1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01716)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Johann Lamont Lab 7
- Tricia Marwick 5
The record
20 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01716)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Muchas gracias.
Yesterday, the Spanish Prime Minister made it clear that, by leaving the United Kingdom, Scotland would also leave the European Union and would have to reapply as a new member. What part of that statement does the First Minister not understand?
Yesterday, the Spanish Prime Minister made it clear that, by leaving the United Kingdom, Scotland would also leave the European Union and would have to reapply as a new member. What part of that statement does the First Minister not understand?
I have here a full transcript of Señor Rajoy’s statement. This is how he starts:
“I don’t yet know what the White Paper says which was presented by the Scottish President yesterday.”
I have to say that promotion is always welcome, but I would like to point out that page 45 of “Scotland’s Future” makes it absolutely clear that Her Majesty the Queen will continue as head of state of an independent Scotland.
“I don’t yet know what the White Paper says which was presented by the Scottish President yesterday.”
I have to say that promotion is always welcome, but I would like to point out that page 45 of “Scotland’s Future” makes it absolutely clear that Her Majesty the Queen will continue as head of state of an independent Scotland.
I know that the First Minister likes to quote selectively, but that takes the biscuit. Looking for reaffirmation, where does he find it?
However, let us hear what the Spanish Prime Minister, Señor Rajoy, said.
“I would like that the consequences of that secession be presented with realism to Scots.
Citizens have the right to be well informed and particularly when it’s about taking decisions like this one ... I know for sure that a region that would separate from a member state of the European Union”—[Interruption.]
However, let us hear what the Spanish Prime Minister, Señor Rajoy, said.
“I would like that the consequences of that secession be presented with realism to Scots.
Citizens have the right to be well informed and particularly when it’s about taking decisions like this one ... I know for sure that a region that would separate from a member state of the European Union”—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I am not sure whether that is the defence that the SNP is going to prosecute. Dearie me.
Señor Rajoy said:
“I know for sure that a region that would separate from a member state of the European Union would remain outside the European Union and that should be known by the Scots”.
The Spanish Prime Minister is being straighter with the people of Scotland than the First Minister is. Since, in any negotiation, Señor Rajoy will have a veto, should the First Minister not listen?
Señor Rajoy said:
“I know for sure that a region that would separate from a member state of the European Union would remain outside the European Union and that should be known by the Scots”.
The Spanish Prime Minister is being straighter with the people of Scotland than the First Minister is. Since, in any negotiation, Señor Rajoy will have a veto, should the First Minister not listen?
I am not a president, I am a First Minister; and Scotland is not a region, it is a nation. [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The difference is that Scotland will be negotiating its position from within the European Union. There are three questions about that. Can that happen legally? Would it happen? Can the process be completed within 18 months?
I have here a letter from the head of unit of the European Commission’s secretariat-general, which addresses exactly the first question. It says:
“The ongoing democratic process is a matter for the UK and Scottish Governments and the Scottish people, and as you say, it would of course be legally possible to renegotiate the situation of the UK and Scotland within the EU.”
I will put the letter in the Scottish Parliament information centre, so that all members can have the benefit of it.
So, it can happen, legally. Would it happen? I cite Sir David Edward, who was the British judge on the European Court of Justice for 12 years and is the person who knows most about these arguments in Scotland. He says:
“In accordance with their obligations ... the EU institutions and all the Member States (including the UK as existing), would be obliged to enter into negotiations before separation took effect, to determine the future relationship within the EU of the separate parts of the former UK and the other Member States.”
So, yes, it would happen, because the obligation is to do it.
Thirdly—[Interruption.]
I have here a letter from the head of unit of the European Commission’s secretariat-general, which addresses exactly the first question. It says:
“The ongoing democratic process is a matter for the UK and Scottish Governments and the Scottish people, and as you say, it would of course be legally possible to renegotiate the situation of the UK and Scotland within the EU.”
I will put the letter in the Scottish Parliament information centre, so that all members can have the benefit of it.
So, it can happen, legally. Would it happen? I cite Sir David Edward, who was the British judge on the European Court of Justice for 12 years and is the person who knows most about these arguments in Scotland. He says:
“In accordance with their obligations ... the EU institutions and all the Member States (including the UK as existing), would be obliged to enter into negotiations before separation took effect, to determine the future relationship within the EU of the separate parts of the former UK and the other Member States.”
