PE1625 is on the wider awareness, acceptance and recognition of pathological demand avoidance syndrome. We will hear evidence from joint petitioners Patricia Hewitt and Mary Black, who are accompanied by Euan Robson and Heather Fullbrook. I welcome you to the meeting. You have the opportunity to make a brief opening statement of up to five minutes. After that, the committee will ask a few questions to help inform our consideration of the petition. Who wants to start?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Pathological Demand Avoidance Syndrome (PE1625)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Patricia Hewitt 16
- Johann Lamont Lab 12
- Mary Black 11
- Rona Mackay SNP 5
- Maurice Corry Con 3
- Brian Whittle Con 2
- Euan Robson 2
- Heather Fullbrook 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
The record
53 contributionsThis statement is from Pat Hewitt, and I will read it on her behalf:
“There are two boys in my case one 19 the other 20. There was no early intervention. The youngest behaviour was classed as ‘lazy and winging it’ at school. ‘We have children like this all the time’ and ignored my concerns. He was removed from Nursery for months because they said he was too hyperactive and immature. Had the schools referred him they would have found out differently. At no stage was I made aware that I could have asked for an assessment of their needs. I found that out too late.
The eldest behaviour was put down to Post Traumatic Stress Disorder after their father died. He was on a heart transplant list for five years then died of misdiagnosed Cancer of the Stomach.
Adult mental health services diagnosed my eldest son within weeks with Asperger’s at 18. His brother was diagnosed at 17 with Asperger’s by CAMHS after a year of cancellations and failed appointments to do a school assessment. I knew he was different and pleaded with them to transfer him to adult services who diagnosed ADHD when he was young and now has ADD.
My boys have been humiliated and degraded throughout their school years and denied a normal childhood and education.
It was not for the lack of trying to get answers by my GP. So many people failed us not just CAMHS. When Sick Kids fail to recognise the type of seizure, Asperger’s and PDA I think it time to worry. In the end I have recognised 95% of the issues. Thank goodness my GP believed me.
It was a comment made by an instrumental music teacher comparing students, seeing Mary’s article in the Press about Hannah and PDA, then reading Jane Sherwin’s book, ‘My daughter is not naughty’. It was a lightbulb moment.
My eldest son has been handcuffed by the Police after he trashed his bedroom in a meltdown. Neighbours and Police searched for him in the dark on another occasion.
My parenting skills have been questioned. I was offered a parenting course. I wanted to end my life because no one would help. One Police Control room assistant called me ‘an unfit mother’.
10:30
I asked my GP to remove the eldest to a homeless unit. I could not cope with his behaviour any more. I have to live with that guilt.
This has had a massive effect on both my mental and physical health, I now need help which I don’t get.
I also care for my sister four days a week who has numerous medical problems. I have been abandoned by Social Work and CAMHS and muddle through the best I can.
Due to PDA techniques not being used my children have failed so many exams at the latter end of their school career. The refusal of adequate support for the youngest resulted in severe sleep deprivation, he was staying up 24/36 hours. He never returned to school. We rescued one exam.
An inspirational tutor listened to the story at Edinburgh College last June and they are now using PDA Strategies to help him in his Classical Music Studies. We believe he is the first PDA student at the College. His private instrumental tutor is working with the College. My faith in the Education System has been restored by this team. For the first time in his life my son is happy in a safe caring environment who have been willing to listen and learn.
My eldest son’s P7 teacher in Primary School said he would be able to pick and choose which University he went to—Oxford, Cambridge, St Andrews. He is on Employment Support Allowance in the support group.
He is a virtual recluse. I still don’t have an accurate diagnosis for both boys. I believe both fit the profile of rare syndromes. We have recently been refused an out of area referral for PDA.
My eldest son was never the same after an accident at school where he received second degree burns to a hand after failing to provide protective gloves. He was not given correct first aid and was in agony for months. Months later he started having seizures. These are still uncontrolled but we now have the right diagnosis. Another Consultant who ‘listened to the story’.
He was bullied from P2 to S6 and eventually bullied out of school.
He could not control anything in his life. Because PDA was not recognised, the long term damage was done.
The local additional needs support Group has refused to support us as the Local Authority does not support PDA.
