1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01368)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 8
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Elaine Smith Lab 3
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
The record
18 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01368)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
In February, I asked the First Minister about the case of 84-year-old John McGarrity who, having been admitted with chest pains, was left for eight hours on a hospital trolley in a corridor. At the time, the First Minister said that these things happen in the national health service and his Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing said that it was “not a true reflection” of the NHS. Can the First Minister tell me whether the number of people left on trolleys is getting better or worse?
That is not what I said at all. I remember very specifically saying that this Government takes seriously any individual case in which treatment is less than satisfactory. That is what we should do and what we do. I made the point that there are very substantial indications that overall treatment in the national health service and patient satisfaction are improving. There is also the point, which we should all be aware of when we quite properly raise such cases, that everyone should be proud of our national health service in Scotland.
I think that the First Minister did say that, but he has clearly not reflected on it.
I do not dispute that we all love and care about the NHS, and the First Minister and I agree that it is a disgrace that pensioners such as John McGarrity wait for eight hours on a trolley in a corridor for treatment. I presume that when I raised the matter with him in February he investigated such occurrences, so I will try again. Can he tell me whether the situation is better or worse?
I do not dispute that we all love and care about the NHS, and the First Minister and I agree that it is a disgrace that pensioners such as John McGarrity wait for eight hours on a trolley in a corridor for treatment. I presume that when I raised the matter with him in February he investigated such occurrences, so I will try again. Can he tell me whether the situation is better or worse?
I call tell Johann Lamont that the situation in terms of treatment in the national health service overall is improving. It is improving despite the great pressure on all public services, and it is improving because of the commitment and effort of our nurses, doctors and ancillary staff in the national health service. I can give her a range of statistics that indicate as much.
Of course, individual cases in which treatment is less than satisfactory are looked at seriously and taken into account, but in pursuing such cases Johann Lamont should not be deflected from the fact that, overall, treatment is—in terms of waiting times for treatment, the efficacy of treatment and the number of people who are being treated—improving in the national health service. I think that that is an enormous tribute to the staff and their commitment to our national health service in what are, inevitably, difficult times.
Of course, individual cases in which treatment is less than satisfactory are looked at seriously and taken into account, but in pursuing such cases Johann Lamont should not be deflected from the fact that, overall, treatment is—in terms of waiting times for treatment, the efficacy of treatment and the number of people who are being treated—improving in the national health service. I think that that is an enormous tribute to the staff and their commitment to our national health service in what are, inevitably, difficult times.
I have absolutely no doubt whatever that the First Minister can give me a long list of answers to questions that he was not asked, but he has not answered the question that I asked him.
This is not about anyone running down the NHS; it is about taking our job seriously. I can only presume that the reason why the First Minister does not know the answer to my question is that he does not care. He has not even asked. [Interruption.] He has not even asked. Perhaps he does not like to ask in case the answer breaches his perfect view of his world.
Let me tell the First Minister what is happening in the NHS that he is supposed to be running, while deciding what currency a fantasy Scotland will have in his fantasy world. In the real world, the number of people who are languishing in accident and emergency departments is increasing; we know that, thanks to a freedom of information request on our health boards.
In John McGarrity’s area of Glasgow, the number of patients who waited over four hours to be seen has more than trebled—up from 10,100 in 2009 to 31,700 this year. Looking across Scotland, I note that in NHS Lanarkshire—the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing’s own backyard—the number of patients who are waiting more than four hours in A and E has also more than trebled and that in NHS Grampian, which is the First Minister’s own backyard, there was an increase of 1,300 in the number of patients waiting more than four hours in A and E, compared with last year. Now that the First Minister knows what is happening in the NHS on his watch, will he tell us what he is going to do about it?
This is not about anyone running down the NHS; it is about taking our job seriously. I can only presume that the reason why the First Minister does not know the answer to my question is that he does not care. He has not even asked. [Interruption.] He has not even asked. Perhaps he does not like to ask in case the answer breaches his perfect view of his world.
Let me tell the First Minister what is happening in the NHS that he is supposed to be running, while deciding what currency a fantasy Scotland will have in his fantasy world. In the real world, the number of people who are languishing in accident and emergency departments is increasing; we know that, thanks to a freedom of information request on our health boards.
