1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01620)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 10
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 5
The record
20 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01620)
I know that the whole chamber will wish to offer our warm congratulations to Professor Higgs on being awarded the Nobel prize for physics. [Applause.]
Later today I will meet Tim Gregory, the United Kingdom president of the Canadian company CGI, which is establishing a digital services centre of excellence in Glasgow. The announcement will see the creation of a further 250 high-value jobs in the city and reinforces Scotland as a leading destination for foreign direct investment.
Later today I will meet Tim Gregory, the United Kingdom president of the Canadian company CGI, which is establishing a digital services centre of excellence in Glasgow. The announcement will see the creation of a further 250 high-value jobs in the city and reinforces Scotland as a leading destination for foreign direct investment.
Last week, the Scottish Government’s fiscal commission announced that an independent Scotland would have not just one oil fund but two, yet the First Minister’s own civil servants reported in March last year, and again in October, that an oil fund would not work unless the First Minister either raised taxes or cut spending. Which is it and when was he going to tell us?
John Swinney said it last week when he announced the fiscal commission’s findings. Let me quote exactly from Mr Swinney’s comments last week:
“It has been widely assumed that Scotland would have to run an absolute fiscal surplus before investing in a savings fund, and this has been reflected in the Scottish Government's early thinking on the subject. However, the commission is clear that there is a compelling case for starting to make early investments into an oil fund whilst in deficit so long as it is manageable and debt is on a downward path.”
That was reinforced in a letter to The Herald last Saturday. I think that Johann Lamont should probably read John Swinney’s letters to The Herald before asking her questions.
“It has been widely assumed that Scotland would have to run an absolute fiscal surplus before investing in a savings fund, and this has been reflected in the Scottish Government's early thinking on the subject. However, the commission is clear that there is a compelling case for starting to make early investments into an oil fund whilst in deficit so long as it is manageable and debt is on a downward path.”
That was reinforced in a letter to The Herald last Saturday. I think that Johann Lamont should probably read John Swinney’s letters to The Herald before asking her questions.
I had expected an attempt by the First Minister to blind us with science. Perhaps I should have predicted instead that he planned to deafen us with gobbledygook. That did not answer the question that I asked. To remove doubt, here is what it says in the advice that he was given last year:
“if the Scottish government had wished to establish an oil fund, it would have had to reduce public spending, increase taxation or increase public sector borrowing.”
In the reporting of this issue, the First Minister has said that events have overtaken that advice, or that the fiscal commission’s report reflects it. Can he now read out where that advice was repeated in the fiscal commission report or tell us which events have overtaken it?
Once again, just like with John Swinney’s paper that doubted the affordability of the state pension and talked of public spending cuts—we knew that the Scottish National Party members would groan because they did not expect other people to know what they said in private—we know that this Government says one thing in private and another in public. Will the First Minister now come clean with the people of Scotland? Will he raise taxes or cut spending to pay for his oil fund, and when was he going to tell us?
“if the Scottish government had wished to establish an oil fund, it would have had to reduce public spending, increase taxation or increase public sector borrowing.”
In the reporting of this issue, the First Minister has said that events have overtaken that advice, or that the fiscal commission’s report reflects it. Can he now read out where that advice was repeated in the fiscal commission report or tell us which events have overtaken it?
Once again, just like with John Swinney’s paper that doubted the affordability of the state pension and talked of public spending cuts—we knew that the Scottish National Party members would groan because they did not expect other people to know what they said in private—we know that this Government says one thing in private and another in public. Will the First Minister now come clean with the people of Scotland? Will he raise taxes or cut spending to pay for his oil fund, and when was he going to tell us?
Let me read that incredibly scientific quote from Mr Swinney again:
“It has been widely assumed that Scotland would have to run an absolute fiscal surplus before investing in a savings fund, and this has been reflected in the Scottish Government's early thinking on the subject.”
That is a straightforward explanation to answer the question that Johann Lamont asked. I do not think that that can be described as scientific or gobbledygook. It is a straightforward suggestion that that was the early thinking.