My biggest fear is what happens once I die. Unless people are aware of PDA and the Strategies required I am so frightened my boys will land up in Prison or a care home, homeless or taking drugs and alcohol.
When I first went to my GP and asked him what he knew about PDA, he replied ‘nothing’, ‘Listen and Learn’. We have worked together and there are now seven confirmed cases of PDA in the practice.
I need hope for the future. My boys will need 24/7 support. Scotland has totally failed them so far. Prove to me and so many other Parents, children, young people and adults out there that you do ‘Listen to the Parents’ and spread the awareness and formally recognise PDA”.
That statement was on behalf of Patricia Hewitt. Do you have a statement of your own?
Yes. First, I thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak to you today regarding the autism spectrum disorder PDA and the petition—which you will have seen, and which is signed by parents and professionals in the fields of research, medicine, social care and education.
I am the parent of five children. Four of my children are very successful educationally and are very happy in life. Two are currently in university and the others are in very good employment. However, there has been a massive impact on us as a family as we knew that Hannah was different—so different from other children—from a very young age. When Hannah started nursery, it was very clear, and her nursery teachers told us, that something was not right: Hannah was different. I turned to all the professionals for help and advice, but I was simply sent to parenting classes. After that, it was just like being on a hamster wheel, going round and round in circles. Eventually, they discharged me. For 11 years, I have been blamed and quizzed about my family. That has caused severe mental health problems for me and my family, and for Hannah.
Hannah is aged 13 and she is so different from her brothers and sisters. With the correct care and understanding, she can be a very loving, caring and happy young girl. In May 2016, she even managed to climb Ben Nevis in under four and half hours. Hannah can also be controlling and extremely demand avoidant, and she is highly anxious most of the time. Due to social communication and interaction difficulties, she can become very verbally and physically aggressive, particularly towards her family. Hannah has a profile of PDA, which is on the autism spectrum disorder. I know that she has that development disorder from all the research and because the therapeutic residential school that she went to in 2015 for six weeks picked up on that within a few weeks during assessments.
The school’s conclusion was that Hannah has to have access to specialist services that understand the needs of young people with complex atypical ASD/PDA, who need 24-hour care. I cannot find a professional in Scotland who understands PDA and who is able to diagnose the disorder. There are several specialists in England who have been trained to assess and diagnose the disorder, and I and many parents in Scotland feel that specialists need to be available in Scotland.
Even though Hannah has not yet been officially diagnosed with PDA, my family and I have been using the management and behavioural strategies for children with PDA and we have seen how much of a difference those have made to Hannah in the past year. However, Hannah still needs an education that can meet all her PDA-related special needs. Whoever educates Hannah will need to have a good understanding of PDA and the strategies that are needed to keep her calm so that she can learn. So far, the education department has failed to provide a suitable education for Hannah and she has remained at home with me for the past couple of years. The department does not have any idea of what to do with her.
For the past six years, Hannah has spent most of the time excluded from primary school because of her extreme anxiety and meltdowns, which have led to her being restrained and handcuffed. PDA is part of the autism spectrum, but it should not be diagnosed as ASD, because the strategies for that are known not to work with PDA children—in fact, those strategies can make children with PDA a lot worse and can affect their emotional and mental health, leading to anxiety, depression and self-harm.
Children with PDA are often labelled as naughty children and are not diagnosed as being on the autism spectrum, because they can give more eye contact and they are high functioning and are intelligent. They can also mask their difficulties at appointments and they have superficial social skills. To get a diagnosis, it takes a very specialist ASD psychologist who has been trained in ADOS—the autism diagnostic observation schedule—and in how to recognise not just ASD but the particular markers and traits of PDA. There are a couple of places in England where professionals can train to accurately diagnose ASD and PDA—one is in Bromley in Kent. Without that training, professional psychologists cannot recognise PDA or note how it relates to the autism spectrum.
If children with PDA do not get the accurate assessment, diagnosis and educational support that they need, their outcomes will be very poor—they will have mental health difficulties or be sectioned or commit suicide. Educationally, they will not achieve or finish school and they could therefore become criminal offenders. However, with the correct assessment, diagnosis and support, children with PDA could go on to college or university or into employment and to live fulfilled lives.