In John McGarrity’s area of Glasgow, the number of patients who waited over four hours to be seen has more than trebled—up from 10,100 in 2009 to 31,700 this year. Looking across Scotland, I note that in NHS Lanarkshire—the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing’s own backyard—the number of patients who are waiting more than four hours in A and E has also more than trebled and that in NHS Grampian, which is the First Minister’s own backyard, there was an increase of 1,300 in the number of patients waiting more than four hours in A and E, compared with last year. Now that the First Minister knows what is happening in the NHS on his watch, will he tell us what he is going to do about it?
Is not that exactly why the health secretary announced the plan for reinforcing the staff and resources at accident and emergency units across Scotland, so that the NHS can be sustained under winter pressures and the position improved? [Interruption.] That is what the health secretary announced, because that is the correct response to the pressures that we have seen over the winter.
The capacity of our accident and emergency units has substantially increased under this Government, and the number of diagnoses and treatments in hospital A and E departments is up by 6 per cent since 2007, under this Government. That has been possible because the resource budget of the national health service in Scotland has increased under this Government, despite the extraordinary financial pressures that have been imposed on us from Westminster.
We know that that would not have happened had the Labour Party been in power. We know that because the Labour Party would not, in the run-up to the elections either in 2007 or in 2011 commit to protecting the budget of the national health service. We also know it because in the only place where Labour is in power in these islands there has been a real-terms decline in national health service funding. That is a reality.
Let us answer the question in this sense—[Interruption.]
The capacity of our accident and emergency units has substantially increased under this Government, and the number of diagnoses and treatments in hospital A and E departments is up by 6 per cent since 2007, under this Government. That has been possible because the resource budget of the national health service in Scotland has increased under this Government, despite the extraordinary financial pressures that have been imposed on us from Westminster.
We know that that would not have happened had the Labour Party been in power. We know that because the Labour Party would not, in the run-up to the elections either in 2007 or in 2011 commit to protecting the budget of the national health service. We also know it because in the only place where Labour is in power in these islands there has been a real-terms decline in national health service funding. That is a reality.
Let us answer the question in this sense—[Interruption.]
Order.
Where there is pressure on the national health service, this Government responds by devoting additional resources to accident and emergency services, so that we can treat real patients with real conditions and sustain the health service against winter pressure. I do not think that a party that was unable to commit itself to the health service in the election campaigns, and which is unable to commit itself to the health service in Wales now, is in any position to pose as a defender of the national health service, when it wanted to spend the money elsewhere.
We would settle for the First Minister answering the question in any sense whatever. That answer certainly does not qualify.
The First Minister talked about Wales, but he is in power here. He is responsible for the NHS. I am sure that he understands that he has been in power since 2007, dealing with the national health service.
On the point about winter pressures, the winter pressures this year were less than they were in 2010, so the explanation simply does not stack up.
If the First Minister ever made it out of Bute house to the real world and met a patient who was waiting on a trolley for treatment, we can assume that he would say to the person who was lying in front of him, “Listen. You are more satisfied with the NHS than ever before.” He would tell the person on the trolley that things are better under his area of responsibility.
The First Minister is simply not serious. When will he understand that patients need medical treatment, not slogans? He has been in charge of the NHS for six years—
The First Minister talked about Wales, but he is in power here. He is responsible for the NHS. I am sure that he understands that he has been in power since 2007, dealing with the national health service.
On the point about winter pressures, the winter pressures this year were less than they were in 2010, so the explanation simply does not stack up.
If the First Minister ever made it out of Bute house to the real world and met a patient who was waiting on a trolley for treatment, we can assume that he would say to the person who was lying in front of him, “Listen. You are more satisfied with the NHS than ever before.” He would tell the person on the trolley that things are better under his area of responsibility.
The First Minister is simply not serious. When will he understand that patients need medical treatment, not slogans? He has been in charge of the NHS for six years—
Thank goodness.
It is not “Thank goodness” for the people who are lying on trolleys. [Interruption.]
Order.
The First Minister tells people that they should be grateful for that. It is not “Thank goodness”, at all. The number of people who wait more than four hours in A and E is increasing, but what does the First Minister do? Instead of cutting times—we can hardly believe this—he cuts the target.
