Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Alzheimer’s and Dementia Awareness (PE1480)

Tuesday 17 September 2013 Public Petitions Committee About 11:15–11:45 Petitions 39 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The third petition today is PE1480, by Amanda Kopel, on behalf of the Frank Kopel Alzheimer’s Awareness Campaign, on Alzheimer’s and dementia awareness. Members have a note by the clerk and the SPICe briefing on the petition. I welcome the petitioner. Thank you for coming. Dr Susan Logie is a consultant in old age psychiatry.

I invite Mrs Kopel to make a presentation of around five minutes. Graeme Dey is also here to support the petition. Mr Dey is free to intervene as he wishes when we are going through the questions.

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

Good morning and thank you very much for allowing me to speak to you today.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have lost my husband, even though he is still living. Alzheimer’s and dementia are a tough subject. Those two words bring fear to the hearts of so many people: to the ones who live with it, for whom it is a true hell on earth, and to the families of those who suffer, who try to bring back the person they knew and loved. We lose them before they die.

My husband, Frankie, was a professional footballer who started his career in 1964 as a 14 and a half-year-old apprentice at Manchester United. He went on to play for Blackburn Rovers, Dundee United and Arbroath and finally became assistant manager at Forfar Athletic. He did not earn the enormous wages that the footballers of today earn. When his football career ended in 1983, he continued in full-time employment until a few years ago. He was diagnosed with vascular dementia the week before his 60th birthday. At that point, he was a very fit, active man.

Frankie turned 64 in March this year. This man when asked now does not even know how to sit down, never mind how to kick a ball. Every day is a battle, which Frankie is never going to win, with his progressive terminal illness. It is also a constant battle for me with officials and red tape—one that I hope will change after today.

The disease behaves differently in each person’s body. It is no respecter of age, creed or colour or how much money you have in your bank account. Frankie did not ask to be diagnosed with dementia, but I find that he is discriminated against by having to pay for personal care because he is under 65. Free personal and nursing care was introduced in Scotland in July 2002 for people over 65. We pay almost £350 per month for his personal care, which covers 45 minutes’ input each day to give him a shower in the morning and get him ready for bed at night.

I would love to have been able to continue to carry out my husband’s personal care, but his dementia has progressed to the point at which that is no longer possible. It should not matter whether someone is 55 or 75: all personal care should be free in Scotland to all people with dementia when they are assessed as needing it, regardless of the figure on their birth certificate.

I, like others in my situation, am asking, begging and pleading for change to enable us to live what precious life we have left together to the full. I am asking for change so that I do not have to make choices, such as whether to take Frankie out for a run in the car—which he enjoys—to get a coffee and cake, or to buy a Kylie so that he does not lie on a urine-soaked bed. Such a change would ensure that our loved ones’ human dignity and safety is not compromised.

The lack of provision of free personal care for people with dementia under the age of 65 needs to be reviewed urgently. No one under 65 with dementia should be discriminated against. Ladies and gentlemen, I know that I am not the only one who has lost a loved one to this awful disease. I need to know that I have done everything in my power to ensure that Frankie has the best possible quality of life. I cannot make the relevant changes, but I know that you can, and I ask you now to please start making those changes today. Thank you.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, Mrs Kopel, for that very moving account of your family circumstances. You touched on what seems to be a key issue, which is the need to extend free personal care to dementia sufferers of any age, rather than providing it only for those over 65. Is that the key point of your petition?

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

Yes—it is about free personal care for those under 65. What does age matter when it is the same illness? It is the same disease whether someone is 65, 66, 76, 45 or 46, but those under 65 have to pay for personal care while those over 65 do not. Many more younger people—those under 65—are being diagnosed with dementia, and, as I think Dr Logie will agree, some of them are not even reaching 65 because of what is happening in their brain. They have a very strong body, but their brain is rapidly dying. Seven, eight or nine years ago, I was one of those people who thinks that dementia is only an elderly person’s disease, but now it has come to our door, and it is a horrible disease. I really feel that those under 65 are being discriminated against because of their age.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do you feel that the public are aware of the huge problems that dementia creates, particularly as we are all growing older, which may lead to greater problems in the future? Dr Logie may want to say something on that too.

