1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01285)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
11 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01285)
Later today I will join the other party leaders for a photo call in support of the Disasters Emergency Committee’s on-going emergency appeal in response to the humanitarian situation in Syria. Millions of men, women and children have fled the violence and are trying to survive in freezing temperatures. They desperately need food, shelter and medical care. I am pleased to announce that the Scottish Government is today pledging £100,000 towards the appeal, which means that the running total from donations from Scotland is now £467,000. I urge everyone—I know that this call will be echoed across the Parliament—to help the Disasters Emergency Committee to meet its target of £500,000.
I welcome what the First Minister said and I hope that we can do our small bit to signal to people in Scotland that they should continue their generosity in supporting people in such terrible situations.
On Saturday I met a young girl who is in her sixth year at a school in my constituency. She has eight grade 1s at standard grade and five As at higher, and she is studying for three advanced highers at school and a fourth at her local college. She wants to be a doctor, but she has not been able to get even one interview at a Scottish university to study medicine. Can the First Minister think why that might be?
On Saturday I met a young girl who is in her sixth year at a school in my constituency. She has eight grade 1s at standard grade and five As at higher, and she is studying for three advanced highers at school and a fourth at her local college. She wants to be a doctor, but she has not been able to get even one interview at a Scottish university to study medicine. Can the First Minister think why that might be?
The pressure on medical places at university is intense and has been for some considerable time, but the Parliament should recognise that we had, thanks to the Government’s efforts and our policy of not charging for higher education, a record number of students in higher education courses in Scotland last year. That is an indication that, across the piece, the policy is a wise one. It is one that we intend to continue.
That will be no comfort whatever to my constituent, or to students throughout the country who are facing problems. Simply to assert that a policy is working is not enough; the Government has a responsibility to create opportunities for young people.
Let us look at the lived reality, rather than at what the First Minister asserts. We know that in Scotland just one in four students comes from the poorest backgrounds—for the rest of the United Kingdom, the rate is closer to one in three. We know that the drop-out rate at Scottish universities is 25 per cent higher than the drop-out rate in England. We know that although constituents like mine have to compete for a limited number of places with students from across Europe, English students can come north, if they have the money, to access unlimited numbers of places.
Does the First Minister recognise that on access, on drop-out levels and on university places, this Government is failing young people in Scotland who want to make the best of themselves?
Let us look at the lived reality, rather than at what the First Minister asserts. We know that in Scotland just one in four students comes from the poorest backgrounds—for the rest of the United Kingdom, the rate is closer to one in three. We know that the drop-out rate at Scottish universities is 25 per cent higher than the drop-out rate in England. We know that although constituents like mine have to compete for a limited number of places with students from across Europe, English students can come north, if they have the money, to access unlimited numbers of places.
Does the First Minister recognise that on access, on drop-out levels and on university places, this Government is failing young people in Scotland who want to make the best of themselves?
Last year there was, in terms of full-time students, a record number of Scottish students in higher education in Scotland, a record number of English students in higher education in Scotland and a record number of international students in higher education in Scotland. I think that all three are a good thing; that is exactly what we should want from our higher education sector in Scotland. Would that have been the case if the Labour Party had had its way and imposed tuition fees, as it will do if it has its way in the future? Would that have been the case if the Lib Dem-Tory coalition had had its way and imposed tuition fees on Scotland?
We need only look south of the border at the collapse in numbers of full-time students in English higher education institutions to see where that policy would have taken us. It is not a matter of insignificance that we have introduced, and will maintain and defend, a policy of free higher education in Scotland. That is the future for the Scottish education system.
We need only look south of the border at the collapse in numbers of full-time students in English higher education institutions to see where that policy would have taken us. It is not a matter of insignificance that we have introduced, and will maintain and defend, a policy of free higher education in Scotland. That is the future for the Scottish education system.
First, the First Minister is completely complacent. Secondly, it is one thing to talk about how to fund students who are at university, but the figures that I pointed out to him show that our access rates in Scotland are poorer than those in the rest of the United Kingdom, so it is nonsense for him to settle for a slogan rather than to find a solution for Scottish students.
The First Minister denies what is happening to young people all over the country, but what do we expect from a First Minister who claims that college spending is going up, when it is going down? What do we expect from a Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning who claimed that there are no waiting lists, when colleges have said that thousands are being denied college places? What do we expect from an education secretary and a First Minister who brutally cut college funding at the very point when we needed colleges most?
