There is no doubt that the Scottish Government’s named person policy is controversial. That is largely due to the remarks that we have heard from Tory members today and the Tory tabloids, which take great pleasure in whipping up concerns and fear among parents about a policy that, in reality, is about protecting the rights of Scotland’s children and ensuring that we provide our most vulnerable families with the support that they need, when they need it.
Members across the chamber have given examples of the fears that have been expressed and promoted, none of which is grounded in reality. The idea that there will somehow be a spy in every home, checking what we let our kids watch on TV or what we give them for tea, is not only far fetched but, as lain Gray said, “complete nonsense”.
lain Gray’s comparison with many of the scare stories that we heard in the early days of the European Union, such as the myths that were circulated about how we would be forced to grow straight bananas and rename British sausages, is a great parallel for much of the debate that we have seen around the named person policy. The reality is, as many members have highlighted today, that the named person policy is not about undermining the role of parents or questioning their authority; neither is it about providing a social worker for every child, as the Daily Mail would have us believe. It is about ensuring that information is properly shared, so that if and when issues appear in a child’s life, teachers or health visitors—who already have a duty of care towards our children and already have a role in our children’s life—are able to better support children and families before problems become severe.
As members across the chamber have said, in many respects, the policy just formalises an approach that is already tried, tested and working well in many local authorities, such as Fife, Edinburgh and Highland. It provides parents with a single point of contact and improves information sharing and multi-agency working. It allows problems to be identified and appropriate support to be provided at the right time, to stop families reaching crisis point.
Barnardo’s Scotland points out that it is
“essential to have a universal early warning system to identify the children who are most vulnerable”.
As Malcolm Chisholm and other members have pointed out, the child who is at most risk is often the one who has not been identified as vulnerable. That is why the named person provisions have the overwhelming support of not only Barnardo’s but almost every child welfare organisation, including Youthlink Scotland, Save the Children, Children 1st, Who Cares? Scotland and parenting across Scotland, which many members have highlighted.
Although Scottish Labour supports the policy in principle, we have concerns about its implementation. We reject the scaremongering that was encapsulated in Ruth Davidson’s newspaper article at the weekend and the political games that the Tories have embarked on with their motion, but we also believe that the Scottish Government has a lot more to do to genuinely get it right for every child and, in particular, to sell the named person policy to parents.
As John Pentland highlighted, we have said at each and every stage that the named person policy must work in practice and be properly resourced. Of real concern is the impact on Scotland’s health visitors, who are already stretched to the limit, as Neil Bibby said. Only yesterday, the Royal College of Nursing warned of staff shortages and highlighted its concern that many of our health visitors are due to retire over the next five to 10 years. When Murdo Fraser raised that issue, the minister’s response was welcome, but the reality is that health boards across Scotland are struggling to recruit and retain health visitors. Many have a large number of vacancies they simply cannot fill. With community nursing staff already working flat out, there is a real danger the extra demands of acting as named persons could increase stress, sickness and staff turnover levels, unless the policy is properly resourced.
The Scottish Government’s named person policy is well intentioned, and Scottish Labour supports it, with qualifications. However, it will only work if it is properly resourced, and right now, as lain Gray said, we are seeing resources squeezed, not provided. Whether we are talking about our NHS, our councils, our police service or our teachers, our front-line services and staff are under growing pressure. Mark Griffin highlighted many of the challenges to those services and staff, including challenges of delivering and resourcing children’s services plans.
We need to ensure that the available resources that are allocated to support the policy are weighted according to need and targeted so that they reach the most vulnerable children and families. That is the approach that Labour puts at the heart of our policies and our plans. We want to ensure that funding always follows the children who are most in need.
If the Scottish Government wants to make the named person policy work and if it wants to gain the support of parents across Scotland as well as that of the professionals on the ground who are expected to take on the additional roles, there is an urgent need to explain much better to parents what the policy is and is not about. I am pleased that members from across the chamber, including Labour members and SNP members such as Stewart Maxwell, have echoed that sentiment.
Scottish Labour wants the best possible protection and support for our children, but there is no denying that, in all our communities, parents have real concerns about the named person provisions. It is time for the Scottish Government to take those concerns on board, to do much more to communicate with parents, children and young people about what the policy means for them and to address the current shortfalls that prevent us from getting it right for every child.
It is no good getting the principles right if we cannot deliver, yet time and again we pass laws only to fail when it comes to ensuring that they are implemented effectively. Therefore, let us not just pass laws to get it right for our children; let us ensure that the laws are backed up with the necessary resources, support and practical guidance to ensure that they really make Scotland better. That is especially important right now, at a time when welfare reform means that more children and families are reaching crisis point.