Good morning. I welcome you all to this historic meeting of the Public Petitions Committee. As always, I ask everyone to switch off their mobile phones and other electronic devices, as they interfere with our sound systems. We have received apologies from David Torrance.Agenda item 1 is consideration of three new petitions. As previously agreed, the committee will take evidence from the petitioners.The first new petition is PE1500, by Stuart Housden OBE, on behalf of RSPB Scotland, on the golden eagle as the national bird of Scotland. Members have a note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and the petition.Normally, of course, we would have Mr Housden in front of us, but I understand that he is on urgent business. However, we are delighted to have at the meeting Mr Duncan Orr-Ewing, who is head of species and land management at RSPB Scotland, and Gordon Buchanan, who is a very well-known wildlife film-maker.I have also received apologies from Rhoda Grant MSP, who is the species champion for the golden eagle. She has passed on her support for the petition.I invite Mr Orr-Ewing to make a short presentation of around five minutes, which will be followed by questions from me and my colleagues. Obviously, Mr Buchanan should feel free to intervene during our session.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
National Bird (PE1500)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Duncan Orr-Ewing RSPB Scotland 25
- Jackson Carlaw Con 18
- Gordon Buchanan 9
- Chic Brodie SNP 8
- David Stewart Lab 7
- Angus MacDonald SNP 3
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
71 contributionsI will give a very brief introduction and then hand over to my colleague Gordon Buchanan to give a bit of detail about his experience of working with the golden eagle, which is a fantastic bird.We consider the golden eagle to be a true bird icon of Scotland, one of our most majestic animals and a suitable symbol as Scotland’s national bird. We call on the Scottish Parliament to place it alongside the lion rampant, the saltire and the thistle as an emblem of this country, which we think could be achieved through simple legislation or a parliamentary motion. We believe that there is a public mandate for that, as the bird was recently voted the biggest species attraction by Scotland’s public; indeed, it polled 40 per cent of more than 12,000 votes in Scottish Natural Heritage’s year of natural Scotland poll. We regard that as a sufficient public mandate to nominate the golden eagle as Scotland’s national bird, and it builds on the public poll to find a national bird for Scotland that was run a decade ago by The Scotsman and championed by the Scottish Parliament’s Annabel Goldie MSP—the golden eagle was also the clear winner of that public poll.The golden eagle was long revered by our forebears. Many Highland chieftains wore eagle flight feathers in their headdresses as a mark of rank, and the eagle motif appears on no fewer than 18 of the historic arms of the clan chiefs. The Royal Scots Greys regiment has the eagle on its badge, and members of the Royal Company of Archers, who are the Queen’s guardians in Scotland, wear a golden eagle flight feather. The species is therefore strongly attached to our culture—and, of course, no less strongly to the Gaelic culture, particularly in the Western Isles and north-west Highlands, where even to this day a good number of places have the eagle as their motif.In his book “The Golden Eagle”, which was first published in 1955, the Gaelic scholar, piper and ornithologist Seton Gordon called the species the “King of Birds”.In Scotland, there are 440 breeding pairs of golden eagles, which represent the whole of the United Kingdom’s breeding golden eagle population. The species is regarded as Scottish.We therefore think that the golden eagle is a suitable species to be our national bird.I will hand over to Gordon Buchanan to give some reflections on his experience, as a film-maker, of working alongside this fantastic bird.
The greatest pity about golden eagles is that so few people get an opportunity to see them. Just last week, I was sitting halfway up a mountain in a very damp hide on Loch Katrine, in the pouring, driving rain and sleet—I have a very glamorous job—waiting for a golden eagle to show up.Golden eagles have long attracted a mystic reverence, not just in recent times but going back thousands of years. They have been depicted in some of the earliest art forms. It is a bird that human beings have appreciated and, in many ways, sought to emulate. As I was sitting in the hide, there was a whoosh like Concorde going overhead as the golden eagle landed in front of me, and I found myself looking at this magnificent creature. You can marvel at the millions of years of evolutionary forces that brought this thing into being or just appreciate its inherent beauty—and more: its power and intelligence. Scotland should have a national bird—something that we see as an emblem of our national identity—and the golden eagle is the only candidate.
