I thank colleagues from across the Parliament who have signed my motion and made this debate possible.
General practitioners at the deep end are those who work in the 100 most deprived populations in Scotland, based on the proportion of their patients with postcodes in the most deprived 15 per cent of Scottish data zones. I apologise now for the fact that my speech will contain an awful lot of statistics, but I think that they will help to emphasise the case that I wish to make. The statistics show that people who live in such areas are likely to attend their general practice more often and will need longer appointment times, because they are likely to present with more than one health issue at a time. That, in turn, means that GPs with even a small or average-sized patient list in those areas are likely to have a greater workload than their colleagues in more affluent areas, simply by dint of their geographical locations and the health issues that their patients have.
To understand the situation, it is helpful to compare the statistics. Across Scotland, the average prevalence per 100 patients of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease—COPD—is 2.21. I repeat: that is 2.21 patients out of every 100. In the Balmore practice in Possilpark in my constituency, that jumps to 4.18 in every 100. At the other end of the scale, in a relatively affluent area of Glasgow, Hyndland, the figure is only 0.63. The figure is 0.63 in Hyndland, it is 2.21 on average in Scotland and it is 4.18 at a particular practice in my constituency.
The equivalent statistics for smoking-related ill health show that 24.87 people per 100 is the average figure for Scotland. The Balmore practice has a figure of 29.17, and Hyndland has just 13.6. It is no wonder that GPs in practices such as Balmore are frustrated and angry about their predicament and that of their patients.
It is widely recognised, and has been for a very long time, that men and women in the most deprived fifth of the population will die 10.4 and 6.9 years earlier, respectively, than those in the least deprived fifth.
The fact that disturbed me most—it was new to me when I read it first, I have to confess—and which has been the catalyst for this motion and debate, is the difference in healthy life expectancy, which is the estimate of how many years people are expected to live in a healthy state. Looking again at the most deprived fifth and the least deprived fifth of the population—the two extremes—we find that the figures could not be more stark. The healthy life expectancy of men and women in the most deprived fifth ends 20.8 and 20.4 years earlier, respectively, than for those in the least deprived fifth. That potentially means 20 years of productivity lost for individuals and their families—20 years, possibly, of pain or discomfort, and potentially 20 more years of stress and anxiety. That is not right, and it cannot be acceptable.
Practices such as Balmore provide their patients with an excellent service. The team of doctors and nurses and the pharmacist work together to continue to do so. However, they are struggling to do everything that they want to do and everything that they are expected to do within their existing resources.
In summary, GPs at the deep end are dealing with patients who have higher levels of multimorbidity at a younger age. Those patients need longer appointments and more follow-up and support. The average spend per annum in those practices is £118 per patient per year, compared with the Scottish average of £123, and £127 per patient per annum in the most affluent fifth.
If those general practices have no additional funding for recognising the difficulties and problems that they and their patients face, it stands to reason that the staff in those practices are working longer hours in more challenging circumstances, and that that will eventually affect recruitment and retention. There is even a name for that phenomenon: the inverse care law. It states that the availability of good medical care tends to vary inversely with the need for it in the populations that are served.
In their submission to the consultation on a fairer Scotland, the GPs at the deep end stated that that is
“not a law of nature ... but a longstanding man-made policy which restricts access to care based on need.”
It is surely time to end that situation and to recognise that we have a particular set of circumstances that puts huge demand on the deep-end practices and everyone who works in them. We surely have to find a way of funding GPs that does not take a one-size-fits-all approach. Across the country, we have already witnessed GP practices without those problems and issues experiencing problems with recruitment and retention of staff. It is sheer dedication and commitment that is keeping many of our GPs in post at the moment.
The First Minister’s announcement yesterday of additional funding for GP training is good news, but how long will it take to filter through the system and make a difference? We need more action now to avert escalation of this crisis.
In July, the Balmore practice sent an 11-page open letter to the health board; I am sure that the Minister for Sport, Health Improvement and Mental Health has had an opportunity to see that for himself. The letter detailed the problems that are faced and made some suggestions about solutions. Fortunately, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde has decided to give the practice some additional support and help. That is welcome, but it is not a long-term solution and it seems to me that such practices need long-term solutions.
In closing, I can do no better than to quote again from the submission that the deep-end practices made to the Scottish Government’s consultation on a fairer Scotland—a document that actually did not talk about their particular predicament, in any case. The submission said:
“Equitable access to emergency care has been a shining example of the NHS commitment to comprehensive health care, based on need and free at the point of use. A similar commitment is needed to reduce inequitable access to non-emergency care, especially general practice, and to reduce social variations in access to specialised and centralised services.”
That is surely a sentiment that we can applaud, and one that our policy and funding should support.
17:12