to refer PE1655 to the Local Government and Communities Committee, it might well be closed down by it fairly quickly.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Doing that might, however, at least flag the matter up as an issue within planning legislation. My sense is that people have frustrations about wind-farm development and are talking about extending NSAs as a way of dealing with a separate problem, which is the cumulative effect of wind farms. There is always a balance to be struck, which I know as someone whose family came from a remote community. Some people think that wind farms create economic opportunity and stability for such communities. In my view, that is to be welcomed. That view will always have to be traded off against the views of people who want the wild to remain wild. Those people do not all live in the wild or in remote communities, although some do, of course. There is always a tension, which I acknowledge, in respect of what is human-made on the land that changes the landscape and other things, but makes communities there more sustainable for the people who live in them. It is interesting that people from within a community are flagging the matter up and feel that it has an impact on them.

I do not think we can go any further with PE1655, although there is an issue. We should make it clear that the problem with referring the petition to the Local Government and Communities Committee is that it has gone past stage 1 of the Planning (Scotland) Bill: the chance to influence the stage 1 report has ended. I have no doubt that the issues will be flagged up in stage 2. My view is that it would help consideration of the bill to allow the Local Government and Communities Committee to have sight of PE1655 and be aware of the issue. I suspect that it will be aware of it anyway, but our doing that would reinforce the problem that communities are wrestling with and are concerned about.

I was a planning minister for a short while; the question of the cumulative impact of wind farms in the area that Brian Whittle represents was flagged up to me then, as was, for example, opencast coal mining. There was a big tension within communities at that time about trading jobs against what was happening to the landscape. These are issues to which we are alive.

I do not think we can deal with PE1655 further. The question is whether we should send it to the Local Government and Communities Committee.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I understand what Rona Mackay and Angus MacDonald have said, but I think that it can do no harm to refer PE1655 to the Local Government and Communities Committee. If it is already aware of the matter, the petition will disappear, but if the petition would reinforce or inform what that committee is currently looking at, I do not see why we would not, at the very least, refer the petition to it.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

When my local authority developed our supplementary guidance on wind farms, it was rejected and we had to change it. The Government did not accept our position, as a local authority. In terms of information, it will do no harm to inform the Local Government and Communities Committee fully of the kinds of things that are coming from other directions. It is an emotive subject that causes a lot of division, so it will do no harm to add to the information that it receives.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is another interesting tension between strategic national goals and how they are delivered at local level. If we are in favour of renewable energy, there comes a point where such things have to go somewhere. There is a judgment call to be made about how that is managed.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

This is also about what people consider to be their fair share. There is quite a lot of tension about people accepting the policy of renewable energy, but asking why one area should get a large proportion of that energy generation, which destroys what people consider to be the intrinsic benefits and beauty of where they live. There are lots of issues. If we put more information in front of people when decisions are made, it cannot be said that we have ignored the commentary.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I do not think it is a bad reflection of the seriousness with which the petitioners made their case. You can understand why, from a community perspective, they have flagged up the issue.

Do members agree that we will refer PE1655 to the Local Government and Communities Committee? We can provide it with our deliberations so far.

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We thank the petitioners for the work that they have done in making the petition clear to us. They have the opportunity to lodge another petition and can choose to engage with the Planning (Scotland) Bill as it goes through Parliament.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 New Petition Petitions · 4
  3. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  4. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12
  6. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13
  7. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  8. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 18
  10. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  11. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  13. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  14. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.