Thank you. Again, I put on record our thanks to you for coming along. As I hinted at in my introduction, this is the 1,500th petition that the committee has received, which is a great achievement. The Parliament has received a wide range of petitions. I have always seen petitions as a sort of window between constituents throughout Scotland and the Scottish Parliament.I have two quick questions. First, you mentioned in your submission that having the golden eagle as a national bird would be very important for tourism. Will you say a bit more about that? Obviously, tourism is vital for Scotland, particularly for the Highlands and Islands. How will having the golden eagle as the national bird of Scotland make a difference?
We think that having a national bird shows a commitment by the Scottish people to the environment. We know that tourism is a very important industry in Scotland. A huge number of people come every year to experience not just our wild landscapes but our wildlife. There are various economic studies, including on the value of white-tailed eagles to the island of Mull. We know that white-tailed eagles are worth about £5 million per annum to Mull alone and that £276 million is spent on wildlife and landscape appreciation trips to Scotland, sustaining about 2,763 full-time equivalent jobs in this country.
Have you looked at Europe and, indeed, more widely to see what other countries have done in respect of adopting national birds?
Many countries have a national bird as one of their symbols. In Europe, our nearest neighbours in Norway have the dipper as their symbol—we have that species here, too. Finland has the whooper swan, Sweden the blackbird, Belgium the kestrel and France the cockerel. The United States, of course, has the bald eagle. The procedure is fairly routine in many countries.
I have had the pleasure of seeing golden eagles flying high in Lewis, Harris and Mull and over in Norway. This is an exciting petition, which I hope is successful. You have both promoted it well.As you will be aware, I have a members’ business debate in Parliament tomorrow to welcome the designation of the Scots pine as Scotland’s national tree. It makes sense that we designate a national bird, too. As a member of the Scottish Parliament’s Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, I have been closely following the debate in farming and crofting circles over the past few weeks about the increase in the number of white-tailed—or sea—eagles. I am told that sea eagles, in addition to the damage that they cause lambs, are starting to crowd out golden eagles. Would designating the golden eagle as Scotland’s national bird protect it from encroaching sea eagles?
Perhaps not, but it would give the golden eagle greater protection, because the species would be seen as one that belonged to all the people of Scotland. Some scientific work has been carried out on competition between the white-tailed eagle and the golden eagle, and there is little evidence of competition between them for nest sites and food. That is largely because, since their reintroduction, most sea eagles in Scotland nest in trees, particularly on the west coast, in places such as Mull and Skye, whereas the golden eagle tends to be a more upland, crag-nesting species—although we have tree-nesting golden eagles as well.Some scientific work has been done on the subject, and there is currently little evidence that the species are in competition with each other. As I said, the sea eagle is also a fantastic species that many people come to Scotland to see and observe. We recognise that there are some issues around farming interests and sea eagles, but hard work is going on behind the scenes to develop a solution.09:45
I think that recognising the golden eagle as Scotland’s national bird would offer it further protection, which it needs. Over the past two centuries, the species has been persecuted. Their number has doubled in the past 100 years, but that increase is not that considerable given the on-going protection that they are offered. Colleagues south of the border who appreciate wildlife are absolutely astounded that the persecution—the poisoning and shooting—of golden eagles continues. Giving the golden eagle Scotland’s national bird status will help to protect it further. It desperately needs that protection.
The sea eagle is very much a coastal and riverine species, whereas the golden eagle—at least in this country—is much more an upland species.
As you rightly say, Mr Buchanan, golden eagles are still being persecuted; indeed, we saw such persecution as recently as a few months ago with a golden eagle called Fearnan in Angus. Therefore, it is clearly still an issue.
Good morning. I think that Mr Orr-Ewing made the point that choosing the golden eagle would be a commitment by the Scottish people to the environment but, as has been said, people hardly ever see golden eagles. Can you expand on how designation would commit the Scottish people to the environment when few of them have seen a golden eagle, other than perhaps in films?
