Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Mental Health Treatment (Consent) (PE1627)

Thursday 19 January 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 10:45–11:30 Petitions 35 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

35 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

PE1627 is on consent to mental health treatment for people under 18 years of age. I welcome the petitioner, Annette McKenzie, to the meeting. I think that she faced some challenges in getting here, so we really appreciate that she has come along.

Annette lodged her petition following the death of her daughter Britney, who, very sadly, overdosed on medication that she had been prescribed. Annette explains in the petition that she has brought the issue to us

“to try and ensure no more parents have to go through what I have gone through in recent months.”

We recognise just how difficult that must have been for you, Annette. If you are happy to do so, we would like you to make a short opening statement for approximately five minutes. After your statement, members will ask some questions that will help us to decide what action we may wish to take in response to your petition.

Annette McKenzie
link

I covered most of what I wanted to say in the petition. First, I would like you to know that I am not here on a witch hunt against the particular doctor who prescribed the medication to my daughter. When what happened with Britney happened, I was devastated—I was broken—but it let me find a fault in the system, where we are letting young people down and increasing the rate of suicide by giving children with mental health problems medication.

My daughter, at 16 years old, did not understand the severity or the strength of the medication that she was given. She went to the doctor that day to ask for help. She did not go expecting to be given pills. I know that a lot of people have concerns that my petition will discourage young children from seeking help from their doctor, but, speaking as an adult, I do not go to the doctor asking for tablets. I go for a diagnosis and to find out what he will do. I do not believe that a child will not go to a doctor to ask for help as a result of my petition, because at that age a child is not going to a doctor to ask for pills. They are going to speak out and ask for help.

At 16, someone who has mental health problems is not adult enough to make those decisions. If someone has mental health problems, they are not in a clear frame of mind. I do not believe that my daughter was in a clear frame of mind that day when she attended her doctor appointment, and I do not believe that, in a 15-minute appointment, her GP would have been able to properly assess and medicate my daughter. She could have been having a bad day that day.

More needs to be done on mental health for people who are 16 and 17. At those ages, people are going through adolescence and a lot of changes: they are learning how to cope in this big bad world that we live in. I would say that, at 18, someone is more capable of understanding consent and the long-term effects of taking something.

I honestly do not know what more I can say to you that I have not said in the petition. I have another daughter who is 14 and a son who is nine. I sit at home every day and worry because my 14-year-old daughter can go to the local GP and say that she is depressed and is not sleeping at night. That GP does not need to contact me and she can give her the same pills that Britney was given. What if she is missing her sister and decides to take all those pills? There is nothing that I can do as a parent. I do not have the right to know.

We are not just talking about my daughter being 16; we are talking about there being no age of consent. If a child goes to see a doctor at eight years old, the doctor will ask them to bring their mummy or daddy with them. If they go in at 13 years old, the doctor will treat them if they think that they can consent—if they are clever enough and can understand. I do not know how a doctor can understand that about someone in a 15-minute appointment, but if they deem someone to be wise enough at 13, they can send them away with medication. It does not just happen at 16.

When Britney passed, I was angry at first because I thought that she should not have been given the medication at 16. When I looked into it a bit more, I found out that there was no age limit. I started speaking to other people whose children were on the same tablets and I started talking to older people who have been on them from the ages of 14 or 15 and are now mentally impaired in what they can do. They were given the tablets at 13, 14, 15 or 16, and by the time they turned 18, they were dependent on them. They could not come off them; they needed them for everyday life.

Mental health has been brushed under the carpet for far too long. There is a stigma and a taboo: nobody talks about it. Kids need to know that it is okay not to be okay. Sometimes, adults get up and they are not okay—we do not know why. Mental health in children is like bullying: it is not spoken about but is brushed under the carpet. We are moving forward into 2017—that is hard for me to say, because I am still in 2016; I will never come into 2017. We need to move forward. Mental health is not getting any better and the death toll is not going down. I read in the SPICe briefing on my petition the number of deaths in 2015 among 10 to 19-year-olds. I was shocked by that number, whether those deaths were intended or not.