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

Since we started the campaign, because of my husband’s profile, I have become aware that dementia can happen to anybody. There is now a great deal of awareness about dementia, and you are right that a lot of people are now living longer. Unfortunately, some of those under 65 are not being afforded the opportunity; they will be dead before they are 65 so they will not even get their free personal care.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Dr Logie, on the issue of those under 65, I suppose that the public are generally aware that, as people grow older, there is a greater chance that they will develop dementia, but they perhaps do not understand that the disease also affects those under 65. Is the number of patients in Scotland who are under 65 and have dementia growing?

11:30

Dr Susan Logie Susan Carnegie Centre, Stracathro Hospital
link

I do not know whether it is growing, but I think that there is probably greater awareness. The Scottish Government’s figures show that there are about 2,500 people with dementia under 65 in Scotland, and about 200 people a year are diagnosed with it.

Dementia covers a wide variety of different illnesses. It can sometimes take longer for people under 65 to get a diagnosis because the condition is much rarer at that age. Someone might present as having depression, or they might see a neurologist, and it can take quite a long time for them to be diagnosed.

People under 65 who have dementia also face a particularly difficult financial situation. It is often a very insidious illness, so they may have been underperforming at work for years or not paying their tax properly. If they run their own business, they might be running into financial difficulties because they are not performing as well as they usually would. They may have mortgages or school-age children, or they may have elderly relatives themselves. They have not reached pensionable age and may not have been able to save for their old age. They are often in the prime of life and would be expected to have reached their highest-earning capacity, and then they develop these illnesses. In my experience, such people struggle more financially than those over 65 do.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I suppose that this might be a difficult question, but how do we know the number of people who are undiagnosed? By definition, that is almost impossible to do. It may be that even experienced GPs do not necessarily pick up the fact that a 30-year-old is suffering from dementia. That must be a real issue in our health service in Scotland.

Dr Logie
link

That is right. More often, it affects middle-aged people: two thirds of those with a diagnosis of dementia under 65 will be over 55. However, those people might turn up looking as if they might have stress-related memory difficulties or depression, and women might be misdiagnosed as having menopausal problems. Even with the best will in the world, it can take a while to diagnose such cases, because the diagnosis involves looking at global cognitive deterioration over at least six months. At present, the GP needs to see a history of things deteriorating over a considerable period of time before they can make the diagnosis.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Is the diagnosis very categoric? Do you need to use brain scan technology?

Dr Logie
link

Yes—we would usually do some detailed neuropsychological testing of someone that age. A psychologist would see them and study the performance in different areas of their brain, and there will be scanning. People of that age may need more intensive investigations in order to exclude other causes, so they may need to be seen by a neurologist. It is often quite a difficult diagnosis to make.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. Does Graeme Dey wish to make any points at this stage?

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

No—the points have been very well made. I would be interested in exploring, beyond the issue of free personal care, how geared up the health service is to cope with this group of people.

Dr Logie
link

This group of people is often looked after by old age psychiatry services, which is perhaps a bit awkward. Most such services in Scotland will be the same as ours, in which we look after everybody over 65 with any mental health issue and people under 65 with dementia. They are—slightly awkwardly—put in with older people in that sense, yet they are not getting the free personal care that the other people whom we look after are getting. The younger people are often fitter and more active, at least in the beginning, and they may have completely different tastes to older people. There are differences between someone who is 55 and someone who is 85—even, for example, in the type of music that they like to listen to.

In some rural areas, such as Angus, it is difficult to organise specific services for such a small group of people that are also local enough to be accessible. That tension always exists in a rural area. In the cities, it is probably a bit easier to organise specific services or specific day care.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

On that last point, there are 3,200 dementia sufferers under the age of 65—

Dr Logie
link

There are 2,500, I think.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Is there a localisation? Is dementia in younger people predominant in any one area of Scotland? Does it occur more in the cities or in rural areas, or on the west coast or the east coast?

Dr Logie
link

Not to my knowledge. There is more alcohol-related brain damage and dementia in the west of Scotland, but I am not aware of any major differences between the major areas.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Mrs Kopel, the petition states:

“There are other uphill battles faced by families. Sometimes these battles are with the DWP”

and

“Health Authorities”.

Could you expand on that, please?

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

Yes. When Frankie was first diagnosed, our GP said, “Right, Amanda, you have to apply now for benefits,” because Frankie was going to lose his job. I had never done that before for him, but I did it anyway. I remember the doctor saying to me that day, “Amanda, once you get everything in place, you can concentrate on Frankie, because this is going to be a very difficult road for you.”