Not many people see golden eagles regularly, but when they do see one, they regard the experience as awe inspiring, as my colleague described. As we have seen in various recent public votes, including the year of natural Scotland vote, there is a huge attraction to the species. Much of the mystery that surrounds it relates to whether or not people know the good places to see it.
Is that because of the bird or the background against which it is professionally presented? One could argue that the osprey, which probably has as much romance attached to it, has an equivalent case.
Yes. Ospreys are, of course, a lowland species, and given that they nest in the same place every year, it is quite easy to show them to the public. To date, unfortunately, we have not managed to achieve a successful public viewing site for golden eagles, but if people go to places such as Arran, Mull and Skye, which are known to be good places for golden eagles, they have a very good chance of seeing them.
The rarest sight in the countryside is a schoolchild. Having two small kids, I know that, although there is a much higher awareness of the environment in schools, it is not quite enough. I think that making the golden eagle Scotland’s national bird would generate interest because there would be a tangible connection between Scottish people, including children, and that ultimate emblem of the wild. Scotland has amazingly accessible wildlife, but not enough people are prepared to get out there and do the little bit of groundwork that is needed.
I accept that, and I do not disagree that an aura surrounds the golden eagle. We have been talking about the species being Scotland’s national bird, but the blackbird that sits outside my door waiting to be fed every morning has, I am sure, the credentials to be our national bird.Given my earlier question, what do you mean when you say in the petition that golden eagles“capture the spirit of Scotland”?
It is about how we see ourselves as a nation. Are we powerful? Are we intelligent? Are we survivors in the way that the golden eagle is? There are other candidates, but there is a traditional respect for the golden eagle.At one time, the species was found throughout much of the northern hemisphere, and wherever it was found, human beings had a fascination with it. Scotland is beautiful, and the golden eagle is beautiful. Scotland is powerful, and the golden eagle is powerful. It is about making the fairly obvious link between how we see ourselves—or would like to see ourselves—and a part of our natural history.
It is worth adding that, but for the persecution problem that, as one of your colleagues mentioned, prevents the bird from becoming a lowland breeding species, we would have more golden eagles in lowland Scotland, as is the case in Scandinavia. Golden eagles are found in countries such as Denmark, where the land is no higher than 140m, and they are also lowland breeding birds in Finland and Sweden. In the absence of persecution, we could look forward to that in Scotland.
Okay—as long as we do not go for the seagull.
The substance of my question has already been covered. It is on whether, as a result of national designation of the species, persecution would cease or lessen. As my colleague Angus MacDonald indicated, although the number of birds that have been found to have been poisoned has fallen in the past year, there are still people who will persecute the golden eagle. Unfortunately, we might see the persecution of the white-tailed eagle taking place as well.Is enough being done to highlight and promote those two species—the golden eagle and the sea eagle—in order to discourage those who wish to go out and kill, poison or trap the birds?
The problem is on-going, and the reason that it continues to this day is that the birds live in such remote areas. Last week, I spent the whole day by the side of Loch Katrine watching a golden eagle, and I did not see another human being.For anyone with ill intent towards a golden eagle or a sea eagle, the designation of the eagle as a national bird would be an added incentive not to go ahead with destroying a nest, or shooting or poisoning a bird.We are talking about individuals who have their own relationship with the bird and what it means to them. Some perhaps see it as a threat to their livelihoods, but declaring it to be a national bird might give those individuals pause for thought.
It is worth remembering that it is a relatively small number of people—who are involved largely with driven grouse shooting, particularly in the east and the southern uplands of the country—who are involved in persecuting golden eagles. In most areas of the golden eagle’s range, particularly in the north and west Highlands and Argyll, the species is not illegally killed.
