Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Prescribed Drug Dependence and Withdrawal (PE1651)

Thursday 29 June 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:45–10:15 Petitions 53 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

53 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 2 is consideration of new petitions. The first petition on which we will take evidence is PE1651, by Marion Brown on behalf of Recovery and Renewal, on prescribed drug dependence and withdrawal.

I welcome Marion Brown to the meeting and ask her to make an opening statement of up to five minutes.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

First, I give apologies from Beverley Thorpe. She had hoped to be here, but her mother is very ill.

I am here today to represent many people in Scotland who are not well enough to be here in person. Some courageous individuals have provided clear evidence to the committee on the terrible suffering that is being endured as a consequence of taking antidepressants and/or benzodiazepines, as prescribed by their trusted doctors. We have previously raised our concerns directly with the doctors, with national health service representatives locally and nationally, with MSPs and with the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport. We actively contributed to the British Medical Association board of science’s 2014 United Kingdom research and are taking part in the BMA’s on-going work on prescribed drugs associated with dependence and withdrawal.

Our focus now is on raising political, press and public awareness of the issues in Scotland, complementing the activities of the all-party parliamentary group for prescribed drug dependence at Westminster. The Scottish Parliament information centre summary links to the current official medical guidance and policy, and it also outlines the recent BMA recommendations.

We have found major discrepancies between what the official medical guidance would have us all believe and the very different actual experiences of patients. The SPICe briefing states:

“despite the licensing procedures and guidance ... it is ultimately the decision of clinicians to decide whether or not a drug should be used in the treatment of their patient”.

That is a comment that seems to come back time and again in response to any questions.

Clinical trials of medicines are usually carried out over relatively short periods. Patients may be prescribed these medicines over very long periods, perhaps in combination with other medicines. We have found that individual reported patient experience is frequently ignored, put down and disbelieved by clinicians. The clear medical guidance is that benzos should be prescribed for a very short time only, but that is not happening. There is substantial evidence for prescribed benzo dependence and withdrawal issues going back decades. In contrast, medical guidance for antidepressants is that they should be taken for at least six months, and then they are commonly prescribed indefinitely.

There are now many people who have been on antidepressants and/or benzos for twenty years or a lot longer. Long-term harm is now clearly apparent. Safe tapering after different periods of prescribed treatment is fraught with difficulties for patients. The very few—mostly online—support groups that exist have for years been informally gathering evidence on a trial-and-error, ad hoc, patient-report and patient self-help basis. That genuine experiential patient learning and sharing has been largely dismissed, disregarded and even denigrated by the medical profession.

Now that there is a great deal of patient communication via online social media, as well as extensive internet availability of research and medical information, patients often come to know much more about their own conditions than their doctors possibly can. When patients try to discuss what they have learned, doctors patronise them and say that they should not believe anything that they find on Facebook or the internet. Those patients find themselves perceived by their doctors as troublesome and difficult heart-sink patients, and acquire psychiatric diagnoses such as personality disorders and medically unexplained somatic, functional or conversion disorders.

I refer to the diagram in my written submission, which summarises the pattern of the patient journey that we have now observed across numerous accounts by patients of what has happened to them. The fact that patient medical records are confidential to doctors turns out to have unexpected consequences for patients. Self-reported serious drug-effect symptoms have been noted in medical records but have not been acknowledged by doctors as drug effects, and instead further medicines have been prescribed for the reported symptoms.

Complaints procedures tend to be perceived as threatening to doctors. The medical defence organisations encourage doctors to do what any other doctor would do and to comply with current medical guidelines. If patients complain, it results in professionally defensive responses, so adverse drug effects continue to be unrecognised for what they are and are not reported to the regulator. There is no provision for systemic patient feedback and constructive learning.

To sum up, patients are suffering very serious harm from taking these medicines as prescribed. Dependence and withdrawal problems are causing untold damage; doctor-patient relationships are being destroyed; and all parties are suffering. The consequences are utterly desperate.

Long-overdue recognition of these issues will open the door to honest communication and genuine collaboration, leading to the establishment of appropriate national, regional and local support services and facilities for those who need them and, most important, urgent prescribing guideline reviews and updating of doctor education. The principles of the duty of candour surely apply here. Given the focus of Scotland’s “Realising Realistic Medicine” on “listening” to patients, “shared decision-making” and “collaboration”, I hope that we can show by example what that means in real practice. This is raw genuine feedback from the public and patients.

I will end my statement by citing “Black Box Thinking: The Surprising Truth About Success” by Matthew Syed, who says:

“The anatomy of progress is adapting systems in the light of feedback.”

Thank you.

10:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you for your statement. I also thank all those who have provided submissions; we have received a significant number in which people have talked about their own experiences, and they will help the committee’s consideration of the petition.

Your petition refers to the BMA’s recent recommendations, one of which is the introduction of

“a national, 24 hour helpline”.

