The next petition is PE1633, by Bill Alexander, on private criminal prosecutions. We have received a number of submissions since last we considered the petition.
The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and the Scottish Government take the view that an individual can petition the court even when the Lord Advocate does not concur. In that regard, the court may direct the Lord Advocate to give his concurrence, or to authorise the private party to proceed without it, by ordering criminal letters to be issued. The Scottish Government concurs with that view and advises that it has no plans to amend the existing legal framework.
The petitioner expresses concern that the cost of challenging the Lord Advocate may be prohibitive for some people. Mr Alexander also considers that there is a potential gap in respect of prosecutions on health and safety matters in Scotland, particularly in the racing industry, which he considers could be addressed by the action that is called for in his petition.
Do members have any comments or suggestions? There is an issue about how the Health and Safety Executive operates in Scotland. I know that it has a Scottish committee, but its submission says:
“Given HSE is not a prosecuting authority in Scotland we have no comment to make.”
The petitioner is trying to address the gap, because if something happens who provides the report? The petitioner considers that the fall-back position should be to pursue the matter as a private prosecution, without first having to get past the Lord Advocate. However, we are getting other advice that the Lord Advocate’s agreement is not needed.