Early intervention is the key to good outcomes for children with PDA, but accurate assessment and diagnosis and early intervention are not available for this very complex and challenging group of children. So, ladies and gentlemen, I am asking you please to make changes in Scotland to ensure that all our children get the care and understanding that they deserve so that they can find their way in the world when we are no longer on this earth to care for them, as PDA is a lifelong disability.
Thank you very much for those substantial statements. There was lots for us to think about in there, and some of our questions might have been answered. The first aim of your petition is to promote a wider awareness of PDA syndrome. Just by being here today and making those statements, you have probably already come quite a long way on raising awareness.
You provide a lot of reference sources in your petition, as does the briefing information that has been gleaned for us. How can those reference sources be promoted to encourage people to access them and be aware of the issues? How can we make the resources that exist more public and more available to people?
At present, there seems to be no recognition whatsoever. When we as parents go into meetings around the child—MAC meetings—or other meetings with agencies, there is no recognition of the condition. To publicise it, there would have to be a campaign in the same way that there was with Autism and Asperger’s, which were not recognised disorders. Education is definitely the key. We need to educate the people at the top in health, education and social work services and work down from there, because people simply do not recognise the condition.
If general awareness is improved, will that generate recognition and acceptance of the condition? If the public are more aware of it, will one follow from the other?
Yes—definitely. The first case was recognised in 1998 by an inspirational team in North Lanarkshire. The child was taken down to Nottingham and the famous Professor Newson diagnosed the condition. She was given one-to-one attention through school until she was 15. How is it that that happened yet my GP had not even heard of the condition? Until I saw Mary Black’s article in the paper, I had never heard of it.
In my case, it was me who recognised it. I was blatantly ignored by the schools. In talking to the teachers, I found that their understanding of the autism spectrum was shocking, and that included the primary school teachers. I do not know whether people need any training whatsoever to be a learning support teacher, but their understanding of autism is shocking.
There is none.
There is significant training for learning support teachers, but that is a different point.
The other point is that it is important to explain things simply. Everything that people get is so complicated. It is really concerning that CAMHS and the school doctors did not recognise the condition and told my son for eight years that it was post-traumatic stress disorder. It was me who worked out all the different parts of it. It is also concerning that places such as the sick kids hospital did not understand the differences between epilepsy, autism spectrum disorders and PDA.
If there had been early intervention at the start, I would not have had the police at my front door and my child in handcuffs. His whole life has been absolutely destroyed. One thing about PDA is the anxiety. Sitting here—half terrified—we have a certain level of anxiety. The anxiety of children with Asperger’s is much higher, but the anxiety associated with PDA is higher than the ceiling. We have to be 10 steps ahead all the time. We can watch the anxiety, and we have to get in quick to distract them. I am not being rude, but I normally talk about politicians. I ask them, “Have you seen what so-and-so in America has said today?” That sort of turns it into a bit of fun, and when I distract them in that way, I can see their anxiety going down.
Even to get my youngest child out of bed is a nightmare. When you think of it, there are all these demands: get out of bed, brush your teeth, brush your hair, go in the shower, get all your things ready. The child has all these demands hitting them—
Every single day.
One thing that schools do not understand is school refusal. People are told that they will take their child to school, and that is the end of it. Schools do not understand what is happening at home.
We have to get them out of bed to start with, and that is a massive demand.
Yes. The help that my son needs to get into the taxi and then on to a bus is unbelievable. As I said, we have had the PDA strategies put in at college, and everybody is working together. That is instrumental in him being at college. If we had not done that, he would not be there. It is as simple as that.
Will you clarify the situation in England? You mentioned a particular practitioner, but are there others?
It is all over the world. There are people affected in America, and I have just talked to a lady in Croatia about it. The whole world is affected by it—it is that important.
Are there specialists who recognise and are aware of the condition? You mentioned that the situation is different in England.
10:45
There are very few, but there are some in Scotland. There was a lady in Inverness whose seven-year-old child was handcuffed—it was horrendous. She is a nurse and, for three years, she had told CAMHS that the child had PDA, but she was totally ignored. Eventually, she got a referral across to Yorkhill hospital, where the PDA was diagnosed. There is also a lady in Aberdeen who said online that she has a diagnosed child, so there are little cliques.
