Item 2 is consideration of new petitions, of which there are three. As previously agreed, we will take evidence on two of them. The first is PE1472 by Councillor Gordon Murray and Councillor Rae MacKenzie, on behalf of protecting interisland transport links, on interisland air services. Members have a note by the clerks, which is paper 2, a Scottish Parliament information centre briefing, and the petition. I welcome the petitioners: Councillors Murray, MacKenzie and Manford. I invite Councillor Manford to make a short presentation of around five minutes to set the context.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Interisland Air Services (PE1472)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 11
- Councillor Manford 10
- Chic Brodie SNP 5
- Angus MacDonald SNP 3
- Adam Ingram SNP 2
- Councillor Donald Manford Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 1
- Councillor Rae MacKenzie Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 1
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
- Councillor Gordon Murray Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Jackson Carlaw Con 1
The record
37 contributionsThank you very much for giving us the opportunity to speak to you, convener. I also thank my colleague Gordon Murray for allowing me to make the introductory remarks. What are lifeline services? Lifeline services are exactly that to the communities that depend on them—a lifeline. It is therefore essential that their application is fair and consistent. The Scottish Parliament has an enviable record in considering and establishing the principles of fairness and equity.Lifeline services, whether by land, sea or air, are supported by Parliaments and Governments, which provide significant funds for that purpose. There are simple and straightforward definitions for lifeline public service obligation services. There is always room for improvement, but they are reasonably clear. What is not clear is the measure for their application or, more importantly, their discontinuation.Lifeline public service transport services are delivered by local and national Governments, although their importance to the people concerned is not altered by who delivers them. However, there appears to be no measure applied for fairness, equity or consistency, although I am thankful that measures are applied to services such as social care and education, irrespective of who delivers them.A public service obligation—PSO—is defined as “any obligation imposed upon a carrier to ensure the provision of a service satisfying fixed standards of continuity, regularity, capacity and pricing, which standards the carrier would not assume if it were solely considering its economic interest.”The SPICe 2011 “Transport in Scotland” briefing explains:“The rationale for imposing a PSO should be based on the fact that the maintenance of regular air services is ... vital to development of the region where the airport is located.”The council asserts that the reason for axing the services is based on cost and usage, holding that 25 per cent usage, or up to £80 public assistance per person, is beyond what should be expected or delivered. In the case of the Stornoway to Benbecula service, the figure is £40.Is that a baseline for all public service obligations? As lifeline PSO transport services are a national provision, it is reasonable that a national criterion should be set at the very least to ensure that application is fair, equitable and not widely different, regardless of the geographical area it is applied to or whether it is delivered by the national or local Government.Has a baseline of £40 per head, or 30 per cent usage, been established as a national precedent? Could it develop into one that applies to all public service obligations? That would include nearly all the air services and almost certainly all the ferry services.Through its budgeting, Western Isles Council has established lifeline transport as meriting being in the bottom 2 per cent of budget priority. Is that to apply fairly to all areas and forms of transport or will it vary? It would be devastating if national Government reduced the priority to that level. Do other local authorities apply different criteria? Is there a postcode lottery in lifeline services? Is there now a need for a national standard? That is what we ask the Parliament to consider. Thank you.
Thank you for lodging your petition, which is obviously relevant to our visit today. You make an interesting point about comparing PSOs in Scotland with the position more widely. As you well know, public service obligations are developed Europe-wide, and the European Commission clearly has a vital role. I had a look at some figures before today’s meeting and I note that, in general, both France and the Republic of Ireland use PSOs a lot more than the United Kingdom does. What is your view on that? If there are set criteria, why can we not use more PSOs?
