I begin by thanking colleagues from across the Parliament, including those who will take part in the debate, for their support for the motion. I welcome to the gallery members of the Scottish fire sprinkler co-ordination group, whose membership includes members of the European fire sprinkler network, the national fire sprinkler network and the Chief Fire Officers Association, as well as members of the insurance industry and representatives of care organisations. The British Automatic Fire Sprinkler Association is a founding member of the group, which is hosting a lunch-time event in the Parliament, and I hope that members will be able to attend it. It is somewhat ironic that the event is being held in the Burns room—given the topic of the debate, the less said about that, the better.
No one can forget the tragic deaths at the Rosepark care home in Uddingston in January 2004, which resulted in the death of 14 residents. After the fatal accident inquiry into the fire, which looked, in particular, at the cause of the deaths, Sheriff Principal Lockhart found that some or all of the deaths could have been prevented if the home had had a suitable and sufficient fire safety plan. I trust that, following the publication of “Practical Fire Safety Guidance for Care Homes” by the Scottish Government in March 2014, no care home is in that position today.
There is no doubt that Scotland has made significant progress in fire safety and prevention and in the use of fire sprinkler systems, which is one of the best protection mechanisms. I pay tribute to Michael Matheson, whose member’s bill, the Fire Sprinklers in Residential Premises (Scotland) Bill, paved the way for that progress.
In 2009, the Scottish Government commissioned the report “Scotland Together: a Study Examining Fire Deaths and Injuries in Scotland”, which concluded that the installation of sprinklers in all Scottish homes was not cost effective. More recent evidence, including a new United Kingdom cost benefit analysis of residential sprinklers by the Building Research Establishment, does not challenge that underlying conclusion, but the BRE says that residential sprinklers as an additional safety measure are cost effective for all residential care homes, including those for elderly and disabled people and children; most blocks of purpose-built flats and larger blocks of converted flats; and traditional bedsit-type houses in multiple occupation in which there are at least six bedsit units per building. It considers that residential sprinklers in two-storey houses that are shared would not be cost effective.
In the Scottish Parliament, we recognise that we cannot make decisions without taking cognisance of cost, but we should always ask, “Of what cost is a human life?”, whether that be the life of a resident, a staff member or a firefighter. Firefighters face considerably fewer dangers when they attend a fire in a property that is fitted with a sprinkler system.
In May 2005, the Scottish Government led the rest of the UK when it introduced new mandatory building standards that required the installation of sprinklers in all new-build enclosed shopping centres; residential care buildings, including care homes and boarding schools; sheltered housing complexes; and high-rise domestic buildings. At the time, the installation of sprinkler systems in all new-build dwellings, such as houses, could not be justified on cost grounds, but we know that the Welsh Government has taken the decision to have sprinklers installed in all new-build domestic properties.
In October 2010, the revised building regulations introduced in the domestic handbook, which gives technical guidance, sprinklers as an option to protect common escape routes in low-rise domestic buildings. Sprinklers were introduced in new primary and secondary schools to support sustainable development by providing enhanced property protection against fire. I am sure that the minister will touch on some of those areas.
As far as affordable housing is concerned, “Scotland Together” found a link between social deprivation and an increased risk of fire fatality, with 40 per cent of accidental dwelling fire deaths occurring in social rented housing and 31 per cent in the Scottish index of multiple deprivation 15 per cent most deprived areas. As a result, a targeted approach to sprinkler installation in social rented homes, council houses or housing association-owned dwellings was rolled out across Scotland, but I know that councils such as Fife Council and Angus Council are installing sprinklers in all new-build council properties. To them, it is a no-brainer to protect not just their residents, but their financial investment in the new properties.
As the convener of the cross-party group on accident prevention and safety awareness, I know that one of the biggest challenges that we have to overcome in fire sprinkler use is the normalisation of their use in our communities. The very fact that both the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service and the British Automatic Fire Sprinkler Association have myth-busting sections on their websites tells us that the safety advantages and the protection of property, life and our fire officers in attending fires should be at the forefront of our discussions, but we are still talking about the myths that surround fire sprinklers.
On its website, BAFSA says that one of the biggest myths
“about sprinklers is that they are expensive and difficult to fit into existing buildings and thus it is rarely practical to fit them after initial construction. In order to determine the truth”
of that,
“BAFSA funded a pilot project to install sprinklers in a Sheffield tower block. This project proved conclusively that it is possible and cost-effective to retrofit sprinklers into an existing high-rise block without first having to relocate the tenants”
or causing major disruption.
There is also a myth that installations cannot be done on a fast-track basis, which has been proven not to be true. On myths around the costs, at around £1,150, the installation cost per flat is reasonable, given sprinklers’ effectiveness in protecting the investment in the property and in the protection of life, which, as I said, should always be at the forefront of our discussions. Tenants, residents and their families feel safer knowing that they are better protected when they live in a building that has a sprinkler system in place.
We also know that sprinklers greatly reduce the potential trauma and disruption to individuals following a fire, as they very much restrict fire damage.
As I said, retrofitting sprinklers as part of a major refurbishment project to meet current building standards can be done reasonably and without major disruption.
I know of many care homes and residential properties that were built, or were in operation, before the new building standards came in. I hope that the message of retrofitting is fully understood and that raising awareness of retrofitting may prompt action to ensure that the use of sprinklers, as the very best form of preventative fire protection, can be extended to the whole community in Scotland.
12:42