3. To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on the continuing use of neonicotinoids. (S4O-01977)
Official Report · Chamber
Neonicotinoids
General Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Paul Wheelhouse SNP 3
- Graeme Dey SNP 2
- Claudia Beamish Lab 1
The record
6 contributions3. To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on the continuing use of neonicotinoids. (S4O-01977)
The Scottish Government’s position on the use of neonicotinoids continues to be informed by scientific advice from the Advisory Committee on Pesticides—ACP—and our scientists at Science and Advice for Scottish Agriculture—SASA.
We know that high doses of neonicotinoids in laboratory conditions are harmful to bees, but we also know that real-life field conditions are different. That is why the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment asked the ACP urgently to provide new advice on a review of field trials on bumblebees.
The Scottish Government received that advice last night. We will need to examine it closely and consider our next steps. Even when we have had time to consider the new scientific advice thoroughly, it may not give us complete clarity. However, we also need to bear in mind the precautionary principle. Therefore, if in light of the new advice, the case for the European Union’s precautionary measures is strong, I would want the United Kingdom Government to consider supporting them.
We know that high doses of neonicotinoids in laboratory conditions are harmful to bees, but we also know that real-life field conditions are different. That is why the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment asked the ACP urgently to provide new advice on a review of field trials on bumblebees.
The Scottish Government received that advice last night. We will need to examine it closely and consider our next steps. Even when we have had time to consider the new scientific advice thoroughly, it may not give us complete clarity. However, we also need to bear in mind the precautionary principle. Therefore, if in light of the new advice, the case for the European Union’s precautionary measures is strong, I would want the United Kingdom Government to consider supporting them.
It is, of course, essential that any decision on the future use of neonicotinoids should be based on sound scientific evidence. Is the minister aware of the research carried out by the University of Dundee that suggested that neonicotinoids interfere with the brains of bees and that there is a striking and concerning difference between honey bee survival rates in the east of Scotland and those in the west of Scotland? Does he accept that it is becoming evident that there is a need to act to protect bee populations not only from a biodiversity perspective but to safeguard Scotland’s hugely important soft fruit sector?
Yes. Ministers agree that there is a need for urgency on the matter. As the Scottish Government received only late last night the advice that it requested from the Advisory Committee on Pesticides, ministers will now need to consider that and other evidence, such as the Dundee study to which Mr Dey refers, before commenting on the detail and any implications for biodiversity or the farming sector.
According to the last pesticide usage survey in the soft fruit sector, which was carried out in 2010, growers used a neonicotinoid on their crops that was not one of the three neonicotinoids suspected to be of concern. However, the Scottish Government recognises the impact on the farming industry and will take that into account when establishing a final view on the issue.
It is worth stating that only 1 per cent of pesticide use in Scotland is in the form of neonicotinoids, largely because our colder climate means that fungal pathogens are a greater threat to our crops than insect pests.
According to the last pesticide usage survey in the soft fruit sector, which was carried out in 2010, growers used a neonicotinoid on their crops that was not one of the three neonicotinoids suspected to be of concern. However, the Scottish Government recognises the impact on the farming industry and will take that into account when establishing a final view on the issue.
It is worth stating that only 1 per cent of pesticide use in Scotland is in the form of neonicotinoids, largely because our colder climate means that fungal pathogens are a greater threat to our crops than insect pests.
Will the minister confirm whether the Scottish Government has had and intends to have any discussions with the UK Government about the EU proposal to ban three types of neonicotinoid pesticides? As Graeme Dey’s supplementary question noted, those neonicotinoids are dangerous to bees when used on flowering plants. That was stated in January by the European Food Safety Authority.
I confirm that the cabinet secretary has had discussions with his counterpart, Owen Paterson, in advance of the Council of the European Union meeting. Discussions continue. I assure the member that the cabinet secretary is committed to examining the issue in depth and ensuring that we take a considered position.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 28 Mar 2013 →- Business Motions Business motions · 3
- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Banks (Agency and Branch Closures) Questions · 6
- Neonicotinoids Questions · 6
- “When parents are detained” Questions · 4
- Supermarkets (Local Produce) Questions · 4
- Maintenance of Land on Private Housing Estates (Consultation Findings) Questions · 4
- Healthcare Improvement Scotland (Review) Questions · 5
- Cashback for Communities (Meetings with Partners) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Welfare Reform First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Junior Doctors’ Hours First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Police Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Bowel Cancer Members’ business · 8
- Decrofting of Owner-occupied Croft Land Statement · 25
- High Hedges (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 43
- High Hedges (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 43
- Point of Order Procedure · 11
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.