7. To ask the Scottish Government what recent discussions it has had with Aberdeen City Council regarding the timescale for improvements to the Haudagain roundabout. (S4O-02498)
Official Report · Chamber
Haudagain Roundabout
General Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Keith Brown SNP 3
- Mark McDonald SNP 2
- Richard Baker Lab 1
The record
6 contributions7. To ask the Scottish Government what recent discussions it has had with Aberdeen City Council regarding the timescale for improvements to the Haudagain roundabout. (S4O-02498)
link
I met Barney Crockett, leader of Aberdeen City Council, last Thursday to discuss the timescales for the Haudagain improvement.
I note from the coverage that the city council has agreed to follow the Scottish Government’s timescale, which will be welcomed by my constituents in Middlefield, who were concerned about the impact on them of the council’s proposed two-year timescale. Is the minister aware of comments by Councillor Willie Young, convener of finance at Aberdeen City Council, who has threatened to withdraw the council from the project and remove it from the regeneration of Middlefield unless he receives what he describes as a written contract on the Haudagain roundabout? Does that reflect the minister’s discussions with Barney Crockett?
link
I made clear to Barney Crockett the same position on Haudagain that I have made clear to Richard Baker, Lewis Macdonald and Mark McDonald’s predecessor Brian Adam and in numerous public statements: the Scottish Government will pay proper compensation for any affected households.
We have already started the design work on the Haudagain at a cost of around £3 million. I had what I thought was a very constructive meeting with Barney Crockett that covered a range of issues on which the Scottish Government and Aberdeen City Council can work together. Unfortunately, as seems to be the pattern with such meetings, as soon as Councillor Willie Young heard that some constructive dialogue was going on between the council and the Government, he got very agitated and responded by trying to create a drama out of a non-existent crisis.
Perhaps the best thing that could happen in the circumstances is for Councillor Willie Young to let the leader of the council, Councillor Crockett, undertake the dialogue with the Scottish Government and to enter into a period of silence for everyone else’s benefit.
We have already started the design work on the Haudagain at a cost of around £3 million. I had what I thought was a very constructive meeting with Barney Crockett that covered a range of issues on which the Scottish Government and Aberdeen City Council can work together. Unfortunately, as seems to be the pattern with such meetings, as soon as Councillor Willie Young heard that some constructive dialogue was going on between the council and the Government, he got very agitated and responded by trying to create a drama out of a non-existent crisis.
Perhaps the best thing that could happen in the circumstances is for Councillor Willie Young to let the leader of the council, Councillor Crockett, undertake the dialogue with the Scottish Government and to enter into a period of silence for everyone else’s benefit.
Every year of delay to this project costs local businesses in Aberdeen tens of millions of pounds. When will the minister submit a planning application for this route? How long will it all take? In fact, what is the problem with the Scottish Government giving a legally binding commitment to meet the costs? Why can the minister not do that?
link
If Mr Baker considered the procedures that have to be followed for purchasing land, making legal commitments and avoiding, if possible, protracted legal cases such as the one involving the Aberdeen western peripheral route, he would understand why we are taking this approach, which is, in fact, the approach that was taken by previous Administrations. If, for example, we committed to giving compensation to households that we did not intend to take over, that could be held against us at the public local inquiry.
I am determined to approach this in the correct way: Haudagain will happen as soon as the AWPR is completed. Indeed, the council itself has accepted that; its own engineer’s report said that that was the right way to do things. I thought that Richard Baker had accepted that position. Barney Crockett has accepted it; perhaps it is time for those on the Labour benches to do likewise.
I am determined to approach this in the correct way: Haudagain will happen as soon as the AWPR is completed. Indeed, the council itself has accepted that; its own engineer’s report said that that was the right way to do things. I thought that Richard Baker had accepted that position. Barney Crockett has accepted it; perhaps it is time for those on the Labour benches to do likewise.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 10 Oct 2013 →- Unscheduled Care Action Plan (Recruitment) Questions · 5
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Control Rooms (Closure) Questions · 6
- Fish Questions · 6
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Control Rooms (Closure) Questions · 6
- Haudagain Roundabout Questions · 6
- Climate Justice Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- National Health Service Workers (Wage Rise) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Specialist Crime Division First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Higher Education (Economic and Social Research Council Report) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- 2014 Commonwealth Games (Ticket Allocations) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Citizens Advice Youth Outreach Members’ business · 8
- Carbon Capture and Storage Debate · 60
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.