I entirely agree that we should use more PSOs. We have argued for many years that a lot of the air services to which the air discount scheme is applied should have been made public service obligations, but there were lots of reasons why people were opposed to that. The coalition Government of the day applied the funding, but the carriers that provided the services on the routes indicated that they might resort to a court action if they were prevented from running them.There is often a debate about what a lifeline service is and what a PSO is. Sarah Boyack was the transport minister in 2000 and 2001, when the review was done, and it was established in that document that a lifeline service and a PSO are in effect one and the same thing. The service has to be a lifeline service before someone can apply for a PSO to operate it. The PSO is on the carrier, but the legal right to place that onus is obtained by the council or the Government in establishing the need. Nobody has ever considered the need to evaluate when the service should end. Under the European regulation, when the Commission is persuaded that the maintenance of regular air services is vital to the development of the region where the airport is located, we are allowed to provide them. However, what ends them? I presume that it is when that vital development is no longer needed.In this instance, a financial line of 30 per cent capacity has been applied. That is worrying given that, in air services, 40 to 45 per cent capacity is a measure of a service that can perhaps wash its face and not need a service obligation. Surely public service obligations exist for anything that falls below that. A measure of 30 per cent is being applied on one service. I am not arguing that that is unreasonable in itself, but does that apply to all services? To answer your question, I would agree with you—and I will be delighted if the Parliament supports bringing the figure down to 10 or even 5 per cent.
As you know far better than I do, the Barra and Benbecula routes are marginal routes that are never going to make money. There will always be issues of fragility with those routes. However, we can use the example of other services: the road equivalent tariff is a way of having some Scottish Government subsidy—in effect—to allow people to use key ferry services; and, as you know, the Labour Administration introduced the air discount scheme, which was another form of that.15:00
Do you think that it is time that we had an overall review of PSOs in Scotland? You will know that the Barra to Glasgow route, which is a Scottish Government PSO, will come to an end at the end of this month. There appears to be some confusion between local government PSOs and Scottish Government PSOs. My view is that we should probably bang a few heads together, conduct a major review and see how we can support fragile and rural areas. Do you share my view on that?
I do not think that there is a difference between Scottish Government PSOs and local authority PSOs. A PSO is a lifeline service. As I understand it, the routes are delivered by local authorities where local authorities have the relevant transport responsibility—it is simple—and they are funded through the Government by public money for that purpose. The Government delivers a PSO where the lifeline service crosses local authority boundaries. That is entirely reasonable and I do not see any problem with that. The Barra to Glasgow route has already spent five years on a feasibility review, and I would be loth to see that one looked at again.The point that I am making is that if a financial line is applied to a PSO and that financial line is 30 per cent, 25 per cent or £80 per head of people using it—if that precedent is set—that is extremely worrying. You have talked about the discount scheme and the road equivalent tariff. The Stornoway to Ullapool route is a PSO that has in the region of £10 million attached to it, and attempts are being made to improve it again. Of course, we would support that, but there is an argument about fairness and equity. How can one PSO be discontinued while support for another is increased?
I will make a final point before I bring in Chic Brodie. In other transport systems, the Government acts as the operator of last resort. You will be aware that, for example, the Government took over a rail service when the franchisee failed. Do you see that as an appropriate role for Government in fragile air services, particularly when PSOs are involved?
In the first instance, I would like the Parliament to advise and guide on whether there really should be a baseline service and what that service should be. That would be the best start.
Thank you. That was very helpful.
Good afternoon, gentlemen. Let me be slightly contentious. I currently have an interest in another airport on the mainland. State aid is aimed at covering losses, and we are told that it is not compatible with the single European market. At a recent meeting of the Airline Operators Association that I attended, we heard that 89 per cent of airports are technically subsidised by the state or by the local region. Have you had any discussion at all with the Scottish Government regarding European state aid assistance?
I have been involved in several discussions on transport matters with the Scottish Government. As I understand the rules for state aid, if a service is run for private benefit but is not delivering economic benefit Europe requires a service obligation in order to intervene.Everything then falls under the national delivery rules. Local authorities are the transport deliverers in certain circumstances and are funded by central Government for that purpose. There have always been—and are—many examples of ferry services that have been transferred from the council to national Government. When power has been devolved to the local authority, it has always been the case that the authority has approached the national Government and said, “Would you like to take this over?” Indeed, I understand that there are many such examples under the ferries review, but to date I have never heard of the Government stepping or muscling in and saying, “I am taking your powers.” The local authority always makes the first approach. It would be a terribly difficult situation if the local authority has received money to deliver a service, does not do so and applies the money to something else in the full knowledge that the Government will deliver the service anyway.I hope that that answers your question.
A big issue at the moment is the interpretation of state aid with regard to transport. Discussions are on-going, but I am not sure where they will end up.Another issue that you might be able to help me with is the imposition of other taxes on passengers. Please forgive me if this is not applicable, but do the air passenger duty and other such charges still apply even if local authorities have a legal PSO?