To be honest, if somebody wants to commit suicide, they will go ahead and do it. A lot of times, when somebody takes medication to commit suicide, they are not trying to end their life. They are trying to get help. They are at the end of their tether and they do not know what else to do. All that I am asking is that we make it harder for children to do that. They are not thinking right; they are too young. My daughter did not think that if she took all those tablets she would not wake up—that she would not be here. She thought that she would go to the hospital and get her stomach pumped—that was it. She did not think that what happened to her would happen.

A law was passed on paracetamol not because it meant that someone could not overdose on paracetamol, but because it made it harder for someone to do that. It made it not so convenient for someone to buy so much paracetamol.

All that I am asking is that you make it a bit easier for kids to get help that does not involve medication. By the time someone is 18, if they are still in that state of mind and they think that they need the medication, they should by all means have it, but if a child under 18 needs medication, their parents need to know.

My daughter’s mood changed from day to day. I told her off because she became lazy. She would not get up and go to her work. As a mother, I just thought that she was being a lazy teenager. It is horrible to say, but I spent my last weeks with my daughter moaning at her and telling her to stop being so lazy and to get up and do things—to get to work. I did not know that she was on propranolol and it was slowing down her heart rate. She was on 120mg a day. That, for a child of her age and her height, who had never been on medication, who had been on antibiotics only twice in her whole life—I needed to know, so that I could safeguard her at home. She had already said how she felt. She was not trusted. The medication was dangerous in the wrong hands, and her hands were the wrong hands.

So many more children are getting it. My daughter’s boyfriend went to a different doctor at a different practice, and three days after my daughter’s death he was handed a full prescription of amitriptyline. He went to the doctor’s three and a half weeks ago, as he was having a hard time with the Christmas period coming up. He saw a different doctor in the same surgery—his surgery, not my daughter’s—and he was given triazolam. The leaflet says that it is not to be given to a child under 18, but he is 17. It is not to be given to somebody with suicidal thoughts because it induces suicidal thoughts and tendencies. He was also given 42 propranolol tablets.

I was disgusted. This young boy had gone in and said that he was scared for his safety—for what he was going to do to himself and to others—and they gave him a very strong antidepressant that induces suicidal thoughts. They also gave him the same drug that my daughter overdosed on. What if that young boy had left the surgery that day and thought, “That is how they cared about Britney. Is this what they think about me?” He had the same amount of propranolol—he had enough to take what Britney took that night. What if he had thought that and taken them? So, my argument is not with only one doctor.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is very powerful, Annette. Thank you. I think that it is a broader question and not specifically about one doctor. What you have said raises a whole lot of questions.

Your petition explains that you would like the parent or guardian’s consent to be obtained before a young person is prescribed medication to treat mental ill health. Will you say more about the point at which parents or guardians should be involved? Is it when young people refer themselves to a doctor or when doctors prescribe medication?

Annette McKenzie
link

The doctor should encourage it when the child first goes to the doctor. In Britney’s case, the doctor never once asked her to involve me or another family member. That should be open. A young patient will not usually know that they can have a family member told. There needs to be more awareness so that young patients know that they can have a trusted family member involved.

I think that it is when it comes to medication that the parent needs to be involved. The child should still be allowed to have private meetings to speak with the doctor. Even after they are given medication, they should have the right to go in and speak confidentially with their doctor. However, for anything regarding medication, the parent has to know.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, Annette. You have put forward your views extremely well today and in the petition. My question follows on from Johann Lamont’s question. Will you explain a bit more about how you would like the consent or consultation to take place? For example, do you envisage the doctor writing to the parent or guardian to inform them of the treatment and seek their consent, or would you like the parent or guardian to be invited to attend the consultation?

Annette McKenzie
link

I do not think that it should just be a phone call to say, “I’m going to give your child X amount of pills. Are you okay with that?” It would have to be the child, the doctor and the parent sitting in the room together. When the person is of a young age, there needs to be a unit. The parents need to work with the doctors, and the doctors need to work with the parents. I would say that the parents need to be at consultations that concern the medication, but they should not have to be told everything. Children have a right to confidentiality; it is just that parents need to know the medication that their children are on and the reason why they are on it.

