1. To ask the Scottish Government what account the business case for the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme takes of the impact that construction work could have on passenger numbers. (S4O-02867)
Keith BrownSNPThe Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
The “Edinburgh Glasgow Improvement Programme: Final Business Case” includes provision for compensation paid under the rail regulatory regime for planned disrupted access to the rail network.
The minister confirmed in written answers earlier this year that 28 trains stop at or pass through Dalmeny every day at peak times. Under the plans that are outlined in the business case, an additional 28 trains will be diverted at peak times while the Winchburgh tunnel is closed. How does the minister expect that to be managed such that he can still meet the commitment that he made in a previous written answer that
“all connections will be maintained”—[Official Report, Written Answers, 1 October 2013; S4W-17247.]
during the tunnel closure?
Keith BrownSNPThe Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
In the past, I have provided information about how Network Rail and others intend to manage the disruption, which is inevitable with a capital improvement project of this type. Buses will be used, as I have mentioned previously. Work is continuing to minimise the length of time for which that disruption will occur. All the partners involved are doing a great deal of work to minimise the disruption, but disruption is inevitable if we are to make the substantial improvements that are required, many of which should, in my view, have been made decades ago.
According to the Government, the failure to construct the Almond curve on the line will mean that the Winchburgh tunnel will close for a minimum of 44 days at a cost of £10 million that will have to be paid in compensation to ScotRail. That will mean 44 days of expensive travel disruption across central Scotland. Will the minister look again at that crazy decision with a view to building the Almond chord, thus investing in much-needed infrastructure and avoiding the waste of scarce public funds?
Keith BrownSNPThe Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
I am sure that all the experts who have been involved in the process, such as Network Rail, the engineers and Transport Scotland, will take note of the member’s reference to a “crazy decision” but, of course, the alternative that Neil Findlay proposes would be to spend upwards of £60 million on a chord that would be superseded by EGIP—in other words, much of it would be abortive expenditure. We are not in the game of wasting that level of public resource—his party might have been previously, but we are not.
As I have said, I see the period of 44 days to which Neil Findlay refers as a ceiling rather than as the minimum period of disruption. We are working very hard to bring it down from that, and we will put in place appropriate measures to ensure that we minimise disruption by providing alternative forms of transport.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.