Of course a currency union is desirable. I desire a currency union as well. That is why I will vote no next month, and that is why Alistair Darling will vote no next month.
The First Minister, writing in the Sunday press this weekend, said:
“The language of politics can be ... instructive and deeply revealing as to the motives and priorities of individuals, parties and campaigns.”
How true. So what of his language on currency?
“It is our pound and we’re keeping it, come what may.”
“No currency union, no debt.”
That is indeed deeply revealing, because it is not the language of someone whose motive is to liberate the Scottish economy. It is the language of someone threatening to take the Scottish economy hostage and blow it up if he does not get his own way. What it promises is a Scotland without its own currency, without a central bank, with no say whatsoever on monetary policy, and without any credibility with lenders. That is a recipe for impoverishment, not a plan for jobs.
The National Institute of Economic and Social Research summed up the situation coolly last week. On sterlingisation, it stated:
“This is likely to have important consequences for Scotland’s financial sector, and therefore its capacity to export financial services, its new balance of payments and general economic prosperity.”
In other words, 200,000 jobs in the financial services sector and 15 per cent of our exports would be in jeopardy, just for starters.
As long ago as December, the economist David Owen of Jefferies LLC told us that walking away from debt would raise the cost of borrowing by 5 per cent. Investment would be hit, public finances would suffer and mortgages would go up.
What is more, membership of the European Union requires a currency and a central bank, so a sterlingised Scotland would not be able to stay in the European Union—[Interruption.] Scottish National Party members may scoff, but if they can explain to me why the European Union would break with its whole history and allow in a country without a central bank or its own currency, I would be very interested to hear them.
Even the Scottish Government’s own fiscal commission dismissed the option of sterlingisation out of hand, and yet that is now the Scottish Government’s desperate fallback currency plan. Perhaps Mr Swinney should direct his boss the First Minister, rather than the rest of us, to read what the fiscal commission has said. If the First Minister had read it, he would not describe the option as “quite attractive”.
The most irresponsible thing about the currency car crash is that the potential victims are not the banks and businesses of Scotland but ordinary Scots. They will not be able to make the higher mortgage payments, move their money out of Scotland to somewhere else or up sticks and follow jobs if companies relocate them.
I believe—I say it again—that Scotland’s best economic prospects lie in the currency union with the rest of the United Kingdom and with the Bank of England as lender of last resort, just as I believe that our best platform for economic success and full employment is a single energy market; a UK-wide financial services industry; a home market of 63 million people with open unfettered borders across our countries; continuing membership of the European Union but not the euro; MOD contracts such as the one for aircraft carriers and the one that we heard about this morning; and access to UK-wide research funding for all our universities.
Those are things that we have; only independence places them in jeopardy. That is why I lodged the amendment and why we should vote positively, proudly and resoundingly no on September 18.
I move amendment S4M-10769.1, to leave out from “can be” to end and insert:
“benefits from being part of the UK currency union, which is one of the oldest, strongest and most successful in history; considers that keeping the pound and the current arrangement within the UK economic and political union is in the best interests of Scotland and that the only way to keep the pound on present terms is to vote to stay in the UK; believes that Scotland benefits from being part of the deeply integrated UK economy, which is the third largest economy in Europe and the sixth largest in the world; considers that being part of the large and diverse UK economy provides strength and stability to Scotland’s finances; believes that, as part of the UK economic union, Scotland is afforded protection from unexpected economic and financial shocks; considers that Scottish businesses have unfettered access to a domestic market 10 times the size of Scotland’s population and that it is imperative that this remains the case; believes that Scotland benefits from being part of an integrated economic union and that the pooling of tax income ensures that public spending in one part of the UK is not exclusively dependent on the taxes raised in that area, meaning that, if one part of the UK is disproportionately impacted on by an economic downturn or slow growth, public services in that area are not forced to assume all of its impact, and considers that the best future for Scotland is for a Scottish Parliament with more powers and enhanced accountability within a strengthened union”.
14:43