If I had known that Britney had propranolol, she would not have been in control of those pills. I would not have wanted her to have them—I would have tried alternative methods—but, if she had needed them, I as a parent would have taken control and administered them to her. If a doctor had convinced me that Britney needed those pills, I would have given them to her, but I would have been in control of giving them because of the state of her mental health. She might have woken up feeling happy or she might have woken up feeling that she wanted to take her own life. She did not know how she was going to feel. The parents need to be consulted.

11:15

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Hello, Annette. It is clear from your powerful and moving evidence what a devastating impact the issue has on families. Are there any circumstances in which you would consider it inappropriate for a family member to be informed about what a young person is being given? I am thinking about a situation in which the doctor makes a judgment but the parent will not allow the child to take the medication.

Annette McKenzie
link

Why would any loving parent not allow their child to take medication that was going to benefit their health if the child was at the point of needing help? As I said, if the doctor had convinced me that it was in Britney’s best interests to have the medication, I would not have disagreed; I would have medicated Britney. We trust our health professionals. I go to my doctor. People say that we should read the guidelines inside the box. I do that now, but I never used to do it. I just trusted that, when the doctor gave me a prescription, it was fine.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Have you heard of any instances of doctors asking children, “Do you mind if I tell your parents?”, or has that issue not come up during the consultation?

Annette McKenzie
link

I spoke to a couple of young people who said that a doctor asked them once whether they would call in their parents. They said no, but I think that the parents were called in anyway because the risk outweighed—

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

It is pretty much left up to the doctor.

Annette McKenzie
link

Yes. My doctor has been my rock since I lost my daughter. She has been amazing—I cannot fault her. I am not saying that doctors are bad, but maybe they are overworked. They do not have a lot of time to deal with so many people, and they are not trained properly in mental health.

For all that the doctor knew, my daughter could have split up with her boyfriend that day—she had split up with him two days before and she fell out with her best friend the day before that. Loads of things had happened. The doctor did not know my daughter, so they based their decision on their own judgment and a 15-minute assessment of my daughter. If the doctor did not have time to make a proper assessment, they should have said to her, “Here’s seven days’ worth of tablets. Come back in seven days.” They should not have said, “Here’s 84 tablets. I’ll see you in 28 days” because they were too busy and they had too many people to see. My daughter sent a message to her friend when she came out of the doctor’s, which said that the doctor did not even care but had just given her pills.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Good morning, Annette. One person who signed your petition commented that she was concerned that young people might be discouraged from seeking medical help if there was a requirement to obtain the consent of a parent or guardian. Is there a risk that young people would not seek help? If so, how could the risk be addressed to ensure that young people are able to seek help?

Annette McKenzie
link

When someone first goes to the doctor, they do not expect to be prescribed antidepressants or anti-anxiety tablets. I have—unfortunately—all my daughter’s messages about how she was feeling on the night in question and prior to that.

Sorry—what were you asking?

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I was asking whether you feel that it would be a barrier to young people seeking help if the doctor had to seek parental consent.

Annette McKenzie
link

I do not, because when they go to see the doctor, they are not looking for medication. They are looking for an answer to something. They are not going to ask for antidepressants or anti-anxiety pills: they are going to try to explain to the doctor what is going on in their head, which they do not know how to explain to their mum or anybody else. They go to the doctor because they trust that the doctor will make them better—that is how the kids look at it.

I do not think that Britney expected the doctor to give her pills. The doctor’s report said that she did not feel like talking at that time, but the doctor had only just met her and was with her for only 15 minutes. Try inviting her back in seven days’ time, try asking whether she would like to bring anyone with her, or try asking whether there is another adult that she would feel comfortable speaking to. My daughter told the doctor that it was her learndirect worker who had advised her to go to the doctor. My daughter had asked her learndirect worker for advice on how to approach the issue and let her family know what was wrong with her, and that person told her that she should first make sense of the matter herself, so she should make a GP appointment, which she did.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

You do not believe that a requirement to obtain the consent of the parent or guardian would discourage young people from seeking medical help.

