Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Barnett Formula

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 28 November 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link


6. To ask the First Minster what the Scottish Government’s position is on the recent comments by the Secretary of State for Scotland regarding the future of the Barnett formula once the economy has “stabilised”. (S4F-01720)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I should pass on my best wishes to the Secretary of State for Scotland as he recovers from last night’s debate.

As the member will have seen, that aspect came up in last night’s debate. On Monday, the report from the all-party parliamentary group on taxation, which includes MPs from the Conservative, Liberal and Labour parties, said that

“the Barnett Formula must be replaced as a priority”

and that we should go over to the proposals of the Holtham commission. We know that the Holtham commission, which was commissioned by the First Minister of Wales, who was lauded by the better together parties when he came to Scotland just last week, forecast a £4 billion cut in spending. That was its assessment. All three of the better together parties are signed up to a £4 billion cut in Scotland’s finances or—to put it in terms that the Tory party understands—a cut of £1,600 for every taxpayer in Scotland.

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link
The secretary of state’s gaffe in saying last Sunday that the United Kingdom economy remains unstable was compounded when he implied that the Barnett formula’s days are numbered. Does the First Minister agree that, as politicians south of the border from all three UK parties are now pressing for substantial cuts to Scotland’s budget—in addition to those that have been endured in recent years—the only way for Scotland to avoid the cuts is for Scotland to vote yes in next year’s independence referendum?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
This is where we come to it. I could cite quote after quote from members of all three unionist parties—from the Labour Party, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats—who say, “Scrap the Barnett formula.” Their all-party group has now said what it wants the formula to be replaced with. The academics who were concerned with the Holtham commission told us in the Financial Times that they estimate that the Holtham proposal would mean a £4 billion cut in Scotland’s finances.

That is why we published the white paper—the enormous amount of detail in “Scotland’s Future”—which is our prospectus for an independent Scotland. Let us see from the unionist parties the reality of what their colleagues plan—a £4 billion cut in Scottish finances.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link
The Barnett formula is an arrangement for redistributing resources around the United Kingdom. The person who is campaigning hardest for the end of Barnett is the First Minister. Does the First Minister understand that if you are not in it, you will not get it?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will answer with two statistics. We get 9.3 per cent of the spending, but we raise 9.9 per cent of the revenue; 9.9 per cent is greater than 9.3 per cent. [Interruption.]

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. Mr Johnstone.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
That happens to be greater by about £4 billion. It would therefore be a good idea if we got control of the revenue as well as the spending.

Drew Smith’s colleagues have in mind cutting the 9.3 per cent to about 8.3 per cent, which would be £4 billion less. [The First Minister has corrected this contribution. See end of report.] I will put that in the simplest terms that I can for Labour back benchers. If we had raised our own revenue and taxation in the past year, we would have £4 billion more. Under the plans of the better together parties, we will have £4 billion less. Does that complete the calculation?

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Engagements (Aberdeen) Questions · 4
  2. Homelessness Questions · 6
  3. Vocational Education and Training (North Ayrshire) Questions · 4
  4. Department for International Development (East Kilbride) Questions · 5
  5. Miscarriage Support Questions · 4
  6. Road Safety (A937 Montrose to Laurencekirk) Questions · 6
  7. Carers’ Rights Day Questions · 4
  8. Policing (Stop and Search) Questions · 4
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  12. Social Care Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. National Health Service (Winter Pressures) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Barnett Formula First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. World Prematurity Day 2013 and Neonatal Care Members’ business · 7
  16. Room Allocation Questions · 4
  17. Sustainable Travel Questions · 4
  18. Exhibitions (Use of Committee Rooms) Questions · 6
  19. Building Maintenance Questions · 4
  20. Disabled Parking Questions · 4
  21. Independent Expert Review of Opioid Replacement Therapies Debate · 46
  22. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  23. Decision Time Decision time · 4
  24. Correction Procedure · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.