Thank you, convener. First, it is correct that we have parliamentary scrutiny of this sort and I welcome it—Mr Rumbles knows that I mean that sincerely. It has allowed us to have an interesting discussion and debate, which is a good thing. Secondly, I am grateful to my officials. We have seen an illustration of the thoroughness and professionalism of officials, which has been exemplary.
Gail Ross asked me several specific questions. It is right that we take reasonable steps to notify all interested parties of the measure if it becomes the law. We will do that by press release, by advertising in local fisheries offices and by all other practical means. Ignorantia lex non excusat, of course; it is up to the individual to know what the law is—it is not up to the state to have a daily promulgation or news bulletin about the hundreds of offences that there are. However, I expect that it will be fairly obvious to those at whom we are aiming the legislation that the law—if the order is not voted against today—is in place. I suspect that those whom we wish to target will be very well aware of it.
This has been a very good debate, and I will address some of the other issues that have been raised.
Mr Stevenson expressed it extremely well when he said that the measure should be passed on public health grounds alone. With help from my officials, I have evinced that there is a serious problem regarding toxins. Mr Stevenson has gone into that issue. We have control over the activities of licensed fishermen and vessels but we have no control whatever over those who are engaged in criminal activity, and the risk of shellfish poisoning is very serious. The risk of imperilling the whole shellfish industry in Scotland through a serious incident or public health scare is very serious indeed. I convened a shellfish summit last year, and I can tell you that the retailers involved take the matter extremely seriously—in fact, public health is probably the most important issue that we must be seen to tackle if we are to get our shellfish on the shelves of the major retailers. I am in the privileged position of having heard buyers—I will not name them, but I am thinking of two or three who attended my shellfish summit—say that public health is absolutely imperative. If we do not pass the measure today—if any member votes against it—I would, for that reason alone, question whether that is the right thing to do
Mr Finnie set out the conservation case succinctly and well. I indicated that there are pressures on some stocks in some areas and that fishermen report their concerns. We all realise that, if fishing is to be sustainable, there must be appropriate management. That is not the sole tool in the box—there are many, as the committee will know—but it will become an important tool in allowing us to tackle effectively the problem that exists.
Mr Chapman asked how we can measure the extent of the illegal activity that is going on. It is difficult for any Government to measure criminal activity, because, by definition, criminals want to avoid detection, so that is not an easy question to answer—I am sure that members will accept that.
Mr Robertson has informed me that his officers say that, during the summer months, in the north-east alone, 50 to 60 vessels can be observed while his officers are on patrol. The vast majority will be hobby fishermen, but only three or four vessels conducting criminal activity could make a substantial difference. For that reason, the daily catch limit is one lobster, a point that has been raised.
I understand the arguments put by Mr Greene, Mr Chapman, Mr Rumbles and the convener. Looked at from a commercial point of view, however, and I will come on to this in more detail in a moment, what numbers are we talking about? If somebody fishes one lobster a day, that is five lobsters a week. I am informed that each lobster is about 2 kilos, at £20 per kilo. That totals about £10,000 per year, just for one lobster per day. We are talking about a lot of money here and a lot of potential impact on the legitimate activity of those who earn their livelihood from this.
The measure is one that those who earn their livelihood from fishing have been calling for for years. The fishermen want us to do this and I hope that members will bear that in mind. I will give some evidence of that. Alistair Sinclair of the Scottish Creel Fishermen’s Federation, representing over 500 creel vessels, says:
“We have no doubt that implementation will go some way to eradicating the problem of unlicensed fishermen who fish for profit.”
“For many years licensed fishermen, whether full or part time, have made representations to Marine Scotland in respect of those who would abuse the notion of taking ‘one for the pot’ from our coastal waters.”
“The current free for all that exists has created a black market in respect of the sale of fresh seafood.”
“We would urge that you implement the proposed restrictions due to come into force on 17 April 2017.”
These views are echoed by Alastair McNeill, the chair of the west coast regional inshore fisheries group. He refers to:
“great concern among licenced commercial inshore fishermen that considerable numbers of people flaunt the rules by fishing under the banner of ‘hobby’ fishermen yet are selling catches either directly or indirectly into the market.”
Bertie Armstrong of the SFF, representing 500-plus member vessels, says:
“The limits as proposed seem reasonable and given that they are aligned to existing practices in N. Ireland would seem fair and sensible.”