Annette McKenzie
link

I do not.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Thank you for coming here today and giving us such a moving testimony. Thankfully, mental health is becoming a much more recognised issue in Parliament. You have raised concerns about the strength of the medication that is available to young people and have done a lot of campaigning and awareness-raising work since submitting the petition.

Members know my views on the matter, but do you think that there is a trend towards using medication to treat mental health issues, and do you think that alternative forms of treatment should be explored?

Annette McKenzie
link

Yes. I think that people maybe think that the alternatives cost too much. The young people’s health budget was cut not long ago. Why cut that budget? It is like saying that young people do not have mental health issues, even though mental health issues in young people are on the rise. Society today puts pressure on children, from the age of nine through their teenage years, to be brilliant and perfect and to fit certain criteria.

The other day, I went to see the doctor that I have been seeing since July, but she was not on duty, so I saw a different doctor—a locum. I get quite upset when I go to see the doctor, and the locum did not know my case or anything about me, so his demeanour was different from my usual doctor’s. It is hard to explain.

Sorry—I have forgotten what you asked. It is the medication that I am on. That is what the medication does to me—I forget, sometimes, what I am talking about.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I was asking about your views on the trend of medicating people instead of looking for alternative forms of treatment.

Annette McKenzie
link

When I put the petition online, I thought that I was going to get quite a backlash from young people, but I was surprised to see that young people are for the proposal.

I have a friend—a young girl called Zoe—who is from Glasgow but who stays in Spain. On her blog, she wrote a perfect example of why she was 19 years old before she went to see a doctor about her anxiety issues, which she had suffered from since she was about nine. She said it was because, from the age of 14, she was terrified that she would be prescribed “the magic pill”. The brilliant piece that she wrote gives the reasons why she chose to wait until the age that she did before going to the doctor. When she expressed her concerns, though, the doctor was brilliant and said that he would never medicate a child under 18 with the kind of high-dose drugs that other doctors give children. We are not talking about 10mg tablets; we are talking about tablets of 40mg. That is a high dose, and people walk away with 84 tablets. That would have been enough to allow Britney and three of her friends to commit suicide if they had wanted to.

Is suicide becoming a new trend? Maybe I am just noticing it more. Since my daughter passed, I have heard of a lot of cases of people taking their own lives. Last week, I looked on Facebook and saw that people were sharing a video from a young girl who had live-streamed her death. Suicide is an easy option these days. If someone wants to take their own life, they will take it. But the kids who are being prescribed the medication that we are talking about do not understand how strong it is—their heads are messed up.

My daughter did not understand. Why would she Google whether the medication was going to kill her after she had taken it? She did not understand. She did not leave the surgery that day knowing about the side effects, but I noticed them. I was not privy to what caused them, but I noticed them then and I just thought she was lazy. I now know what was causing them.

She did not understand that, if she took 38 of those tablets, she would not be here. She went to the doctor and asked for help, but she felt that she got no help apart from just being given pills, which was not a help. The next step was to take those pills that the doctor had given her, 16 days later. I do not know whether that medication made her feel any different in herself—in her thoughts and feelings. It says that they should not be given to somebody with depression. That is a whole different matter for the General Medical Council.

The medication is too strong for them. I have spoken to adults who were on the dose of propranolol that my daughter was on. One woman had it for postnatal depression. She was to take one 40mg tablet three times a day, but she told me that she could only manage to take two of those tablets per day at the most, because the dosage was so high. She had had mental health problems prior to her postnatal depression and she was 45 years old. My daughter was 16 years old with no history of mental health issues. She had had the cold and normal, everyday things like that, but that was it.

The doctors use their discretion. Some doctors are brilliant—they are amazing. I cannot say that all doctors are the same, but one death is too many. My daughter’s death has not been the only death. I am the only one sitting here talking about it, but hers is not the only death because someone has been given prescription medication without being told about it.

