Amendments 76 to 83 seek to make various changes to section 47A, which relates to a stillbirth that occurs as a result of a post-24-week termination, and their cumulative effect is to enable a health body to ask the woman what she wants to happen to the remains before the termination occurs. By virtue of amendment 77, health professionals must do that if they consider it to be in the woman’s best interests.
Amendment 84 adds after section 47A a new section that gives various powers to health authorities where they are authorised to make arrangements by section 47A. Powers rather than duties are used in the section to provide additional flexibility. The effect of that is that health authorities will be able to make arrangements for the disposal of remains when they are authorised to do so by virtue of section 47A.
Amendment 85 adds a new section after section 47A that will place a duty on health authorities to give a woman the opportunity to make a decision about what she wishes to be done with the remains following a post-24-week termination. That will have effect when it appears to the health authority that no decision has been made under section 47A. The new section allows women to make a range of decisions, including authorising the health authority to make the arrangements. When the woman does not wish to or is unable to make a decision, or when she does not inform the health authority of a decision, the health authority may make arrangements for the burial or cremation of the remains.
Amendment 86 inserts a further new section after section 47A. The effect of that is that a health body will be able to ask a woman if she wants to make a decision about arrangements for burial or cremation before the loss occurs in the case of a stillbirth. The health professionals must do that if they consider that it will be in the woman’s best interests to do so. The woman can choose to make the arrangements herself or to authorise the health body to make them. The woman will be able to instruct the health body to make the arrangements as soon as practicable after the loss occurs. Otherwise, the health authority must wait for seven days after the loss occurs.
Amendment 87 inserts a further new section after section 47A that sets out the process that a health body must follow when it is authorised before the stillbirth occurs to make arrangements for the burial or cremation of the remains. That authorisation is given by the woman by virtue of the section that will be inserted by amendment 86. If the woman has specified how she wishes the health body to make the arrangements, it must do as she has specified.
Amendments 88 and 34 make various changes to section 47B. Amendment 88 inserts a new paragraph so that section 47B has effect when it appears to a health body that no arrangements have been made by virtue of the section inserted by amendment 86. That means that, when a health body does not ask a woman what she wants to happen to the remains before the loss occurs, it must do so after the loss occurs.
Amendment 34 adjusts the drafting in relation to requirements around the keeping of information. That does not alter the effect of the provision; it provides consistency with similar duties throughout the bill. Amendment 37 replaces a reference to the “appropriate” form with the “prescribed” form in section 47C.
Amendment 39 adjusts the drafting of section 47D so that a health body can make arrangements for the burial or cremation of remains when it appears that no arrangements have been made or are being made. Amendment 40 adjusts the drafting of section 48 so that it refers to the burial or cremation of remains rather than their disposal.
Amendment 89 inserts a new section after section 49 that provides health bodies with various powers in relation to the burial or cremation of remains of a pregnancy loss that occurs before or on completion of the 24th week. The new section applies when a health body is authorised to make arrangements by virtue of section 54A. It allows health bodies to make the arrangements and requires them to comply with any wishes that the woman might express about the burial or cremation of the remains. If a woman authorises the health body to make the arrangements for burial or cremation of the remains as soon as practicable after the loss occurs, it must do so. Otherwise, it must wait for seven days after the loss occurs before making arrangements.
Amendment 90 adds an additional criterion to the circumstances that must be met before section 50 can have effect. It must appear to the health authority that no arrangements for the burial or cremation of the remains have been or are being made.
Amendment 93 provides a definition of appropriate health authority for the purposes of section 52A. It is given the same meaning as it has in section 56.
Amendments 58 and 59 adjust the drafting of section 54 to add additional criteria to the circumstances that must be met before section 54 applies. Those are that it appears to the health authority that no arrangements for the burial or cremation of the remains have been or are being made.
10:45
Amendments 94 to 96 make changes to section 54A. Amendment 94 adjusts the criteria that must be met for the section to apply to include the woman being in the care of a relevant health body, clarifying when the section will apply.
Amendment 95 makes changes to section 54A so that a health body may ask a woman what she wishes to happen to the remains of a pregnancy loss before that loss occurs. In some instances, that may be preferable for the woman, and the amendment ensures that it can happen. Where the woman makes a decision, the health body must follow her wishes.
Amendment 96 moves section 54A to after section 49, placing it next to other provisions dealing with the same subject. Amendment 97 changes the section of the bill to which section 55 applies. That has the effect of requiring health authorities to keep a register of information in relation to sections 47A to 54, which cover pregnancy loss on or before 24 weeks, post-24 week terminations and stillbirths.
Where it is known that a pregnancy will result in a stillbirth or will be lost, amendments 86 and 95 place health bodies under a duty to give a woman the opportunity to say before the pregnancy ends what she wishes to happen to the remains. Importantly, health bodies are given the discretion to decide whether it is appropriate to ask a woman in advance or whether it is better to wait until the loss has occurred.
In some instances, a woman who knows that she will lose her baby may wish to start making arrangements in advance. In other instances, the trauma of being told that her baby will be lost may be so great that it would be better for her to make the decision after the loss occurs.
The approach that is set out in the amendments means that a health body can act accordingly depending on the interests of each individual woman who experiences such a loss. If the health body considers that it would be better not to ask a woman before the loss occurs, it is nonetheless still a duty to give the woman the opportunity to decide after the loss occurs.
Amendments 86 and 95 have the effect of allowing health professionals to use their judgment as to whether it is better to raise this difficult subject with a woman before or after the loss occurs. That approach ensures that a woman’s best interests are always the priority. It will always be the woman who makes the decision.
The intention of amendments 86 and 95 is to ensure that no woman is required to make that decision before she is ready to do so. The amendments provide that flexibility and person-centred approach.
The effect of amendments 86A and 95A in Malcolm Chisholm’s name would be to remove the health body’s discretion, meaning that, in every instance where it is known that a pregnancy will end or a stillbirth will occur, the health body must ask a woman what she wants to happen to the remains, regardless of whether the woman is ready to make that decision.
I think that that approach is unnecessarily rigid, removing the health professionals’ ability to judge whether a woman should be confronted with the decision before the loss has occurred. If amendments 86A and 95A are agreed to, it will mean that every woman will be asked what she wants to happen to the remains of her pregnancy loss or stillborn baby while she is still coming to terms with the fact that her baby has died.
I move amendment 76.