The golden eagle is a magnificent bird, but I challenge your petition in two respects. First, colleagues know that I am not terribly fussed about national things—we now have a national tree, and I am waiting to see all the tourists queuing up to come and see it. I wonder where it stops. Do we then have a national domestic animal, a national wild animal or a national grievance? The list could go on.Secondly, the golden eagle is the symbol of an empire that once invaded large parts of Scotland and, more recently, of another empire that tried to. Within the lifetime of many people in this country, it was the last thing that their relatives saw as they were marched to their deaths. It has been a symbol of imperial power, which Scotland is emphatically not, never has been and—I hope—never will be. Is an eagle, as the symbol of imperial authority, the right national symbol for a democratic nation such as Scotland, irrespective of the merits of the bird itself?
My response to that is to point to how the people of Scotland actually view the eagle. I think that Gordon Buchanan gave a very apt description of that, and it is not what you said.
I do not know that we have had a proper debate on that; I do not even know whether people have considered that point. For me, the robin is a much more accurate representation of Scotland, with its ability to face adversity and its tenacity. It is a bird that I think people across Scotland see all the time and have learned to love. Even if there were ultimately to be an agreement that such a thing should be agreed, rather than Parliament deciding perhaps there needs to be a much more extensive debate so that people can put arguments for other natural species to be considered or arguments against the eagle.Frankly, I am uncomfortable about what is proposed. I wonder how the eagle would come to be represented. Would it be an emblem that we would start to see? You said that you would like to see it alongside the saltire. That is very imperial. I do not know whether you have considered that. Whether you like it or not, an eagle fluttering on a flag in Scotland would be a representation of an association with something that has some very negative as well as positive overtones.
We understand that, but the public do not seem to view it in that way.
Oh!
Sorry, but I am just answering your question. We have now had two public votes, one of which was carried out by The Scotsman and with which your former leader Annabel Goldie was involved. That gave people the option to decide what our national bird should be. The clear front-runner at that time in the poll in The Scotsman was the golden eagle. Latterly, in the year of natural Scotland, we had another vote. Scottish Natural Heritage conducted that as an independent arbiter and, again, the golden eagle came out as the clear front-runner.
What was the question?
Well, you asked—
What was the question in the opinion poll?
The original question in the—
No, the one that you have just referred to: the Scottish Natural Heritage question. What was the question?
The question in the latest poll in the year of natural Scotland was about choosing between the big five species, as SNH saw it, that people regard as important in Scotland.
But that is quite a different thing, is it not?
Yes, but the previous poll that was conducted by The Scotsman was more about what should be Scotland’s national bird.
What was the question in The Scotsman poll?
It was a poll—
I am asking you what the question was.
I cannot remember the exact question, to be honest, but it was about choosing which species would be suitable as Scotland’s national bird.
So how many people participated in the Scottish Natural Heritage poll?
I think that the figure that I quoted earlier was 12,000.
They were asked to choose from a selection consisting of the golden eagle, the harbour seal, the otter, the red deer and the red squirrel.
That is correct, but I think that there was one other.
So they were not actually asked to choose from a selection of birds.
Not in that case, but the previous poll in The Scotsman did ask people to choose from a selection of birds that occur here.
And the question was—sorry, what was the question again? Can you remind me what you said the Scottish Natural Heritage question was?
It was to choose from the big five species that SNH considered to be impressive species that occur here in Scotland and that are an attraction to the public.
Is that the same thing as saying that they were voting for it to be a national symbol of our country?
No, but we think that it does give an indication of what the public see as an important and valuable species.
Okay, fine. I am not sure that I am persuaded, but I understand your position.How would you address the point that I made earlier about us having a never-ending stream of national this, that and the next thing? Would you say that the bird is it and that, once we have a bird and a tree, that is enough? Or are you quite open to us having Parliament endlessly determining—
Parliament?
Well, through parliamentary motions or legislation. Would Parliament endlessly be determining that things are the national something or other?10:00
I refer to Mr Stewart’s earlier comments about questions around national birds in other countries. It is quite standard procedure for countries across the world to have national trees and national birds, at least. I do not know about the other things that you mention, but those are the popular subjects for national emblems.
