I will not go into set-up costs. I have here, of course, the figure that the UK Government came up with when it came up with set-up costs, which is 12 times the cost that was estimated by Professor Patrick Dunleavy. Of course, his figure of between £150 million and £200 million for set-up costs was well rehearsed. Also, it was mentioned that those costs would be recouped through efficiency savings.
The point about uncertainty is what I want to move on to. Although we have said that we will preserve continuity of employment and have cemented that by saying that we have a policy—as members are aware—of having no compulsory redundancies, no such commitment is forthcoming from the UK Government. That is where the uncertainty about the DFID jobs lies. In fact, even members in the Opposition parties have not committed to having no compulsory redundancies. Those in the Labour Opposition have not committed to no compulsory redundancies. Ed Balls has not committed to having no compulsory redundancies. If he has, please would members intervene and tell me otherwise? I did not think that he had.
When it comes to the threat to DFID jobs, that threat comes from the UK Government. Here are some of the things that Margaret McCulloch’s good friend, Michael McCann MP, has said.
He has said:
“I have also made it clear that compulsory redundancies should be avoided at all costs”—
he does not realise that his party has not quite made a commitment to that—
“and have asked the Minister to keep me updated with any developments.
It seems to me that the Government isn’t doing all it can to protect British jobs.”
Margaret McCulloch’s very good friend Michael McCann has also said:
“Today my worst fears have come to pass, despite the department’s previous denials. Staff”
at DFID
“were called to a meeting and told in excess of 140 jobs will go ... But more than that”
Andrew Mitchell
“owes it to the staff to reverse this crazy decision.”
If Margaret McCulloch does not believe me, perhaps she will believe Michael McCann, and if she does not believe her very good friend Michael McCann MP, perhaps she will look at DFID’s accounts, as other members have. The International Development Select Committee examined and scrutinised those accounts, which show clearly—in the graph that I am holding up—that the number of staff will reduce in 2014-15. The threat to jobs comes not from a yes vote but from the status quo.
The Scottish Government has an ambitious vision of the role that Scotland could play as a good global citizen. We have committed to the 0.7 per cent target that the UK has finally met—I have been fair in commending the UK Government on eventually getting there. It took a Conservative Government to get us there; in her motion, Margaret McCulloch says that the UK Government has “at last” reached the target.
It is important to realise that the 43 years for which the target was missed represent £87.5 billion of missing aid. That is not something to be proud of. In the 1970s, Sweden was the first country to reach the target, in 1974. In 1975, the Netherlands met it. In 1976, it was Norway and in 1978, it was Denmark. All four of those countries have consistently met the target. What do they have in common? They are of course small independent European nations.
Malcolm Chisholm said that there is no way that Scotland could have the same impact as the UK; he almost questioned the audacity of Scotland even to think that it could have the same impact as the rest of the UK. My point is simple—we should look at contributions to development according to the CDI, which is the index that his colleague Margaret McCulloch mentioned. On that index, the UK is in a commendable eighth position, but the other nine of the first 10 countries on the index are small independent nations. That index does not rank countries by their size in monetary terms; it ranks them by their impact—their contribution—and what they have achieved on the world stage in tackling poverty.
Our vision for international development goes above and beyond what some members have suggested a small country should seek to do. We want to legislate for the 0.7 per cent and we want to do aid better. We will of course work with the UK Government to do that, and with any Government that wishes to achieve that.
I am disappointed that a members’ business debate has been used for such a distasteful motion, which is intended to scare hard-working civil servants across the country. I give the absolute assurance again that, in the case of a vote for independence, we will preserve continuity of employment for not just DFID staff but hard-working civil servants across the country.
Meeting closed at 17:58.