The next petition is PE1548, by Beth Morrison, on national guidance on restraint and seclusion in schools. Included in our meeting papers are submissions from the Deputy First Minister and the petitioner.
In his submission, the Deputy First Minister addresses the committee’s question about whether, as part of the forthcoming review of the “Holding Safely” document, he might consider whether that would be the most appropriate place for the inclusion of the new guidance on de-escalation and physical intervention. The new guidance—“Included, Engaged and Involved Part 2: A Positive Approach to Preventing and Managing School Exclusions”——is referred to as IEI2.
The Deputy First Minister refers to feedback that he has received, which suggests that the “Holding Safely” guidance is still well used within the sector, and notes that it is just one part of a wider trauma-informed approach. In her submission, the petitioner provides a list of bullet points to demonstrate the feedback that she has received on IEI2 from parents and carers across Scotland. That feedback appears to suggest that there are still concerns about the guidance.
The petitioner contrasts IEI2 with the consultation that was run recently by the United Kingdom Government. She says that that is much more like the guidance that she would have liked to have seen in Scotland. She considers that it is
“very clear and specific and was written by bespoke experts in the field of restraint and seclusion.”
The petitioner appears to suggest that the degree of understanding about the use of restraint among professionals elsewhere in the UK is more advanced than it is in Scotland, and expresses her disappointment that the Scottish Government does not appear to see merit in updating the “Holding Safely” document.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?