The fiscal commission pointed out that, in marshalling Scotland’s enormous natural resources to invest in the future, there should be two oil funds—one, a stabilisation fund to take advantage of windfall gains, and two, a long-term savings fund—and it set out the criteria by which it should be done. I think that that is an entirely sensible thing to do. If we had had those funds when these resources were being mismanaged by the United Kingdom, we would be in an entirely better place. How do I know that? The former Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer, Denis Healey, said that there should have been an oil fund. He said that
“we should have invested the money in things we needed”
in terms of an oil fund
“and I had thought about an oil fund ... but it wasn’t my responsibility by then”—
it was all Margaret Thatcher’s fault.
Perhaps even more interesting is that, in The Scotsman on 21 August, Alistair Darling, when asked that very question about whether there should have been an oil fund, said:
“if we had our time over again, perhaps we should have”.
So even Alistair Darling wants to have his time over again. Well, Scotland has the opportunity over the next 40 years, and we are not going to make the same mistakes as in the past.
“It has been widely assumed that Scotland would have to run an absolute fiscal surplus before investing in a savings fund, and this has been reflected in the Scottish Government's early thinking on the subject.”
That is a straightforward explanation to answer the question that Johann Lamont asked. I do not think that that can be described as scientific or gobbledygook. It is a straightforward suggestion that that was the early thinking.
The fiscal commission pointed out that, in marshalling Scotland’s enormous natural resources to invest in the future, there should be two oil funds—one, a stabilisation fund to take advantage of windfall gains, and two, a long-term savings fund—and it set out the criteria by which it should be done. I think that that is an entirely sensible thing to do. If we had had those funds when these resources were being mismanaged by the United Kingdom, we would be in an entirely better place. How do I know that? The former Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer, Denis Healey, said that there should have been an oil fund. He said that
“we should have invested the money in things we needed”
in terms of an oil fund
“and I had thought about an oil fund ... but it wasn’t my responsibility by then”—
it was all Margaret Thatcher’s fault.
Perhaps even more interesting is that, in The Scotsman on 21 August, Alistair Darling, when asked that very question about whether there should have been an oil fund, said:
“if we had our time over again, perhaps we should have”.
So even Alistair Darling wants to have his time over again. Well, Scotland has the opportunity over the next 40 years, and we are not going to make the same mistakes as in the past.
It was not my party that walked through the lobbies to create a Tory Government under Margaret Thatcher. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. [Interruption.] Order!
I know that SNP members do not like to remember their history, but that is what the SNP did to Scotland and Scotland will never forgive them.
For all that chuckling nonsense from the First Minister, he ignored the central question. The one thing that the fiscal commission report makes clear is that the oil fund is not a saving scheme; it is an insurance policy against the volatility of oil prices, although it does rather sound like the kind of oil fund—[Interruption.]
For all that chuckling nonsense from the First Minister, he ignored the central question. The one thing that the fiscal commission report makes clear is that the oil fund is not a saving scheme; it is an insurance policy against the volatility of oil prices, although it does rather sound like the kind of oil fund—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The noisier the SNP members get, the more troubled they are.
It sounds rather like the kind of oil fund where people get a free Parker pen just for inquiring. The fact is that the First Minister does not want to admit that his oil fund will not work without tax rises or spending cuts. He does not want to admit that he has been told that, rather than setting up a Norwegian-style oil fund, Scots would be better off investing in United Kingdom bonds. That is why the issue is serious.
There is a central deceit in what the First Minister says—the people of Scotland, upon independence, are immediately expecting increased spending on services while his own independent advice says that, precisely because of independence, he would need to redirect moneys from public expenditure to a stabilisation fund. So let us have an answer: does the First Minister want tax rises to pay for his oil fund or cuts in hospitals and schools, and when was he going to tell us?
It sounds rather like the kind of oil fund where people get a free Parker pen just for inquiring. The fact is that the First Minister does not want to admit that his oil fund will not work without tax rises or spending cuts. He does not want to admit that he has been told that, rather than setting up a Norwegian-style oil fund, Scots would be better off investing in United Kingdom bonds. That is why the issue is serious.
There is a central deceit in what the First Minister says—the people of Scotland, upon independence, are immediately expecting increased spending on services while his own independent advice says that, precisely because of independence, he would need to redirect moneys from public expenditure to a stabilisation fund. So let us have an answer: does the First Minister want tax rises to pay for his oil fund or cuts in hospitals and schools, and when was he going to tell us?