So, yes, it would happen, because the obligation is to do it.
Thirdly—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Thirdly, and crucially, having cited Sir David Edward, I will now cite someone whose authority cannot be questioned even by the better together parties: Professor James Crawford, who was appointed and paid by the UK Government to dispense legal advice on this matter. When asked the specific question about the 18-month timetable, he said:
“Well, the Scottish estimate is about 18 months, and that seems realistic.”
We have the European Commission, Sir David Edward, formerly of the European Court of Justice, and the person who was appointed by the UK Government, who says that the timetable is realistic. That is reasonably substantial evidence that Scotland as a nation can negotiate its position to full membership of the European Union.
“Well, the Scottish estimate is about 18 months, and that seems realistic.”
We have the European Commission, Sir David Edward, formerly of the European Court of Justice, and the person who was appointed by the UK Government, who says that the timetable is realistic. That is reasonably substantial evidence that Scotland as a nation can negotiate its position to full membership of the European Union.
I know what a nation is; the problem is that the First Minister does not seem to understand what a veto is. It does not matter who else he quotes, if there are 28 states with a veto they can use it if they choose to do so.
This is the First Minister who said that he had EU legal advice
“in terms of the debate”,
which did not exist in terms of reality. The President of the European Commission, Mr Barroso, has said that Scotland would have to reapply to the EU, and now the Spanish Prime Minister agrees with him. However, in Salmond’s world they are wrong. Here is negotiation Salmond style. Yesterday, he said that without Scottish electricity England’s lights would go off—as though he is Vladimir Putin and the rest of the UK is the Ukraine. What is the First Minister going to turn off in Spain—
Members: Fishing rights!
This is the First Minister who said that he had EU legal advice
“in terms of the debate”,
which did not exist in terms of reality. The President of the European Commission, Mr Barroso, has said that Scotland would have to reapply to the EU, and now the Spanish Prime Minister agrees with him. However, in Salmond’s world they are wrong. Here is negotiation Salmond style. Yesterday, he said that without Scottish electricity England’s lights would go off—as though he is Vladimir Putin and the rest of the UK is the Ukraine. What is the First Minister going to turn off in Spain—
Members: Fishing rights!
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
What is the First Minister going to turn off in Spain if it insists that Scotland is not in the EU? Is he going to threaten to blockade the North Sea again, as he did in June this year?
In terms of—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I am sure that Johann Lamont would not want to say something that the Spanish Prime Minister did not say. There was no mention of a Spanish veto in anything that Señor Rajoy said yesterday. However, the question has been addressed directly by the Spanish foreign minister, Señor García-Margallo. In response to that exact question, he said:
“If in the UK both parties agree that this is consistent with their constitutional order, written or unwritten, Spain would have nothing to say, just that this does not affect us. No one would object to a consented independence of Scotland.”
We have an extraordinary situation in which that is what the Spanish foreign minister says but Johann Lamont has the idea that Scotland is a place that no one else in the European Union would want as a member. This nation, with its huge natural resource base, would be welcome in the European Union. Not to realise and understand that point is not to get to grips with the matter. Scotland is a European nation and we want to be a European nation. The only question about our membership is coming from the Conservative Party, many of whom want to get out of Europe. They are the real risk to our EU membership. Can Johann Lamont not embrace the fact that Scotland will be welcomed as a member of the European Union?
“If in the UK both parties agree that this is consistent with their constitutional order, written or unwritten, Spain would have nothing to say, just that this does not affect us. No one would object to a consented independence of Scotland.”
We have an extraordinary situation in which that is what the Spanish foreign minister says but Johann Lamont has the idea that Scotland is a place that no one else in the European Union would want as a member. This nation, with its huge natural resource base, would be welcome in the European Union. Not to realise and understand that point is not to get to grips with the matter. Scotland is a European nation and we want to be a European nation. The only question about our membership is coming from the Conservative Party, many of whom want to get out of Europe. They are the real risk to our EU membership. Can Johann Lamont not embrace the fact that Scotland will be welcomed as a member of the European Union?
I used to say to my children, “What you want is not necessarily what you get.” The First Minister needs to understand that it is not his assertion that matters, but what people are entitled to do. If people cannot agree, they can disagree, or they can agree on conditions, and we do not know what those conditions would be.
