I congratulate Jean Urquhart on securing the debate. In local newspaper week, I have to say that life would not be the same without a weekly read of the Linlithgow Gazette. I welcome the chance to speak in this timely debate and I thank members for the interesting and informative comments that we have heard. There is a widespread debate in Scotland about the relationship between the media, political power and democracy, and there is also a belief that critical and well-supported journalism is essential to a thriving democracy—Jamie McGrigor made that point.
For our part, public engagement with politicians and the media’s critical analysis of our work inside and outwith Parliament are essential to building and maintaining trust in the political process. It is essential to ensure the continued participation of people throughout Scotland in shaping our nation’s future.
Malcolm Chisholm talked about the role of social media, particularly in elections. A thriving media sector that supports diverse job opportunities, training and development is important, and a press and media environment that values, respects and champions quality journalism is essential to our future. We should also note, recognise and appreciate the role of the new publication The National.
The levels of engagement in September’s referendum and during the UK general election campaign have been rightly celebrated and it is heartening that so many people feel that they have a voice in the critical decisions that affect us all. However, despite such high levels of engagement, we find ourselves at a time of great change in how the media delivers its content and ensures its continued relevance amid changing perceptions of what constitutes international, national and local.
Nowadays, I can consume information from a variety of media outlets, with news in many languages and from many perspectives at my fingertips. Such easy access to a plurality of information is a challenge to our traditional modes of consumption and engagement and it can have an unsettling effect when what seems to be established fact is quickly challenged by another point of view. That is positive for the quality of debate, but it changes our relationship with the media and challenges our ability and appetite to distinguish between opinion and fact, which might also impact on our levels of trust in media institutions, at least in the short term.
To sustain a flourishing democracy in Scotland, we will need diverse and independent voices across the media. However, the media continues to be concentrated in a handful of corporations and individuals who have considerable power over our news, cultural life and access to information. That was a focus of John Finnie’s speech. Decisions about the newspaper industry, such as decisions on merging titles, deskilling and the laying off of good journalists, are often made with scant regard for the impact that such decisions will have on the media’s ability to support democracy, political engagement and high-quality debate in Scotland.
We have seen job cuts throughout the media sector, including at the BBC. On print journalism, Graeme Dey warned of the vicious cycle of deteriorating circulation and standards in the media. The move to go online is also creating an ever more economically challenging environment for the print media. Circulation figures in February show reductions in the past six months across most major titles of between 5 and 15 per cent, and there have been closures at a range of media organisations. Of course, some publications have moved successfully to online circulation that pays.
Such challenging times for print journalism are leading to increasing domination of the industry by a smaller number of large media organisations. That is a challenge for industry regulators and one of the reasons for the loss of trust in the media that we have heard about today.
Alternative new media platforms have sprung up rapidly in the past few years, and access to local and social media provides many opportunities for voices to be heard on a range of issues. An example of that comes from Jean Urquhart’s work on xenophobia earlier this year, which made excellent use of exactly that kind of opportunity. However, the ability of digital intermediaries, such as search engines and social media giants, to filter information threatens to create new monopolies that will undermine positive developments.
As the traditional print media adapts to respond to the digital age, it is critical that local voices are still heard and that high-quality local journalism and media remain vibrant and continue to develop. The launch of local TV services in Edinburgh and Glasgow earlier this year and the forthcoming launches in Aberdeen, Ayr and Dundee are an interesting development. The risks and opportunities for the media in Scotland at this time must be assessed, and we must address the issues facing us, particularly where trust has broken down, in order to rebuild the relationship with people across Scotland.
As members know, the Smith commission proposed new powers for Scotland over broadcasting, and today’s debate is well timed as we enter this critical period. The continued work to implement proposals on independent press self-regulation is also key to rebuilding trust in our media and helping to address structural issues.
I am committed to making sure that we seize the opportunity and promote continued public debate so that we can sustain and develop diverse media outlets that can generate positive engagement with politics, the Parliament and the important issues facing society, thereby ensuring that everyone has a voice in Scotland’s future. I want to see a national debate with politicians, the industry and—critically—the public to ensure that we fully understand the vision for media in Scotland and the key issues that we want to address, from BBC charter renewal to support for independent producers across Scotland and support for vibrant and diverse print and online media.
I look forward to a lively and informed discussion of the issues with colleagues across the chamber and throughout Scotland. This is a critical agenda that matters. I am pleased and grateful that Jean Urquhart brought the debate to Parliament.
13:05 Meeting suspended.
14:30 On resuming—