Let us start with the trip down memory lane. Actually, James Callaghan, in his autobiography, “Time and Chance”, allocated responsibility for the fall of his Government to Labour Party anti-devolutionists. I am surprised that Johann Lamont does not remember that, because she was a Labour Party anti-devolutionist at the time, so I really think that that historical script will have to be changed. If we come right up to the present day, Johann Lamont is in alliance with the Conservative Party in a campaign called better together.
On the questions on the oil fund, those matters were of course addressed in the fiscal commission report. For example, the issue of bond yields against returns from our oil fund is dealt with on page 61, which states:
“As an illustration, over the past five years yields on 10 year UK Government bonds have averaged 3.1% whilst the Norwegian Oil Fund has achieved average annual returns of 5.9%.”
Now, 5.9 per cent is greater than 3.1 per cent. I think that that deals with the point that Johann Lamont was trying to make.
The concept of a stabilisation fund is very important indeed. Let us say, for example, that the Scottish Government’s forecast of oil at $113 a barrel over the period to 2017 is not right and that the Department for Energy and Climate Change, which is forecasting maybe $130, is right. That would give a windfall gain that we did not forecast or expect, because we would have taken a modest view of the future course of oil prices. The fiscal commission sensibly pointed out that it would be sensible to put that into an oil fund so that we have a stabilisation fund in case the forecasts go the other way. I hardly think that that is a matter of great contention. It seems to me a very sensible process to propose.
The fundamental difficulty that the unionist parties have with that is clear: they want the people of Scotland to believe that having an asset whose estimated wholesale value over the next 40 years is £1.5 trillion is somehow a major encumbrance and disadvantage. It is a huge advantage for the people of Scotland—would that we had had it over the last 40 years; we are certainly going to have it over the next 40 years.
On the questions on the oil fund, those matters were of course addressed in the fiscal commission report. For example, the issue of bond yields against returns from our oil fund is dealt with on page 61, which states:
“As an illustration, over the past five years yields on 10 year UK Government bonds have averaged 3.1% whilst the Norwegian Oil Fund has achieved average annual returns of 5.9%.”
Now, 5.9 per cent is greater than 3.1 per cent. I think that that deals with the point that Johann Lamont was trying to make.
The concept of a stabilisation fund is very important indeed. Let us say, for example, that the Scottish Government’s forecast of oil at $113 a barrel over the period to 2017 is not right and that the Department for Energy and Climate Change, which is forecasting maybe $130, is right. That would give a windfall gain that we did not forecast or expect, because we would have taken a modest view of the future course of oil prices. The fiscal commission sensibly pointed out that it would be sensible to put that into an oil fund so that we have a stabilisation fund in case the forecasts go the other way. I hardly think that that is a matter of great contention. It seems to me a very sensible process to propose.
The fundamental difficulty that the unionist parties have with that is clear: they want the people of Scotland to believe that having an asset whose estimated wholesale value over the next 40 years is £1.5 trillion is somehow a major encumbrance and disadvantage. It is a huge advantage for the people of Scotland—would that we had had it over the last 40 years; we are certainly going to have it over the next 40 years.
Whatever that was, it will not give anyone confidence that the First Minister has a clue about what he is talking about. His own fiscal commission said:
“It therefore requires fewer resources to be allocated to current spending, or to reducing other taxes, than would otherwise be the case.”
The First Minister is simply dishonest when he talks about a stabilisation fund—
“It therefore requires fewer resources to be allocated to current spending, or to reducing other taxes, than would otherwise be the case.”
The First Minister is simply dishonest when he talks about a stabilisation fund—
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Ms Lamont, I think that you should withdraw that.
The First Minister is not being accurate when he says that a stabilisation fund—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
However we describe it, the First Minister said that the stabilisation fund was about a windfall. The stabilisation fund is to address the volatility of oil over time and his own fiscal commission says so.
We know that John Swinney told the First Minister the truth about the state of the public finances in private. The First Minister wanted that hidden from the public. Now he says that, in a separate Scotland, we would have two oil funds, when he has been told in private not once but twice that that would not work without there being an impact on taxation or public spending.
Unless the First Minister is denying that that advice was given to him, he needs to explain why it is no longer relevant. When was he going to tell us? When was he going to tell us whether his choice is to raise taxes or cut public spending? The answer is never. Honesty is not something that this Government deals in. [Interruption.]