Could you, as a starting point, clarify whether you would want the Scottish Government to establish a Scottish helpline or to contribute towards a UK-wide helpline?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We envisage a UK-wide approach with the Scottish Government collaborating with all the other UK partners. The whole of the UK could be covered by a helpline and a website containing lots of information; indeed, the website in particular would be incredibly useful for doctors, not just patients. It would be immensely helpful if there were reliable information to which doctors could refer. A UK-wide measure would also be fairly cost effective, as it would cover all the regions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Has the UK Government taken action in response to the BMA’s recommendation?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

I understand that BMA representatives met Westminster Government representatives on 22 June, but I have heard no reports of what happened there. The BMA has certainly approached the Westminster Government about the issue.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is a matter that we can inquire about.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I want to find out more detail about the helpline. What role would it perform? Would it be a source of medical advice, act as a counselling service or signpost people to various sources of support?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Discussions are on-going, but it would have to be a combination of those roles. Sometimes people are incredibly distressed, so they need help; the Samaritans, for example, have been overwhelmed with this problem, but it does not have the expertise to help people. In any case, there is nowhere to signpost people to at the moment.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Do you foresee the need for specialist training to carry out that role?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Yes, there would certainly have to be specialist training, but it could be centralised. Although there is nothing in Scotland, helplines have been running in England for quite a long time now—about 20 years—although some of them have closed down due to lack of funding. Barry Haslam, who has sent in one of the submissions to the committee, helped to set up a helpline in Oldham, and that set-up has been replicated in other places in the north-west of England.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is the service widely used?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Yes. There is one in Bristol, too. The service is overwhelmed—people cannot get through to it.

There is huge need for a properly resourced service that has information that doctors will believe. At the moment, even if people tell their doctor that they have phoned a helpline and have been advised to take a particular action, the doctor will say that they do not know anything about that and that that is not what it says in the guidelines.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

There needs to be more crossover and co-operation between the two.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Yes, absolutely. It needs to be something that the medical profession—

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Yes, and which it can collaborate with and believe in, too. I hope that patients are getting good advice from somewhere. Quite often, people get good tapering advice, usually from one of the online resources, but when they go back to the doctor and tell them what they have been advised, the doctor says, “My guidelines don’t say that—I suggest you do this.”

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Yes.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Another of the BMA’s recommendations calls on

“Each of the UK governments, relevant health departments and local authorities”

to

“establish, adequately resourced specialist support services for prescribed drug dependence.”

Can you expand on what “adequately resourced specialist ... services”, in addition to the helplines and websites that you mentioned earlier, might look like?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We are still in the early stages of figuring out exactly what they would be. The BMA has been talking to the charities that have been running support helplines and so on, and there is a lot of expertise there to work with. Early in the process, collaboration would mean everyone speaking to everybody else and trying to work out what is needed.

At the moment, people are being left in the long grass and are really suffering. You just have read their accounts; there is just nothing—no support—for them. They are just left, and nobody believes what is wrong with them.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Good morning, Marion. I am well aware of the good work that you do with Recovery and Renewal in my home town of Helensburgh. It is a great benefit to the area.

The BMA’s recommendations also call on professional bodies to offer

“guidance on tapering and withdrawal management”.

Are you aware of any work that is being done to develop such guidance?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Again, it is at an early stage. Because the problem has not been recognised by the medical profession, nobody has done the research. Nobody has really done anything about it—except hope that it will all go away. However, some research is being done now, and more will follow.

One thing that I would like to say is that there is a lot of expertise in the self-help groups, the Facebook groups and the internet groups. The patient self-help groups have developed a huge amount of expertise, and they will be able to share what they have learned, as long as they are willing to. They have been helping real people go through real processes, and there has been a lot of coming and going and a lot of people supporting each other.

There is a lot of expertise out there, if it is recognised. If everyone were able to talk to each other and collaborate, that work could be developed.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Do you find that that is helping you in your work in the Recovery and Renewal centre?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We do not have a centre.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I am sorry—I mean the work that Recovery and Renewal does.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We have found it really difficult. People are struggling desperately with the medication; the doctors are not helping them and their advice is often unhelpful. It is really hard. When Recovery and Renewal started up in 2013, we approached local doctors, told them what we would be doing and asked whether they would be interested in coming to speak to the group or whatever. We heard nothing. We have kept writing to various people, and we keep getting nothing. The response has been nothing—a blank. Everywhere we go in the medical profession, we get a blank response.