The first gentleman who came to see us became quite good friends with us, but I remember that he walked in that first day and said, “I’m not going to shake your hand, Frank, because you’re an Arab.”

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

You will know exactly what that means, then. Obviously, that comment broke the ice a bit. That gentleman started to complete the form, but his words to us were, “Well, I don’t think you’ll get anything, Frank, because you look all right.” That was the first step we took.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Sorry, but was that man from the Department for Work and Pensions?

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

He was from the local jobcentre and he brought the DWP form. He came back six or seven months later—Frankie had started to deteriorate by then—and he said that we would be able to claim something. He said, “My father had dementia,” to which I replied, “Well, you should have known, then. If you knew that six months ago, you shouldn’t have made that remark then.”

I have had five years of constant battles with the DWP, form filling and going through the rigmarole of someone on the other end of the phone asking whether Frankie can do this or that—for example, go on a bus. I tell them “No. My husband is dying in front of my eyes and he cannot do that.” The final word before I got off the phone—I wish I had £1 for every time that someone said this to me—was always, “I hope he gets better soon.” In an ideal world, I would love it if, the minute someone phones up those departments and says that they have a husband who has dementia or Alzheimer’s, the reply was, “Right. I’ll put you on to someone who understands what you are talking about.” I would love my husband to improve, but it is never going to happen.

I know that the DWP and the Government are trying to sort out the benefits system to make it simpler for people, but all my energy goes into looking after Frankie. I should not—

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

I have a support worker coming in from Alzheimer Scotland—Mrs Brodlie—who is very good. I have a good family and good friends. Frankie goes to day care five mornings a week, usually from 10 o’clock to 1 o’clock, to give me a wee bit of respite. However, I was told last week that, because he is deteriorating and because they do not have dementia status, they are now struggling to cope with him. He has gone to that day care for the past year and a bit, but he is now going to have to go somewhere else. As Dr Logie said, the only places that Frankie can go to have people in their late 70s, 80s and 90s. I feel that they do not have facilities for the under-65s.

Frankie and I have been married for nearly 45 years. We grew up together; in fact, we have been together for 50 years—a lifetime. I want to do the best I can for him. If that means keeping him at home until he passes away, that is what I want. I would like to keep him at home and not to put him in a nursing home, where he will not get the care that I will give him.

I get £3.81 a day carers allowance from the DWP for looking after my husband. That is because I am 63 and I get my small state pension. I do not get the full married woman’s state pension. I get £42-odd a week from the Government. According to the rules and regulations—which I understand—because I did not pay enough big stamps in my working life, I am not allowed to claim the full carers allowance. I get £3.81 a day, which is insulting.

We still have a mortgage to pay. We pay gas and electricity. Because of Frankie’s condition, our heating is normally on; even in the summertime, it is on low. The bills are going up. We still have to have a phone. Because his dementia is changing, his taste buds and so on are changing. We still have to have our insurance. There is wear and tear on things. Things add up, such as mattress protectors—we have to have two or three of those—and duvets and blankets, because he is now doubly incontinent. When he gets up during the night, he can go from bed to bed. If he has soaked the bed, I have to put him in another bed. It is very stressful for me, but I love this man to bits.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That was a vivid and distressing comment on the finance side, which must add so much extra pressure to you.

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

It does. A few years ago, they said, “Frankie, you’re allowed working tax credit”, so we filled in the forms and so on. About 18 months ago, we were told, “You have to repay it because we made an error.” It was nearly £4,000. We were told that we should have gone on to pension credit. Even up until two weeks ago, they were still hounding my husband for the overpayment.

I started to pay some of it back, but expenses and so on are getting on top of us. Our solicitor, who is trying to fight it, argued with the DWP that, if it had given us the right information first time round, it would have put Frankie on to pension credit, and the amount owing to the state if the DWP had stopped it would have been in the hundreds, which would have been repayable. It is like anything in life: if you have never been in that position before, you do not know.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It may be that you are already dealing with it, but it may be one for your local MSP or MP to take up. I would certainly recommend that you do that.

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

Yes. Thank you. Two or three months ago, Atos sent us a brief letter—I know that it had to do it—to say that one of Frankie’s benefits would be stopped unless we could provide it with details about how bad he was and come through to a tribunal in Edinburgh to get him back to work.