When colleges challenged him on waiting lists, did the First Minister say that that was something that the Government should investigate and get to the bottom of and ask, “Should we reflect on our spending priorities?” No. I will describe what the Government does. A private Government document that has been released under a freedom of information request says:
“The sooner we can produce our own version of events and discredit the Scotland’s Colleges survey the better.”
That is the Government’s approach—to get out its “version of events” rather than address the real problem. Once again, the Government says one thing in private and another in public. Does the First Minister understand why college lecturers have passed a motion of no confidence in Mike Russell?
The First Minister denies what is happening to young people all over the country, but what do we expect from a First Minister who claims that college spending is going up, when it is going down? What do we expect from a Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning who claimed that there are no waiting lists, when colleges have said that thousands are being denied college places? What do we expect from an education secretary and a First Minister who brutally cut college funding at the very point when we needed colleges most?
When colleges challenged him on waiting lists, did the First Minister say that that was something that the Government should investigate and get to the bottom of and ask, “Should we reflect on our spending priorities?” No. I will describe what the Government does. A private Government document that has been released under a freedom of information request says:
“The sooner we can produce our own version of events and discredit the Scotland’s Colleges survey the better.”
That is the Government’s approach—to get out its “version of events” rather than address the real problem. Once again, the Government says one thing in private and another in public. Does the First Minister understand why college lecturers have passed a motion of no confidence in Mike Russell?
What a long hotch-potch of nonsense. What the Government did was to examine the claims from the Labour Party, which were variously reported as 21,000 or 13,000 students waiting, depending on the time and who was speaking. We did that by conducting a survey that covered 12,866 applications. What did that survey find? It found that the claims from the Labour Party were a lot of piffle—its numbers did not exist. The lack of willingness to accept that point and that detail shows the emptiness of Johann Lamont’s questions. Of course, that is all in preparation for the Labour Party’s attempt to shift to a position of bringing tuition fees back in Scotland. Let us get to the reality.
In addition to our having a policy of no tuition fees and having the funding deal for universities—which everybody across the sector regards as excellent—we have provided £16 million for extra funded places at university in the coming year, which will provide more than 2,900 additional funded places, including more than 1,000 to increase articulation, 727 to widen access, 850 additional taught postgraduate places and 342 undergraduate places for key sectors. That is practical and detailed action to address the situation.
In a week in which the Labour Party’s hypocrisy has been blatant for all to see, a party that voted against legislation to widen access is in no position to complain about a lack of access in Scotland. [Applause.]
In addition to our having a policy of no tuition fees and having the funding deal for universities—which everybody across the sector regards as excellent—we have provided £16 million for extra funded places at university in the coming year, which will provide more than 2,900 additional funded places, including more than 1,000 to increase articulation, 727 to widen access, 850 additional taught postgraduate places and 342 undergraduate places for key sectors. That is practical and detailed action to address the situation.
In a week in which the Labour Party’s hypocrisy has been blatant for all to see, a party that voted against legislation to widen access is in no position to complain about a lack of access in Scotland. [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I can live with the First Minister insulting my intelligence, but he insults the intelligence of every young person across Scotland with that nonsense. The issue of college places absolutely describes the First Minister’s approach, which is, “If you don’t like what people say, shoot the messenger.” It was not the Labour Party that said that there were college waiting lists; it was Colleges Scotland. How dare he show such disrespect to people who are living with the cuts that he is imposing on their sector?
The First Minister boasts that
“the rocks will melt with the sun”—[Official Report, 8 September 2011; c 1537.],
as if everything in our education sector is perfect. He needs to recognise that, for too many Scots, the rocks will melt in the sun before they get a place at a Scottish university or college.
He denies the existence of the young people who are waiting for college places when he should be helping them. He promises to turn our schools from good to great when half of teachers admit that they are unprepared for the new curriculum, maths examiners are quitting and teachers are voting to strike. Mr Russell sits there, and his only answer in his speech was that we need independence rather than to address the problems that young people face now.
Is the truth not that, after six years of this SNP Government, the First Minister has failed to give all of Scotland’s young people the best chance in life and is now happy to hide behind soundbites rather than to create chances for students, with the promise of jam at some point in the future if the SNP ever wins the referendum question?
The First Minister boasts that
“the rocks will melt with the sun”—[Official Report, 8 September 2011; c 1537.],
as if everything in our education sector is perfect. He needs to recognise that, for too many Scots, the rocks will melt in the sun before they get a place at a Scottish university or college.