We have been trying to help people and signposting them to the charities and the Facebook groups. There is a website called “Surviving Antidepressants” and another one called “BenzoBuddies”. They have been going for years and have built up a huge amount of knowledge and experience, but they are not funded. Basically, they are self-help groups.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

You have said in your evidence that many people appear to have been taking for many years prescribed medication that was intended for only short-term use. From the many submissions that we have received from patients, it would appear that they consider the practice to have harmed their health. What can the Scottish Government do to better monitor prescribing practice and raise awareness of the issues?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

The first thing to do is to raise awareness of the issues. As far as prescribing practice goes, once the issues are recognised and taken into account, that will begin to help things change through the process of feedback that I referred to. However, the issue of prescribing practice is really for the Scottish Government and is not really for us to help with. I can speak only about the public perception of what is happening.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The suggested overuse of prescribed drugs perhaps leads to a change in people’s personality, which can result in a lack of good decision making. In the current system of prescription, patients can stockpile prescription drugs. Is that, coupled with the impaired decision-making process, exacerbating the problem?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Are we going on to issues of misuse?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

No—I am thinking more about the way that the drugs are prescribed and the possible lack of control by the medical profession, which could be allowing that poor decision-making process to exacerbate a health problem with antidepressants.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

I am not sure that I can give an opinion on that.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Convener, I just want to put it on the record that I am here on behalf of and at the request of Joanna Dennison, a constituent of mine who had hoped to be here but who was unable to come. I believe that members all have her personal testimony.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

As I have said, we are very appreciative of the personal submissions that people have made. They have given us an idea of some of the important issues that Marion Brown has flagged up.

Marion, you mentioned an all-party parliamentary group at Westminster. Have you explored the possibility of a cross-party group involving members of the Scottish Parliament to highlight the issues?

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

Jackie Baillie raised something like that back in, I think, 2013, soon after we started our group. We have been involved with Jackie Baillie right the way through, and she knew about that possibility. She came to one of our meetings and contacted a cross-party group on something similar, such as mental health issues.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is a range of groups. We would have to look at them, because specific questions on prescribed drug dependence might be a subset of the issues that an existing group deals with. You have distinguished between the misuse of drugs and dependency on prescribed drugs, which is a slightly different issue.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We asked Jackie Baillie to explore that, and a letter came back saying that the group did not think that that was necessary.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The petition might generate an interest in the issue, and that could then be looked at.

We appreciate your evidence and the substantial written evidence that we have received on the issue. There is a dilemma here. First, there is the appropriateness of prescribing particular drugs at all, and then there is the issue of prescribing drugs for longer periods than they are intended to be used for. Are there some drugs that ought not to be prescribed at all or whose use should be discouraged?

There is also the issue of the extent to which the medical profession is alive to people’s concerns when they feel that they have become dependent. We will all have been in circumstances where we have raised questions and had the response that it is a clinical decision, which is difficult to argue with.

The petitioner has raised a number of important points, and we now need to decide how we want to take forward the petition. What are members’ views on that?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

As you have alluded to, convener, the issue is not the prescribing of the drugs per se but the length of time that those drugs are prescribed for. In cases where drugs are supposed to be used for only a short period, what is in place for the medical profession to change that service? The only thing that I can think of doing is to write to the Government to ask for its view on the petition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That would certainly be a good starting point, because the Government would then take advice from the chief medical officer. We could ask patients organisations other than Marion Brown’s that deal with mental health issues whether they are seeing people with the same concerns. For example, the Samaritans, which Marion Brown mentioned, or the Scottish Association for Mental Health might have evidence on the scale of the problem that they face.

10:15

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

It is clear that the BMA is aware of a problem. There is no denying that this is a huge issue; it is just a question of how we take the issue forward. Certainly, we should write to the Scottish Government as a first step.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

If the BMA is aware of an underlying problem in the profession, I would like to understand why that problem exists. I do not know whether we need to go any further than writing to the Government at this point.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suggest that we write to the Scottish Government, which will get information from the chief medical officer. It might also be worth exploring with SAMH, the Samaritans and other such organisations whether they are aware of the issue. We had a petition in tragic circumstances where a young woman was prescribed drugs on her first surgery visit and then sadly died. We are very aware of individual tragic circumstances and another petition on the issue. We might want to tease out the issue of the appropriateness of prescribing drugs in the first place, and there is also the issue of managing dependence at a later stage.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

We should perhaps bring the issue to the attention of the UK all-party parliamentary group for prescribed drug dependence, which Marion Brown mentioned. We might as well benefit from the larger area that it covers.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We want as much collaboration as possible.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It might be worth contacting it to ask what it has done on the issue.

Marion Brown Recovery and Renewal
link

We have been involved with that group. We know it and we have been working with it.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We can perhaps also ask the BMA for an update on where it has got to with its recommendations on a helpline.

That has been a reasonable first stab at what is an important petition. Again, I thank Marion Brown for attending. The petition will come back on to the agenda after the summer recess and once we have received responses from the Scottish Government and other organisations.

I suspend the meeting to allow a changeover of witnesses.

10:17 Meeting suspended.

10:19 On resuming—

  1. 09:15 Continued Petition Petitions · 65
  2. 09:45 New Petitions Petitions · 53
  3. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 57
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 18
  8. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 22
  12. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  13. 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.