Perhaps this is just about where my interests lie, but I am not interested in having a national anything other than a national bird. To have a national tree is fantastic, however.The national bird is about drawing a link for Scottish children—it is about something that they can see and a part of their natural environment that they can be proud of. When people see the eagle as a symbol, they take that symbolism for what it means to them. It is about giving people an opportunity to have something that symbolises the wild part of our country.I think that it should stop after this. I do not agree with having a national animal. A golden eagle covers it all—it is an emblem of the wild in Scotland. I think that, if we show people a photograph or film footage of an eagle, they do not have thoughts of imperial tyranny; they see a wild, beautiful animal.
I entirely agree with that, although what you describe is not the bird as a national symbol being represented in the heraldry of the nation, which is quite different—but thank you.
I am afraid that we are very short of time, but we can have a very quick question from Chic Brodie.
This is on the point that you made about the public. What would the golden eagle, as a national symbol, mean to children in some of the inner-city parts of the large cities of Scotland?
I think that children living in all parts of Scotland should be given an opportunity once a year, as part of the curriculum, to get out and actually see a little bit of wild Scotland. There is nothing really being done, in that our children go to—
I understand that, but Mr Carlaw made the point that the robin can be seen by these children, as can sparrows, blackbirds and others. What specifically will the golden eagle mean to children in the inner parts of our larger cities?
It is a powerful, emotive symbol. That is why it is being used.
That is a concern. I am very supportive, and I do not necessarily disagree, but the point that Jackson Carlaw made is that we are talking about a very powerful bird. It is beautiful and it is powerful, but we have to match that across Scotland. I am talking about the spirit of Scotland, which you mentioned, and that embraces more than just the Highlands and Islands. We have to have some sort of affinity and identity that embraces all our children, not just a few who might see the power and beauty of this bird in actuality.
The bird that the majority of people see most often is the pigeon. If you want to go for a populist vote, the pigeon is accessible to everyone, but it does not necessarily do the job.
There is something in the aspiration. As a young person growing up, I had a strong interest in seeing birds such as golden eagles. We need to get children outdoors, and we know that that is important. The RSPB is a big provider of environmental education.About 70 per cent of Scotland’s land area is upland by character, and the golden eagle very much symbolises that. As I said earlier, in the absence of persecution, we could expect golden eagles to be in more lowland situations and available to the schoolchildren in Glasgow and Edinburgh you are talking about. We see a strong symbolism and a chance for the future. There is a link to aspiration, too.
I am afraid that we are out of time, but I ask the witnesses to hold on for a couple of minutes. We have finished with questions and points, so we now come to the summation, when the committee considers the next steps.My own view is that it is important to take the petition forward and to seek advice from some key organisations: contacting the Scottish Government, SNH and the Scottish raptor study group would be a sensible next step. As always, committee members might have their own views about alternatives, so I invite their thoughts on the next steps. Do committee members agree to those three organisations being consulted?
I certainly agree to those three organisations being consulted. When we write to the Scottish Government, would it be possible to ask whether it would be minded to conduct a consultation similar to the national tree consultation that was held by the Forestry Commission between September and December 2013?
That probably encompasses my point. The presumption that we are making is all of a sudden in favour of the concept of there being a national bird. I would like to know whether the Scottish Government thinks that that would add something. If so, does the Government feel that it would be appropriate for the public to be more widely involved in the choice of bird and for there to be a proper public debate and scrutiny around the question?
That is a good point.Are members happy to take that course of action? We will write to the three organisations that I have mentioned, and we will specifically ask the Government about holding a consultation, to be carried out with a sort of scientific poll and involving the public as much as possible. Is that a fair summary of the points made?Members indicated agreement.
I thank both witnesses for coming along. As you can hear, the committee is taking the petition forward. We will keep you up to date with developments. Thank you, in particular, for coming along to give evidence on the historic 1,500th petition.10:06 Meeting suspended.
10:07 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jan 2014 →- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 71
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 86
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 58
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.