Towards the end of his letter to us, Mr Ivanov spells out the response of his local authority. When his local authority threatened to go on a landowner’s land to clean it up, it was threatened with legal action by the landowner for trespass. If such confusion exists at local authority level, it is clear that there needs to be a change in the guidance that is issued to local authorities and the action that is taken.
In one of the bullet points in his response to the committee, the policy manager in the Government’s directorate for local government and communities says:
“We are not aware of any evidence that Amenity Notices are routinely ignored or not complied with.”
At the same time, the petitioner is being told by his local authority that it is not willing to take any action in case legal action is taken against it.
As Jackson Carlaw has pointed out, there seems to be confusion out there. I argue that, if the situation is confusing for local authority officials and they feel that it is inappropriate to take legal or enforcement action against landowners, there is something wrong with the guidelines. I suggest that we write back to the Government, make it aware of the petitioner’s response and seek clarification of whether the directorate for local government and communities gathers information from local authorities or has surveyed them to find out whether there are problems with enforcement notices being issued.
The directorate says that
“less than 1% of enforcement notices result in prosecution.”
Is that because of the failure of local authorities to take enforcement action? Is it realistic to say that, with 99 per cent of enforcement notices, the issue is resolved without a prosecution? We should seek clarification of those issues before we close the petition.