He denies the existence of the young people who are waiting for college places when he should be helping them. He promises to turn our schools from good to great when half of teachers admit that they are unprepared for the new curriculum, maths examiners are quitting and teachers are voting to strike. Mr Russell sits there, and his only answer in his speech was that we need independence rather than to address the problems that young people face now.
Is the truth not that, after six years of this SNP Government, the First Minister has failed to give all of Scotland’s young people the best chance in life and is now happy to hide behind soundbites rather than to create chances for students, with the promise of jam at some point in the future if the SNP ever wins the referendum question?
I will deal with those points in turn. Johann Lamont claims that
“It was not the Labour Party that said”
it. However, a Labour Party news release from 26 October stated that, according to Hugh Henry,
“over 21,000 students are on college waiting lists”.
However, on 25 January, in The Herald, Mr Henry is quoted as saying that
“likely more than 13,000 Scots were denied a place at college at a time of record high youth unemployment.”
I notice that the figure went down by 8,000 between October and January. The survey showed that those figures were a grotesque exaggeration and that Labour’s claims were total piffle and nonsense.
The reason why Johann Lamont does not like the survey is that she does not like the facts when they are spelled out to her Labour colleagues, whose comments were totally and utterly indefensible. Let us remember that, last year, there were a record number of Scottish students with full-time places in higher education in Scotland: “a record number” means that there were more than ever before. There was also a record number of English students in higher education in Scotland and a record number of international students.
Those were last year’s figures, while the number of university places was collapsing south of the border. Why was it collapsing south of the border? It was because of the punitive increased tuition fees. What does the Labour Party want to do? It wants to introduce tuition fees in Scotland. Every student and family knows full well that Johann Lamont’s plan is to introduce the £9,000 tuition fees in Scotland, and every family in Scotland can count.
As to how people are regarded, we heard evidence of that at the weekend in a poll showing the party ratings. The SNP was at 47 per cent, and the Labour Party was at 30 per cent. I hope and believe that that is a commentary on the excellence of the SNP Government, but I must face reality and know that it is also a commentary on the poverty of the Labour Opposition.
“It was not the Labour Party that said”
it. However, a Labour Party news release from 26 October stated that, according to Hugh Henry,
“over 21,000 students are on college waiting lists”.
However, on 25 January, in The Herald, Mr Henry is quoted as saying that
“likely more than 13,000 Scots were denied a place at college at a time of record high youth unemployment.”
I notice that the figure went down by 8,000 between October and January. The survey showed that those figures were a grotesque exaggeration and that Labour’s claims were total piffle and nonsense.
The reason why Johann Lamont does not like the survey is that she does not like the facts when they are spelled out to her Labour colleagues, whose comments were totally and utterly indefensible. Let us remember that, last year, there were a record number of Scottish students with full-time places in higher education in Scotland: “a record number” means that there were more than ever before. There was also a record number of English students in higher education in Scotland and a record number of international students.
Those were last year’s figures, while the number of university places was collapsing south of the border. Why was it collapsing south of the border? It was because of the punitive increased tuition fees. What does the Labour Party want to do? It wants to introduce tuition fees in Scotland. Every student and family knows full well that Johann Lamont’s plan is to introduce the £9,000 tuition fees in Scotland, and every family in Scotland can count.
As to how people are regarded, we heard evidence of that at the weekend in a poll showing the party ratings. The SNP was at 47 per cent, and the Labour Party was at 30 per cent. I hope and believe that that is a commentary on the excellence of the SNP Government, but I must face reality and know that it is also a commentary on the poverty of the Labour Opposition.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 28 Mar 2013 →- Business Motions Business motions · 3
- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Banks (Agency and Branch Closures) Questions · 6
- Neonicotinoids Questions · 6
- “When parents are detained” Questions · 4
- Supermarkets (Local Produce) Questions · 4
- Maintenance of Land on Private Housing Estates (Consultation Findings) Questions · 4
- Healthcare Improvement Scotland (Review) Questions · 5
- Cashback for Communities (Meetings with Partners) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Welfare Reform First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Junior Doctors’ Hours First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Police Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Bowel Cancer Members’ business · 8
- Decrofting of Owner-occupied Croft Land Statement · 25
- High Hedges (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 43
- High Hedges (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 43
- Point of Order Procedure · 11
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.