There are pockets where it is recognised.
That is why I was asking about referral. On the PDA Society website, I sent a private message to a family in Edinburgh who have a diagnosis for their 19-year-old daughter. She is in a homeless unit with mental health difficulties, because CAMHS had failed to recognise her condition.
There is no support afterwards. I was told that my daughter had PDA in 2015, but CAMHS discharged me and the education authorities did not believe it—they said that PDA does not exist. I was told to get on with it and I was left on my own. That is why I went public to raise awareness and to say, “This is what’s wrong.” I had to witness my child in the back of a police van being manhandled, because of her sheer anxiety. I had to watch her being handcuffed and thrown. That was awful, and it was all because of the lack of awareness and a belief that there is no such thing as PDA.
We have proved that it does exist, because of the original case. The CAMHS that are poor do not recognise PDA, but the good CAMHS do. It goes from one extreme to another—from absolutely brilliant to absolutely appalling. It is the same with education services.
Only last year, I was told in a MAC meeting that I should not bother wasting any money going private to get my child diagnosed officially with PDA by a professional, because it is not recognised and it does not exist. I was told that it was down to me and the way that I brought my child up.
We have heard a lot of information, so we might not need to ask all our questions.
In the petition summary, you refer to “appropriate agencies and bodies” providing training, developing therapeutic programmes and providing support. What might the appropriate agencies be?
They would include the National Autistic Society, for one. It has a wonderful school just outside Rotherham with a specialised hub for about 17 or 18 children. They are given specialist education and taught social skills—it is absolutely amazing. There are also schools in Scotland that will work with such children.
My two children went through mainstream education and it was absolute hell for them, but the eldest represented the Scottish Borders in a K’Nex competition. The youngest went to Germany with the Borders chamber orchestra and he was in Inverness last year with Edinburgh College’s orchestra. If you saw him, you would not think that he is autistic.
When it comes to the early intervention strategy, my biggest bugbear is the additional support for learning legislation. The Scottish ministers say that a diagnosis is not needed, but people on the education side do not know that a diagnosis is not needed and that there is a legal duty to refer. The education minister said, “Yes, that is right.” We were fobbed off to make inquiries in the Govan Law Centre. The General Teaching Council did not want to know. Nobody wanted to know—it was unbelievable. You should go to a specialist school and listen to the parents, because we were totally ignored. I said that my youngest had lots of issues outside of school and that he was a nightmare getting to school, and other parents said, “My children are like that.” What they were put through was horrendous.
The committee should go to those specialist places and see what they are doing. A little while ago, we were up at Barrhead, training with the PDA Society, and we listened to some of the teachers. One of them said that the most brilliant thing in her career was to get a child with PDA right through the school system and to ensure that they got an education; to her, that was the most rewarding thing out. However, one of my neighbours who is a teacher said to me, “Patricia, we just do not have the time or the resources. It’s easier for us if these children fall out of the system.”
Did you want to come in, Mr Robson?
If I might, convener. I should say that I am here in a private, not a professional, capacity.
There is quite a direct and straightforward answer to the member’s question: there needs to be official recognition of the syndrome. Without that, there will always be a debate about provision, and it would be ideal if the Scottish Government were to look carefully at the matter, to officially recognise the syndrome and to issue guidance to inform the relevant authorities, whether they be in health or education.
I am a layperson in this area, and I suspect that all the members of the committee are, too, but there is evidence that appropriate therapies can lead to fulfilled lives and reduce the appalling stresses on families. The sad thing is that well-intentioned interventions or therapies that are appropriate to certain parts of the autistic spectrum but not to this syndrome can actually do more harm than good and can raise difficulties. Therefore, recognition of the syndrome by the Scottish Government and guidance for professionals on how to cope and the therapies that are available will be of enormous assistance.
As far as PDA is concerned, sending a teacher on an ordinary autism training course is a total waste of time—it is like sending a plumber on an electrician’s course. The strategies are completely different.
We are told to choose our battles carefully, and that is what we do. Most parents would be absolutely horrified at what we have to turn our backs on—being told to eff off and all the rest of it—but we know how far we can go, because we just do not want to have a meltdown situation. When you think about it, it is like looking in a sweet shop; the children with PDA want to go in, but the demand avoidance aspect is telling them, “No—don’t.”