11:45

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I certainly recommend that you seek advice from elected members.

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

I am trying to make the point that these are all stressful situations. I should not have to be battling that. Not only is my husband in this battle but I am battling for him. When these other things come in day by day—they come in about once a week—it takes away from the care that I want to provide for my husband.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Thank you for bringing your petition to us this morning. You have identified an area that you have ably demonstrated is overlooked currently within the system. We all understand that, sadly, your experience is one that ever more Scots will face. It is no longer something that is set to happen in the future; it is happening to families across Scotland now. Indeed, it might not be an exaggeration to say that at some point every family will have a direct rather than indirect experience of it. In fact, Alzheimer Scotland estimates that 3,200 people under the age of 65 have dementia.

As Dr Logie said, the emerging group will be people in their late 40s who may well be substance misuse recoverers of some sort, for whom the onset of dementia at an earlier stage in life than we might have anticipated is an unexpected consequence. I cannot presume to know the view of the committee, but I think that this is certainly a matter that will be pursued.

I think that you have partly answered this question. Clinicians say that there is no breakthrough treatment on the immediate horizon. As health spokesman for my party, I regularly meet clinicians and ask the question. Whenever I ask, I am always told that it is 15 years away. When I asked seven years ago it was 15 years away and it is still 15 years away now. Some major breakthroughs that were anticipated had to be withdrawn at the last minute, because unforeseen consequences were found. Developing such treatments is a long slow process.

I am interested in Mrs Kopel’s experience. Given that more families will have to face Alzheimer’s and dementia, is the education and training for families and their preparedness currently pretty inadequate? Over and above the issues directly addressed in your petition, which calls for support to be provided for people with dementia who are under the age of 65, something more fundamental needs to be looked at to aid the early understanding of families who will have to face the issue and to give them comprehensive guidance about what they might need to do and how they might need to access support.

Amanda Kopel Frank Kopel Alzheimer's Awareness Campaign
link

Definitely. There has to be more education and awareness. I was asked to speak at a Royal College of Nursing conference on dementia earlier this year to say what it was like from the point of view of a younger person with dementia. The feedback that I got from the delegates was amazing. They said that they learned quite a bit when I told them our story. Alzheimer’s and dementia is now getting mentioned more often, but it must be more of a priority across the board to educate people about it, even in schools and suchlike. The young people now are the possible future sufferers of dementia.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Unfortunately, we are a little short of time. As no other members have questions, I ask the witnesses to hold on for a few minutes as we will look at the next steps on the petition.

I think we all agree that Mrs Kopel’s situation with her husband is a very moving example. We will certainly contact the Scottish Government to ask for its views on the petition. We might also clarify whether there are any moves to reduce the age of eligibility for free personal care. I think that the Government has made some statements about that in the past and it might be worth getting some clarity, because Mrs Kopel made the point that it is the absolutely vital aspect of care. We will also seek the views of Alzheimer Scotland and other groups.

I seek the views of committee members. Do you agree with that course of action?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Yes, I agree with that. The number of people in this group is growing, but I do not think that the numbers are growing in such an alarmingly unmanageable way that they could not be accommodated within the system.

Given that this is a devolved Parliament and some matters are still reserved to Westminster, I would be interested to know what liaison there is between the two health departments in trying to pull together the necessary advice for Alzheimer’s sufferers. In the first instance, I would be interested to know the Scottish Government’s view on that. It may well be that the issue is made harder for people than is necessary because of the political process that we have put in place. If so, that would be most unfortunate and we ought to be able to correct our approach. Such a situation would be unique to the devolved Administrations, given that in England and Wales health matters are under the control of a single entity.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are there any other action points that members wish to suggest? Do members agree to the course of action that has been suggested?

Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As you have heard, we are enthusiastic about pursuing the petition, so we will write to the Scottish Government and a number of other agencies. Obviously, we will keep you up to date with developments.

I thank Mrs Kopel for appearing before the committee. I know that it must have been difficult to explain your very difficult family circumstances with regards to your husband. I also thank Dr Logie and Graeme Dey for their attendance.

I will suspend the meeting for a minute to allow our witnesses to leave.

11:51 Meeting suspended.

11:52 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Current Petition Petitions · 77
  2. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 61
  3. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 32
  4. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 39
  5. 11:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 11:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  7. 11:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  12. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. 12:00 Witness Expenses Evidence session · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.