PE1652, by Irene Baillie, is on abusive and threatening communication. Members have a copy of the petition, a SPICe briefing and a note by the clerk.
The petition is concerned with the operation of the existing law on abusive and threatening communication and the extent to which it is enforceable, particularly in cases involving text messaging. The petitioner takes the view that the law needs to be reviewed, and the SPICe briefing advises that the relevant law is contained in the Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Scotland) Act 2012.
I would like to understand whether there are differences in the law between Scotland and the rest of the UK. I would have thought that threatening behaviour through text is the same as any other threatening behaviour and that the person could be prosecuted. I would like to understand the position. We should perhaps write to Police Scotland or the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service to ask them to clarify the position.
There seems to be an issue about the impact of having to get corroboration that the text was actually sent by the person who owns the phone. I suppose that that is why the argument is put forward that there should be strict liability and that the person should therefore be responsible because it is their phone. However, I am aware from speaking to young people that from time to time they use other people’s phones to send messages or whatever.
One of the questions that I have written down is that we should consider asking the Scottish Government what action has been taken on the corroboration aspect, which follows on from the point about the Cabinet Secretary for Justice’s decision in April 2015 to postpone a proposal to abolish corroboration. We need to be specific about that.
Corroboration has been mentioned. Is the idea that in this case the law should be similar to when, if someone’s car is caught speeding, they are liable unless they can prove that somebody else was driving?
I think that that is the argument that the petitioner is making. It would be interesting to know the views of those who are involved in the criminal justice system on the consequences of such an approach. We are not minimising in any way the impact of being at the receiving end of abusive and threatening communication yet not being able to get a prosecution because there is a need for corroboration. When someone can use such communication in a systematic way in a course of hostility towards you, it must be very difficult if, although it is recognised that it is happening, it cannot be proved. It would be interesting to ask the organisations that we write to whether strict liability would work. Would addressing the issue through changes to the legislation on corroboration make sense? Fundamentally, as Rona Mackay says, if this is a hate crime, how do we police it if we are not going to do it in the way that has been suggested?
The cabinet secretary said that the corroboration aspect would be part of a wider package of measures that was to be reviewed in the next session of Parliament, so it is obviously on the radar. It would be good to get clarification of where we are on that.
It is proposed that we write to the Scottish Government, Police Scotland and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. It would probably be good to write to some of the women’s organisations that support people who are dealing with abuse and violence. We should write to women’s organisations and organisations that deal with victims, especially since there is now recognition in the legislation that is coming through from the Government that not only physical violence but coercive control and so on are part of the issue. Should we write to anyone else?
We have got to the point that we understand that abusive and threatening communication is a crime and that it is a course of action that is directed against someone, but the issue is securing a prosecution and what steps should be taken to address that.
Do we agree to write to the Scottish Government, Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, women’s organisations and victims organisations to seek their views on the petition and, specifically, issues around the hate crime review, corroboration and the potential for the use of strict liability?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.