The other thing about Asperger’s relates to prediction: the children cannot follow through and predict what will happen next. If they stay up all night, they cannot predict that they will have to go to school the next morning. They also have all sorts of sensory issues; they are oversensitive to many things. That is what you are looking for. My youngest one has attention deficit disorder; that is what I have, too, and the only way that I can describe it is as “Flit, flit, flit, flit.” When you take all those issues together, you can see why the normal autism strategies cannot be used.
When my son did his Business and Technology Education Council level 3 diploma, because he had not been taught using the correct PDA strategies, he got only three merits and he needed six to get into the next course. Had those strategies been there in the first place, we would have been able to get him through. He failed four out of five exams, because they totally ignored me and refused to put in the support. Even after that, they still would not put the support in. Eventually, I told them about the sleep deprivation; the sleep had gone off the scale. To me, it is mental cruelty to do that to a child—it is just unbelievable. The other child was denied an education, because he was bullied out of school. It has just been absolutely horrendous.
Had the right strategies been in place for both children, we would not have had the issues that we had to deal with all the way through. This syndrome is never going to go away or get better; there is no cure for it, and the strategies need to be put in place. If something were to happen to me today, they would just lose it and go “Tchoong!” again.
Their anxiety would go so far—
—that they could not cope. The right strategies should be put in. People do not know about PDA, and many parents come on to the forum. A lot more women come on to it and talk about abuse from husbands, for example. I help parents throughout the country. One parent has four children. Getting support is absolutely horrendous.
I am conscious of the time. Does the committee have any other questions? I appreciate everything that has been said so far.
I have a short question. You referred to music and art, which I have a deep interest in. Do you find that they are the most prominent therapy for your children?
The other child is into engineering and science, but music helps many children on the spectrum.
Out of music, art and engineering, is music at the top?
It is for him.
For my daughter, it is swimming. I do a lot of horse therapy, and we go swimming. Music helps, and she is quite musical.
Every child with PDA is unique.
They are all different.
They are like fingerprints; no two are the same.
What works for one child might not work for the other. It just depends.
The strategies could work on the first day, but if they are tried the next day, no will mean no; it does not matter what is done.
The point about the particular example of music is what can be achieved when the appropriate therapies are applied in individual cases. A young man who has had a very difficult educational experience is now flourishing because there is an understanding of his condition. The tragedy is that, until the syndrome is recognised, there will be endless cases of people who could have achieved and done much, but cannot do so.
I am conscious of the time. If the witnesses want to feed further things into the committee, we would obviously be keen to hear from them, but the most compelling thing that they have said is pretty basic. It is about getting recognition of the syndrome.
We will now consider what action we can take as a consequence of what we have heard.
I would like to get the Scottish Government’s views on the matter and see what actions that the petition calls for it can take.
Do members agree that we should ask the Scottish Government for its views?
Members indicated agreement.
What about other organisations?
The National Autistic Society has already been mentioned. I coach somebody with autism in track and field athletics, and I can see the impact that having a different route can have. I would like to understand the National Autistic Society’s views on the matter and on whether it recognises PDA as a syndrome.
There are Scottish autism organisations, too. It has been suggested that we seek the views of Enquire, Child Autism UK, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health—I would be interested to know its view—and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. Perhaps we could seek the views of the teaching unions, as well.
It is important that we contact as wide a range of bodies as possible.
I want to follow on from Brian Whittle’s comments. If we are writing to COSLA, I think that Mary Black mentioned that some councils recognise PDA, but other councils do not. Is it possible to get a list of which councils recognise PDA and which ones do not give it proper recognition?
Okay. We agree that we should write to the Scottish Government and the organisations that we have identified. We could also explore differences between local authorities.
I thank our witnesses very much for attending. If their first aim was to raise awareness of the condition, they have certainly done that. We hear very clearly that things would come as a consequence of getting recognition that would be very important in helping families and individuals in those circumstances.
I suspend the meeting for a changeover of witnesses.
10:59 Meeting suspended.
11:02 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Jan 2017 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 38
- 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
- 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
- 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 49
- 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 53
- 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 35
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.