I thank my colleague and friend Hanzala Malik for lodging his motion and securing cross-party support for it, and I thank members for their eloquent and articulate but also insightful speeches. I will try to touch on a few of them.
I think that I speak for everybody when I say that this is one of those members’ business debates that we would rather not be having, but nonetheless it gives us the opportunity to express our solidarity with the people of Pakistan, the Pakistani community worldwide and those who stand in defiance against terror.
I note, as other members did, Hanzala Malik’s personal endeavours in fostering closer relationships between Scotland and Pakistan, and indeed between his and our beloved city of Glasgow and Lahore. He has done well to foster those links and they are strong and enduring.
Members will be aware that Pakistan is a country that is close to my heart and close to Hanzala Malik’s heart because of our family connections. My father was born there and, although my mother was born in Kenya, her parents came from Pakistan. Hanzala Malik has family from Pakistan, too. However, such was the depravity of this attack that it did not matter whether somebody had a link to Pakistan. People felt the absolute suffering, the anger at what happened and the absolute sadness of the events that took place regardless of whether they have such family connections.
I want to touch on a couple of points that were made in the debate. It is worth while to reiterate a point that Hanzala Malik made in his opening speech. Pakistan is up there with the countries that have suffered the most—if not the country that has suffered the most—because of the so-called war on terror. For a country that had nothing to do with the incident that led to the war on terror—the dreadful attacks on 9/11 on the twin towers in New York—it has, as Hanzala Malik said, lost $80 billion from its economy, tens of thousands of innocent people have been killed and millions have been displaced from their homes. Kenny MacAskill was also correct to remind us that countries in the developing world are the worst affected by terror.
Countries such as Pakistan continue to suffer from terrorism, as we saw from the attacks on 16 December. Who would not be moved by what we saw on our television screens? Those images will stay with us, chillingly, for ever. The children’s shoes scattered across classrooms, blood-soaked jotters, desks riddled with bullet holes—that is not what a school should look like.
I pay tribute, as Malcolm Chisholm and Johann Lamont eloquently did, to the bravery of those children who returned to their school in Peshawar just yesterday. The children of Pakistan must be the bravest in the world, if we think of those who have returned to school and, of course, Malala Yousafzai as well. Children who have been fired at and been the target of Taliban brutality have not thought twice but have gone back to the very school where their schoolmates and playmates in the playground lost their lives less than a month ago. I salute them and stand in absolute admiration of their courage.
So horrific was this attack that, when it took place, it was even condemned by the Afghan Taliban, who are not known for their compassionate streak by any stretch of the imagination. Such was the brutality of the attack that even the Afghan Taliban said that it was “unIslamic”.
I think that, as a result of the attack, there has been a step change in Pakistani attitudes. It would be wrong to say that there was not some modicum of sympathy for the Pakistani Taliban in Pakistan. There was, as those who have travelled to Pakistan and those who know the Pakistani community will know. That was not born out of any belief that what the Pakistan Taliban was doing was correct. It was probably an anti-western reaction more than anything else, and Kenny MacAskill made an important point in that regard.
When we are fighting terrorism—and we have every duty to do so—we must be careful that we do not give terrorists any ammunition or get them any public sympathy because of unjust actions such as the drone attacks that have taken many innocent lives, or by not being careful enough about who we support on the global stage. The Taliban is a classic example of that, coming out of the mujahideen, which was trained by the United Kingdom, the United States and other western forces. We must be careful that we in the UK, in Scotland and in the rest of the western world, are voices of compassion and that we do not give terrorists any ammunition whatsoever.
Colleagues have touched upon the fact that one of our friends, Councillor Jahangir Hanif, lost two family members, and I express the Scottish Government’s condolences to him and his family. I know that Hanzala Malik and Mr Hanif are very close. If I am right, they are also related, so my sympathies go to them all.
Hanzala Malik touched on the important point that education is vital to ensuring that we defeat the scourge of terrorism and radicalisation. I am pleased about the project that Anne McTaggart mentioned for the scholarships that have put girls and women through university, and we will look to build on that. The refresh of the Pakistan plan that we are aiming at could look to promote gender equality more strongly than it has done in the past.
Education is certainly the key to defeating radicalisation. Yes, there is no doubt that a military solution is needed—those who will take up guns against children have to be defeated—but if we want to defeat radicalisation we must recognise that we cannot kill an idea with a bullet. We have to challenge it through education.
That gives the Muslim community a big challenge in relation to al-Qa’ida and ISIS-inspired terrorism: the challenge is for moderates within the community to ensure that we are educating people in the progressive Islam that we know is the core of the religion.
There is also a challenge for us all when a common enemy, such as that which we face through the worldwide extremist threat, will kill anybody, Muslim or non-Muslim. If there is a common enemy, there must be a common solution and we must stand in solidarity. We must not allow those who seek to divide us to do just that. An assault on one must be seen as an assault on us all.
Meeting closed at 17:52.