Yes, convener. Thank you for the opportunity to introduce these draft regulations to be made under section 271A of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003. The draft regulations will deliver the Government’s stated intention to ensure that the scheme that is provided for in the 2003 act can operate effectively in the present secure estate. They will fully deliver the Millan report’s recommendation
“that patients should have a right of appeal to be transferred from the State Hospital or a medium secure facility to conditions of lower security”
by extending the right that is already in force for patients in the state hospital to patients in the three medium-secure units in Scotland.
The Government’s stated intention was set out in initial draft regulations that were provided to the committee on 24 April to assist in your consideration of the provisions in the Mental Health (Scotland) Bill, which is now an act of the Scottish Parliament, having received royal assent on 4 August. The draft regulations that the committee is considering today differ from those that were provided in April in only two respects. I shall deal with each regulation separately and will highlight where there has been an amendment.
The 2003 act introduced a requirement for applications to the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland from patients in the state hospital and those in medium security to be accompanied by a supportive report prepared by a medical practitioner. Regulation 3 is an addition to the April draft regulations. It amends the 2003 act so that the medical practitioner must be an “approved medical practitioner”, as defined in section 22(4) of the 2003 act.
As approved medical practitioners have been approved by a national health service board or by the State Hospitals Board for Scotland as having special experience in the diagnosis and treatment of mental disorder, they have the necessary expertise to assess and determine whether a patient requires to be detained under conditions of special security in the state hospital or whether the test in the regulations is met for patients in qualifying hospitals.
Regulation 4 remains unchanged and lists the three medium-secure units in Scotland. Patients in those “qualifying hospitals” will benefit from the regulations through the extension of the right of appeal against being detained in conditions of excessive security.
Regulations 5 and 6 set out the test that must be met for the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland to grant an order declaring that the patient is being held in conditions of excessive security and requiring the relevant health board to identify a suitable hospital with the appropriate level of security. The test focuses on the key issue of the risks that the patient may pose to themselves and to others. After all, the purpose of security in psychiatric care is to provide a safe and secure environment for patients, staff and visitors that facilitates appropriate treatment for patients and appropriately protects the wider community. It is only when the level of security that the patient is subject to is greater than necessary to manage those risks that a lower level of security can be considered.
The draft regulations that were issued in April included reference to the risks to a patient’s safety that other persons may pose. That reference has been removed following consultation that highlighted concerns about patients being detained in conditions of excessive security due to the risks posed by others.
With that, I am happy to field any questions that the committee may have.