The reality is that the white paper—so vaunted, like an Argos catalogue but without the prices—is truly historic: no document has become obsolete quite so quickly. What it says about keeping the pound is just plain wrong. Now we know that what it says about Scotland staying in the European Union is just plain wrong. However, the First Minister thinks that if he asserts things often enough they become true, and that, if he says that it is common sense or as sure as night follows day, his next statement will be believed however unbelievable it is in reality. What does it say about Scotland when Scots have to listen to a foreign Government to find out the truth?
The reality is that the white paper—so vaunted, like an Argos catalogue but without the prices—is truly historic: no document has become obsolete quite so quickly. What it says about keeping the pound is just plain wrong. Now we know that what it says about Scotland staying in the European Union is just plain wrong. However, the First Minister thinks that if he asserts things often enough they become true, and that, if he says that it is common sense or as sure as night follows day, his next statement will be believed however unbelievable it is in reality. What does it say about Scotland when Scots have to listen to a foreign Government to find out the truth?
In this exchange, I have cited the head of unit at the European Commission, who says that we could do it legally from within the European Union; I have cited Sir David Edward, a British judge in the European Court of Justice for 12 years, who says that there would be an obligation to have the negotiations; and I have cited Professor James Crawford, the legal adviser paid by the UK Government, who says that the 18-month timetable is realistic. That is a substantial amount of evidence. I have pointed out that the Spanish foreign minister says that
“No one would object to a consented independence of Scotland. ”
That was the precise reason for having the Edinburgh agreement in the first place.
I had heard the one about the catalogue before, because Johann Lamont used it last night—just before, I think, she suggested that she would means test nursery education under Labour’s plans for Scotland.
The question goes to the heart of whether the unionist parties believe that Scotland would be a welcome member of the European Union. We had a definitive answer on that last night from one of the key members of better together—Alistair Carmichael. Now, listen, I would not recommend that people go and watch the programme, because a referee would have stopped things when Nicola Sturgeon was bruising the bruiser. However, Alistair Carmichael managed to complete a sentence, which I think the rest of his colleagues in better together should look at:
“The question is not whether we would be welcome or not; it would be the terms”.
Exactly. I believe that, for example, the terms of Scottish membership of the European Union would not allow €1 billion to be taken away from our rural industries, as the UK Government has done.
Scotland is a European nation. Resource rich Scotland would be welcome. Anyone with an ounce of sense knows that. Can better together not just get off the scaremongering and embrace the idea that this nation is a European nation?
“No one would object to a consented independence of Scotland. ”
That was the precise reason for having the Edinburgh agreement in the first place.
I had heard the one about the catalogue before, because Johann Lamont used it last night—just before, I think, she suggested that she would means test nursery education under Labour’s plans for Scotland.
The question goes to the heart of whether the unionist parties believe that Scotland would be a welcome member of the European Union. We had a definitive answer on that last night from one of the key members of better together—Alistair Carmichael. Now, listen, I would not recommend that people go and watch the programme, because a referee would have stopped things when Nicola Sturgeon was bruising the bruiser. However, Alistair Carmichael managed to complete a sentence, which I think the rest of his colleagues in better together should look at:
“The question is not whether we would be welcome or not; it would be the terms”.
Exactly. I believe that, for example, the terms of Scottish membership of the European Union would not allow €1 billion to be taken away from our rural industries, as the UK Government has done.
Scotland is a European nation. Resource rich Scotland would be welcome. Anyone with an ounce of sense knows that. Can better together not just get off the scaremongering and embrace the idea that this nation is a European nation?
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 28 Nov 2013 →- Engagements (Aberdeen) Questions · 4
- Homelessness Questions · 6
- Vocational Education and Training (North Ayrshire) Questions · 4
- Department for International Development (East Kilbride) Questions · 5
- Miscarriage Support Questions · 4
- Road Safety (A937 Montrose to Laurencekirk) Questions · 6
- Carers’ Rights Day Questions · 4
- Policing (Stop and Search) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Social Care Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Winter Pressures) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Barnett Formula First Minister’s Questions · 8
- World Prematurity Day 2013 and Neonatal Care Members’ business · 7
- Room Allocation Questions · 4
- Sustainable Travel Questions · 4
- Exhibitions (Use of Committee Rooms) Questions · 6
- Building Maintenance Questions · 4
- Disabled Parking Questions · 4
- Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies Debate · 46
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.