My question is about the free week of travel and the service quality incentive regime or SQUIRE fund. Minister, when you last came before the committee you said:
“Contractually speaking, it is up to the Scottish ministers how the money should be spent but, generally speaking, and as we have always done, we decide that in consultation and in discussion with ScotRail.”—Official Report, Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, 1 February 2017; c 20.
I pointed out to you that, prior to that, Phil Verster had said
“The contractual position is that the decision about where to invest it sits with Abellio ScotRail”,—Official Report, Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, 18 January 2017; c 27.
to which you responded:
“I do not imagine that Phil Verster has a photographic memory of the contract in his head. I am more than happy to provide the member with the wording of the contract.”—Official Report, Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, 1 February 2017; c 20-21.
You did that—you sent the franchise agreement to us. In it, paragraph 10.9 clearly states that
“The Franchisee”—
that is, Abellio ScotRail—
“shall propose for agreement by the Authority no less than once every Franchise Year how the Investment Fund should be spent.”
My first question is whether you agree that Phil Verster was correct in saying that the decision was for Abellio ScotRail, as the franchisee, and also that he had not agreed that the SQUIRE fund should be used for the free travel.