A much calmer Christine Grahame and a calmer debate than the last one.
On 26 September, I attended the launch of a Capital Credit Union outpost at Penicuik North kirk. That sounds like something from the wild west, but it is actually a partnership with Capital Credit Union in Edinburgh and churches of other local denominations, such as St Mungo’s and St James the Less. Volunteers, trained by Capital Credit Union, help run the service. Some of them made it through the storms and are in the public gallery tonight.
The church provides the premises free of charge, and Lothian presbytery provides the furniture. I am a member of Capital Credit Union—I should have declared that sooner. As members know, because they are all well informed, credit unions are financial co-operatives that provide savings, loans and a range of services to their members. Importantly, they are non-profit making. They are owned and controlled by the members—a bit like the old Trustee Savings Bank, which I think you might remember, Presiding Officer. Each member has one vote, and volunteer directors are elected from the membership, by the membership and for the membership.
Membership of a credit union is based on a common bond. That can be working for a particular employer or in a particular industry, or simply living or working in a specified geographical area, which could be as small as a village or as large as several local authority areas—or, in this case, the size of Penicuik.
Credit unions encourage all their members to save. That word, “save”, is key. Members can pay in directly by payroll deduction or through benefit direct accounts; through retail payment networks such as PayPoint and Payzone; by standing order or direct debit; or in cash at local offices and collection points. They offer an affordable source of credit to their members. “Affordable” is another key word—we are not talking about loans that lead the borrower into personal financial crisis. In fact, credit unions are more responsible than the so-called responsible banks were or indeed are.
Credit unions are prepared to make small-sum and shorter-term loans that most banks and building societies do not offer. However, interest on credit union loans is always much lower than that charged by doorstep and payday lenders.
For example, home credit companies such as Provident openly advertise typical annual percentage rates of 399.7 per cent, while payday lenders such as Wonga can charge rates in the order of 5,853 per cent. Loan sharks can charge even more outrageous interest rates. Incidentally, credit unions’ interest rates for savers are not that bad, either.
At the North kirk, there is already a food bank, and the outpost is a further practical church initiative that is introducing people to the old-fashioned way of saving and borrowing responsibly. As I said before, the credit union is a not-for-profit organisation. The loans that are offered are on the basis of a proper look at what the person can afford, so that they do not get into trouble.
The initiative follows a special commission that was undertaken by the Church of Scotland in 2012, which called on the Kirk, society and our Governments to take action on four priorities: reducing inequality; ending poverty; ensuring sustainability; and promoting mutuality. The report encouraged the use of credit unions, commenting that, with the new breed of pawn shops, payday loans, cheque cashing and instant internet loans, it is easy for the unwary to fall into a debt trap.
In 2014, the Church of Scotland’s General Assembly took up that theme and encouraged all members of the church to save and to borrow with a credit union. I would encourage all members in the chamber, and people outside the chamber, to do that, too. That is what Penicuik, through its churches, is doing.
The facility is open from 10 am to 12 noon on Mondays, and 2 pm to 4 pm on Fridays. The target was to sign up two new members to Capital Credit Union each week. In the first few weeks of operation, with a team of trained volunteers, the credit union has signed up 28 new members, thereby exceeding that target. Each of those people will have opened a savings account with Capital Credit Union. In addition, a loan has been taken out in that time.
I quote the Rev Ruth Halley of the North kirk:
“Joining a credit union is a great way to support ethical banking. Credit unions are responsible lenders and offer affordable credit. They also encourage us to save as well as borrow and are ‘not for profit’. ... This can be of real benefit to all the people of Penicuik, and the more people who join the greater that benefit will be. I’ve already joined, and I hope that everyone who lives or works here will join too.”
I encourage all members who are not yet members of a credit union to join one. The interest on savings is quite good and it is an ethical way to save that allows others to borrow responsibly. Better still, credit unions provide mutual funding for people who may not be able to access banks otherwise.
I congratulate the churches on their involvement. I am not a member of a church—I am an atheist—but I like to see churches putting their money where their mouth is. I commend the churches of Penicuik, which are doing just that. They are carrying out practical work in the community—first, through the food banks and, now, through the Capital Credit Union outpost—to encourage people in the community and to help those who may need a bit more help. I wish the pilot well and look forward to local credit union facilities being extended, following in Penicuik’s footsteps.
17:11