I congratulate Alex Rowley on introducing the debate, on shining a spotlight on the gross failures of Serco and on giving us an opportunity to express solidarity with the employees and, indeed, the travelling public, given that some of the defects on board the trains are potentially dangerous for the public as well as for the staff.
As we have heard, the franchise was awarded in 2014, with a commitment to replace rolling stock by 2018. However, with two years to go until that deadline is met, relations have deteriorated and conditions for employees and customers have got worse. In response to media questioning on 22 December, which was the day of the strike action, Peter Strachan, managing director of Serco Caledonian Sleepers, said:
“Both Serco, and more importantly over 1,000 of our paying passengers, are being hugely inconvenienced by this wholly unnecessary action by the RMT in the run-up to Christmas.”
I suggest that perhaps a greater inconvenience to the paying passenger is to travel in below-par accommodation where their safety is potentially put at risk and where the staff who serve them are intensely unhappy about the situation. RMT representatives have expressed frustration at the apparent resistance to addressing the key issues, which are highlighted in the motion and which are significant for Serco’s long-term ability to provide a value-for-money service. It is for that reason that RMT members backed industrial action by nine to one in the ballot.
The decision to award the contract to Serco was clearly unfortunate, given that management of the service thus far has been poor. Mike Cash, the general secretary of the RMT, pointed out:
“Our members have been unhappy with Serco’s management of the iconic service from Scotland to London since the very early days of them taking on this 15-year franchise. This is yet another example of Serco winning public sector contracts and failing to deliver for the tax payer, passengers and staff.”
I used to use the London to Edinburgh bit of the service when I was an MP. The extended route into the Highlands is perhaps one of the most iconic routes that exist in the country, and it is certainly a service that we can be proud of. For it to be operated by a controversial outsourcing giant and for the standards to have slipped so early in its tenure is a serious problem that speaks volumes.
Apart from the Serco issue, there are other issues. For example, in April last year, the general secretary of the Transport Salaried Staffs Association, Manuel Cortes, described the separate tenders for ScotRail and Caledonian sleepers as
“market fundamentalism of the highest order.”
He stated that
“every knowledgeable commentator argues that the biggest problem facing our industry is fragmentation.”
That leads on to consideration of wider problems in the railways, which I accept is more within the province of the UK Government than the Scottish Government. However, Christian Wolmar, who is acknowledged as one of the UK’s leading commentators on transport matters, has said that
“Fragmentation is the problem, not the solution”
and that there is
“only one way back to a rational cheap railway”,
which is to
“Bring all the disparate parts together under unified control ... that cannot be done without reintegrating the track and the trains.”
Fragmentation leads to inefficiency and, ultimately, higher costs for people and the kind of lower standards attested to by the RMT. Action for rail, which is the campaign for a railway that puts people before profit, argues that the privatisation of railways has led to a fragmented and dysfunctional system. I am glad that the Labour Party at UK level has policies to address that issue.
I hope that in the future Serco representatives will approach discussions with workers more constructively than they have done in the past and will do so with a mind to restoring and maintaining standards. My second hope is that the lessons that have been provided in this and previous contracts will serve as cautionary tales for future procurement decisions.
Having no choice should not be a viable reason for awarding a franchise. I hope that in the future the Government will provide evidence that all alternatives have been fully and properly explored and that it will consider other factors above immediate costs. Let us learn lessons for the future, but let us also do everything that we can to hasten resolution of the immediate problems.
17:34