4. To ask the First Minister what the implications for Scotland are of the Queen’s speech. (S4F-01364)
Official Report · Chamber
Queen’s Speech
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 4
- Elaine Smith Lab 3
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 2
- Gavin Brown Con 2
- Neil Findlay Lab 1
The record
12 contributions4. To ask the First Minister what the implications for Scotland are of the Queen’s speech. (S4F-01364)
Yesterday, we were looking for an indication in the Queen’s speech that the Westminster Government realises the seriousness of the economic situation facing the country, given the lack of growth in the economy, and that there would be new measures to deal with that. Not only was that not in the Queen’s speech, but progressive measures such as minimum pricing for alcohol were dropped and there was no legal commitment to overseas aid, despite repeated promises. Overall, that speech indicates why this country needs good government from this Parliament as opposed to bad government from Westminster.
Certainly, yesterday proved that Westminster is not working for Scotland. Does the First Minister agree that, particularly in the tough economic times that people are facing, we need to see a United Kingdom Government that is focused on delivering jobs and prosperity for Scotland rather than one that is pandering, in a blind panic, to the threat of the United Kingdom Independence Party after last week’s local elections south of the border?
That analysis about the UK Government’s response is widely shared among political commentators and, indeed, politicians at Westminster. Such a response would be unfortunate, because the real issues that are emerging were not those that were contained in the Queen’s speech yesterday but those that will be in the new spending review that is currently being prepared at Westminster.
Yesterday, the Institute for Fiscal Studies said:
“The current government plan”—
at Westminster, that is—
“is for eight successive years of tax increases and spending cuts”.
It seems that the choice facing Scotland is clear. We have heard so much from the no campaigners, on the Labour and Tory sides, about the uncertainty of independence. Here is a certainty of UK Government: there will be eight successive years of tax increases and spending cuts on the Scottish people.
Yesterday, the Institute for Fiscal Studies said:
“The current government plan”—
at Westminster, that is—
“is for eight successive years of tax increases and spending cuts”.
It seems that the choice facing Scotland is clear. We have heard so much from the no campaigners, on the Labour and Tory sides, about the uncertainty of independence. Here is a certainty of UK Government: there will be eight successive years of tax increases and spending cuts on the Scottish people.
I call Gavin Brown with a brief supplementary.
Presiding Officer, allow me to cheer up the First Minister and his back benchers just a little bit—
Briefly, please.
The national insurance contributions bill that was in the Queen’s speech yesterday got a big thumbs up from the Federation of Small Businesses, which said that it will be a shot in the arm. What is the First Minister’s view on the national insurance contributions bill?
I support measures that bring people back into employment. The point that I was making is that, for an economy that is suffering severely from a clear deficiency of demand with huge unspent resources and many skills and people lying idle, not to address that fundamental question seems to me to be a failure of leadership and of stewardship.
Given the real-term cuts—as the member well knows—of 8.2 per cent that are already in the Scottish budget, to anticipate eight successive years of tax increases and spending cuts is a dismal prospect, which I think will encourage many people to think twice about continuing Tory rule from Westminster when we could mobilise the resources and people of this nation to build a prosperous and socially just future.
Given the real-term cuts—as the member well knows—of 8.2 per cent that are already in the Scottish budget, to anticipate eight successive years of tax increases and spending cuts is a dismal prospect, which I think will encourage many people to think twice about continuing Tory rule from Westminster when we could mobilise the resources and people of this nation to build a prosperous and socially just future.
Also briefly, Neil Findlay.
Yesterday, the UK Government dropped plans to regulate the lobbying industry. Does the First Minister think that that was a mistake and does he support plans to regulate the industry in Scotland?
If the member brings forward ideas or plans, we will see how they are appropriate to the work of this Parliament. It should be said that, in general, this Parliament operates with a greater degree of transparency than the Westminster Parliament. Having served in both, I am in a reasonable position to judge that. If the member brings forward suggestions in a positive fashion, they will be treated in a positive fashion by the Government.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 May 2013 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Scottish Court Service (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route (Cap on Costs) Questions · 8
- Bus Services Questions · 4
- Air Pollution (Cities) Questions · 6
- Currency Questions · 8
- OKI Electric (Workforce Reduction) Questions · 5
- Air Passenger Duty Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Queen’s Speech First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Ageing Population (Scottish Government Policy) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Foreign Affairs Committee (Report on Consequences of Scottish Independence) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Reducing Reoffending (Prisoners’ Assets) Members’ business · 10
- Youth Employment Debate · 79
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.