I have raised the issue with the First Minister time and again. Is it not the case that the reason why things have got worse, the reason why he has done nothing to improve the situation, and the reason why he does not even know, is that he does not care about NHS patients and cares only—[Interruption.] Scottish National Party members also care only about SNP slogans. [Interruption.] You might want to ask your own guy for an answer occasionally. That would be encouraging. [Interruption.]
I have raised the issue with the First Minister time and again. Is it not the case that the reason why things have got worse, the reason why he has done nothing to improve the situation, and the reason why he does not even know, is that he does not care about NHS patients and cares only—[Interruption.] Scottish National Party members also care only about SNP slogans. [Interruption.] You might want to ask your own guy for an answer occasionally. That would be encouraging. [Interruption.]
Order. Please speak through the Presiding Officer.
Then we would really know that we were in a new place.
Here is a phrase that sums up this country, and the First Minister should reflect on it: in this country, under Salmond, Scotland is lying on a trolley while his referendum is in intensive care.
Here is a phrase that sums up this country, and the First Minister should reflect on it: in this country, under Salmond, Scotland is lying on a trolley while his referendum is in intensive care.
It struck me, as I was listening to that, that folk who are being treated now in Monklands or Ayr hospital accident and emergency departments will know that their hospitals would not even be there if they had been left to the Labour Party. Not content with not securing the budget, the Labour Party was going to cut the hospitals.
Perhaps what is more important than Johann Lamont’s view of the national health service is what the people think about the national health service. Eighty-five per cent of Scottish in-patients reported in the in-patients survey that their overall care and treatment was good or excellent. In 2011, 88 per cent of people were very satisfied or satisfied with their local health services—up from 81 per cent in 2007. Those issues were tested at the 2011 election, which is why people vindicated the SNP’s stewardship of our national health service and left the Labour Party languishing in opposition.
Johann Lamont says that we should not talk about what is happening in Wales. Why should we not talk about what is happening in Wales? It is because it shows what actually happens when the Labour Party is in power. We are in a position where fierce cuts from Westminster are affecting both the Welsh and Scottish budgets. In Wales they decided to cut the health budget in real terms. They were under financial pressure and could not see the commitment to maintain the health service budget in Scotland. In Scotland, this Government decided to maintain and sustain the resource budget of the national health service in real terms.
When it comes to political commitment, the record of this Government on the national health service, which was vindicated by the people in the 2011 election, and the financial commitment that has been made, show that the national health service being in our hands is, above all, the reason why we are in government and the Labour Party is in opposition.
Perhaps what is more important than Johann Lamont’s view of the national health service is what the people think about the national health service. Eighty-five per cent of Scottish in-patients reported in the in-patients survey that their overall care and treatment was good or excellent. In 2011, 88 per cent of people were very satisfied or satisfied with their local health services—up from 81 per cent in 2007. Those issues were tested at the 2011 election, which is why people vindicated the SNP’s stewardship of our national health service and left the Labour Party languishing in opposition.
Johann Lamont says that we should not talk about what is happening in Wales. Why should we not talk about what is happening in Wales? It is because it shows what actually happens when the Labour Party is in power. We are in a position where fierce cuts from Westminster are affecting both the Welsh and Scottish budgets. In Wales they decided to cut the health budget in real terms. They were under financial pressure and could not see the commitment to maintain the health service budget in Scotland. In Scotland, this Government decided to maintain and sustain the resource budget of the national health service in real terms.
When it comes to political commitment, the record of this Government on the national health service, which was vindicated by the people in the 2011 election, and the financial commitment that has been made, show that the national health service being in our hands is, above all, the reason why we are in government and the Labour Party is in opposition.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 May 2013 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Scottish Court Service (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route (Cap on Costs) Questions · 8
- Bus Services Questions · 4
- Air Pollution (Cities) Questions · 6
- Currency Questions · 8
- OKI Electric (Workforce Reduction) Questions · 5
- Air Passenger Duty Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Queen’s Speech First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Ageing Population (Scottish Government Policy) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Foreign Affairs Committee (Report on Consequences of Scottish Independence) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Reducing Reoffending (Prisoners’ Assets) Members’ business · 10
- Youth Employment Debate · 79
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.