We know that John Swinney told the First Minister the truth about the state of the public finances in private. The First Minister wanted that hidden from the public. Now he says that, in a separate Scotland, we would have two oil funds, when he has been told in private not once but twice that that would not work without there being an impact on taxation or public spending.
Unless the First Minister is denying that that advice was given to him, he needs to explain why it is no longer relevant. When was he going to tell us? When was he going to tell us whether his choice is to raise taxes or cut public spending? The answer is never. Honesty is not something that this Government deals in. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. Ms Lamont, I think that you should withdraw that.
I am astonished. I do not know what word we use to describe somebody saying—[Interruption.] I accept the advice of the Presiding Officer, but I have to say that I do not know what word we use to describe a Government that says one thing in private and something different in public.
The fact of the matter is that Scotland is on pause and we will not be given the full facts by this Government ahead of the referendum.
The fact of the matter is that Scotland is on pause and we will not be given the full facts by this Government ahead of the referendum.
It might have been better for Johann Lamont to withdraw the comment than to try to talk her way round it.
Johann Lamont asked a precise question, so I will read out from page 4 of the fiscal commission proposal. I assure the member that this is not too scientific or complicated:
“We have however, proposed a model which takes into consideration the fiscal position that an independent Scotland is likely to inherit, and which, in principle, allows investments to be made into both a stabilisation fund and a savings fund without an automatic offsetting change to public spending or taxation.”
That is on page 4 of the fiscal commission report. I think that it reflects exactly the question that Johann Lamont had to ask me—if indeed there was a question somewhere in there. That is what the fiscal commission said last week, and John Swinney wrote to the papers to point out the importance of the fiscal commission’s recommendations.
We know that this is an issue on which Alistair Darling—if he had his time over again—and Denis Healey would have liked to have done something, in terms of investing for the future. The fiscal commission report sets out clear criteria on how we can marshal Scotland’s resources and ensure that that asset is used for the benefit of this generation and future generations.
Nobody would seriously argue that the UK has handled oil well as a resource over the past 40 years. Nobody would seriously dispute that Norway, the country across the North Sea, has handled that resource much better. The fiscal commission has put forward a proposal that allows Scotland to get towards the fortunate position of Norway, as opposed to making the unremitting bungles that Westminster and successful United Kingdom chancellors have made.
Johann Lamont asked a precise question, so I will read out from page 4 of the fiscal commission proposal. I assure the member that this is not too scientific or complicated:
“We have however, proposed a model which takes into consideration the fiscal position that an independent Scotland is likely to inherit, and which, in principle, allows investments to be made into both a stabilisation fund and a savings fund without an automatic offsetting change to public spending or taxation.”
That is on page 4 of the fiscal commission report. I think that it reflects exactly the question that Johann Lamont had to ask me—if indeed there was a question somewhere in there. That is what the fiscal commission said last week, and John Swinney wrote to the papers to point out the importance of the fiscal commission’s recommendations.
We know that this is an issue on which Alistair Darling—if he had his time over again—and Denis Healey would have liked to have done something, in terms of investing for the future. The fiscal commission report sets out clear criteria on how we can marshal Scotland’s resources and ensure that that asset is used for the benefit of this generation and future generations.
Nobody would seriously argue that the UK has handled oil well as a resource over the past 40 years. Nobody would seriously dispute that Norway, the country across the North Sea, has handled that resource much better. The fiscal commission has put forward a proposal that allows Scotland to get towards the fortunate position of Norway, as opposed to making the unremitting bungles that Westminster and successful United Kingdom chancellors have made.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 10 Oct 2013 →- Unscheduled Care Action Plan (Recruitment) Questions · 5
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Control Rooms (Closure) Questions · 6
- Fish Questions · 6
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Control Rooms (Closure) Questions · 6
- Haudagain Roundabout Questions · 6
- Climate Justice Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- National Health Service Workers (Wage Rise) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Specialist Crime Division First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Higher Education (Economic and Social Research Council Report) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- 2014 Commonwealth Games (Ticket Allocations) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Citizens Advice Youth Outreach Members’ business · 8
- Carbon Capture and Storage Debate · 60
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.