If I had known that Britney had medication, I could have safeguarded it. I would have been aware and I would have been more vigilant at home. I would have understood more when I asked Britney to do the simplest thing—to go to the shop across the road for me. She did not want to go out the door and go to the shop. I would say, “You’re so lazy. Please go to the shop. I’ve got your brother and sister here.” To her, it was a big thing even to go out to the shop, because of the way that she was feeling. I did not know that, though. I just thought that she was being lazy and did not want to go over to the shop—that she was too busy on her phone in her room. I treated her differently from how I would have treated her.

There is no distinction between mental health and physical health. I could have seen it if she had been physically unwell, but I could not see that she was mentally unwell. It is a bit of a concern that there is no distinction between the two. Somebody can hide mental health problems. How do we know that nobody in this room has mental health problems? What does somebody with mental health problems look like? My daughter was absolutely beautiful. Countless people have asked me, “Why would your daughter do what she did?” That is like asking what somebody with mental health problems looks like. There is no answer to that.

We need to do something about it—I would say before it is too late, but for me it is too late. It is not too late for my other children or for other families with children, though.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much for that, Annette. Sadly, our time is constrained. That is not because we want it to be; it is simply because, once business starts in the chamber, we are not allowed to continue here. That is the only reason for it.

Annette McKenzie
link

I appreciate your saying that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that you have used the time that you have had very powerfully. You have given us a clear message about the range of challenges that you have highlighted. Other families will have cause to thank you. I know that that will not be any comfort to you, but there are some really important issues that we need to consider further.

We will not deal with the issue in a rush, as there is a lot of thinking to be done about it. I wonder whether there are any specific suggestions about what we might do immediately as a consequence of the petition.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

We all know that mental health gets much more parliamentary time these days, especially now that we have a Minister for Mental Health, but Annette McKenzie has brought us consideration of something that I had never thought of. She has brought something else into the debate, and I thank her very much for that.

I would like us to write to the Health and Sport Committee or the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport to find out their thoughts on the matter and to find out how the legislation lies on the issue.

11:30

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There was a report to a House of Commons committee that talked about the GP at least asking the person whether it was all right to speak to their family.

Annette McKenzie
link

I read about that in the SPICe briefing.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The evidence was that most people would say yes to that. We can reflect on that.

We could write to the Scottish Government, asking for its views, and perhaps the Scottish Association for Mental Health. The Scottish Youth Parliament will have a view, and we could seek the views of the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, the Mental Health Foundation and the General Medical Council on the petition.

I am interested to know what the guidelines are for prescribing to under-18s. This is surprising because my sense is that there is a reluctance to prescribe even antibiotics to them. Is there a guideline about not prescribing to under-18s or prescribing only in certain circumstances? I would be interested to know the clinical view on that, too.

Do members have any other suggestions?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

What you are saying is absolutely right. It would be interesting to find out whether there are guidelines. That would mean that they would be open to interpretation by different doctors. Should there be more than guidelines? Should it be mandatory to take certain steps to avoid such situations? That should all come out in the evidence that we take from the various organisations.

Annette McKenzie
link

We wrote to the people who drew up the guidelines—is it the Medicines & Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency?—and that is in the regulations for the medication, I think. We wrote to them.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We can check with the body concerned. One of the other bodies that we could contact is the Royal College of General Practitioners, which must have a view on what the guidance is in such circumstances.

Annette McKenzie
link

I know that there were no guidelines for the medication that my daughter was on.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Those are the kind of things that we would want to go into. This is the initial stage of getting those organisations and the Scottish Government to reflect specifically on what your petition calls for, which is consent, but there is no doubt that other issues are emerging from it, too.

Are we agreed to take those actions?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will keep in touch with you, Annette. If there is anything else that you wish to add, do not hesitate to contact the clerks or me, and we can pursue those questions. Thank you very much for your attendance.

11:32 Meeting suspended.

11:32 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 38
  3. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  4. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  5. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 49
  7. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 53
  8. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 35
  9. 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.