I, too, thank Linda Fabiani for securing this debate on world mental health day and for giving us the opportunity to debate the critical issue of mental health.
In response to Sandra White’s question, Linda Fabiani mentioned early diagnosis and institutional issues. For many people, the issue is not only early diagnosis but a lack of diagnosis.
Although the motion shines the spotlight on schizophrenia, many issues that relate to that condition—including difficulties with getting employment, discrimination, stigma and shortened life expectancy, which other members have mentioned—also apply to most other mental health conditions.
The motion highlights the work of the East Kilbride support group. I also acknowledge the work of the Highland users group on mental health—HUG—which is very competently managed by Graham Morgan.
As a member of the Health and Community Care Committee, which scrutinised what became the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003—to which nearly 3,000 amendments were lodged at stage 2—I hoped that there would be significant improvements in early diagnosis, early intervention, appropriate treatment and support, with people not parked on anti-depressants, and that there would be access to cognitive behavioural therapy and other therapies, psychology and psychiatry specialists and advocacy and treatment with dignity and respect. I hoped and trusted that all the issues that we discussed in the first session of the Parliament would be significantly improved more than 10 years later.
However, I have looked at a recent briefing paper from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, and I doubt the progress and success of the previous legislation. I will quote directly from that paper without my glasses. It said:
“Despite its longstanding position as a priority within health policy it remains the case that mental health services do not receive the same degree of focus (or funding) as other disease areas ... Mental health is responsible for”
23 per cent
“of the disease burden”,
but it gets 11 per cent of the budget, and
“The life expectancy of those with severe mental illness is on average 20 years less for men and 15 years less for women”.
It said:
“depression is associated with ... a 50% increased mortality ... a three-fold increased risk of death”
in subsequent years in respect of coronary heart disease, and
“There is a disparity in research spending”,
which particularly applies to schizophrenia. One of the United Kingdom health research funders showed that mental health got 6.5 per cent of total funding, despite 23 per cent of patients suffering from such conditions.
The recent Health and Social Care Act 2012 for England sets parity for mental health and physical health. I would be thrilled to bits if that were the case in the Scottish Parliament. I hope that it will be.
We—especially Richard Simpson and others—have often spoken about dual diagnosis. We have spoken about people with mental health and drug and alcohol addiction issues. We know that many people use alcohol and drugs as self-medication to mask and cope with mental health issues. That is in the paper from the Royal College of Psychiatrists.
The paper talks about services for older people and dementia. It says:
“Access to psychological”
and other services
“is much poorer for older people”.
The RCP makes plenty more points in its briefing. It is still
“concerned at the lack of Adolescent Intensive Psychiatric Care Units in Scotland. Young people with a need for this are required to be admitted to an adult ICPU.”
It also mentions the consultant vacancies in psychiatry, although I appreciate that psychiatrists are not the only specialists. It is disappointing to read about all the issues that are raised in the royal college’s paper given that they were also raised 11 years ago when the Parliament passed mental health legislation.
Other members have mentioned their experiences of trying to help constituents to find support, particularly in relation to personality disorders. The time taken to diagnose such conditions and the transition from child to adult services, which needs to be looked at, are poor.