The air discount scheme was introduced to counter concerns about the threat of legal attacks or action against a Government for trying to impose a service obligation on a particular route. In such circumstances, the route would have to go out to tender, with the possibility that the organisation running it would lose out and then argue that it had built up the route. ADS was created to deal with such matters—
But I am talking about the air passenger duty that the UK Government levies on passengers who travel. Does that still apply under the auspices of a PSO?
I beg your pardon, Mr Brodie. I am not aware that it applies directly to the PSO. The PSO sets the top-line figure that cannot be exceeded, and the air service provider requests of the organisation giving it the contract the money that it needs to make a profit within the constraints set in the contract itself.
As we are a little short of time, I ask for short questions and answers.
I should probably declare that I am a weekly reader of the Stornoway Gazette and have therefore been following this issue quite closely. I have to say that I was very surprised at the council administration’s decision to axe in its budget the Barra to Benbecula service. As was stated in the ministerial response to a question that I believe the convener lodged about three weeks ago, the onus is on Comhairle nan Eilean Siar to provide this service.I have a lot of sympathy with having PSOs for lifeline services; indeed, as Councillor Manford has already pointed out, without PSO status we fall foul of European Union rules on direct state aid. However, we have not received in any briefings the exact figures for the number of passengers who use this particular service.Does anybody have those figures available? It is certainly clear that we need a fair and transparent formula across the country for PSOs, and it has already been stated that the decision by the council administration may set a precedent, which is a concern. Given that, do the petitioners agree that there should be a baseline evaluation for PSOs or, in other words, a national standard?
I certainly agree with that. I think that, nationally, we are going to get into a terrible mess now that it has been established that some form of baseline has been set. That probably undermines the whole reason for PSOs being introduced in the first place.
Given that the axing of the service arises from the recent budget, does the petition have the full backing of the administration and the full council?
I would like to give brief background information and my personal view, too.It is a fact that there was a budget and that a majority of councillors were in favour of axing the service, but there was another view, which we are representing here.The Western Isles Council was formed in 1974 and took over from the original town and county council in 1975, as members know. I was on that council and I am the last survivor of it serving on the Western Isles Council, although others are still around—I suppose that I am the last of the Mohicans. At that time, there was a conscious effort by the Lewis councillors, who represented two thirds of the council’s majority, to improve the situation in the southern isles, which had, as they would say themselves, suffered under Inverness-shire County Council in comparison with Lewis, which was under Ross and Cromarty County Council. Over the past 38 years since then, causeways have been built, roads have been improved, and ferries have been introduced.On 19 August 1975 the council minutes referred to the proposed interisland air service, and a couple of months later they mentioned the inaugural flight of the Loganair service.The vision of the founding fathers of the council has, sadly, been thrown in the bin, on the floor or wherever. After 38 years, the aspiration of linking the islands together has taken a backward step. Gordon Murray and I are from Lewis, and we will probably never need the service on a regular basis—and, we hope, never in an emergency—but many will. That is why we are looking for the committee’s help and guidance.I have an email that is relevant to the present situation. It says:“Presently we can provide blood transfusions in St Brendan’s by arranging it around the flights so we are within the guidelines for the timings in transfusing blood. The blood is therefore in transit for the shortest time possible. If we lose the Barra leg then the blood journey from Lewis to Barra is too long and we will not be able to provide that service meaning patients will have to be transferred away.”That is from St Brendan’s hospital.I cannot, of course, say what a future alternative would or should be, but that sort of thing should have been sorted out before the service was withdrawn.
Thank you very much for your background information, Councillor MacKenzie. You certainly do not look like a veteran, so keep up the good work.
I have a supplementary question. Earlier, Councillor Manford mentioned the ferries review. When is that due to be completed?
The ferries review is already complete. The plan is now being rolled out and delivered.The point that I made was that each single ferry route is essentially a public service obligation and has a sum of money attached—there is sometimes a global sum, but the sum can be worked out for each different one.There are lots of campaigns to increase each ferry service whether it be through ferry fares, increased numbers of journeys, or speed. However, each link will require more PSO money. I am asking the Government and Parliament, for the purposes of fairness and equity, what formula we can use to decide whether the ferry service should be increased, remain the same, or end. Do you feel that there should be such a formula?15:15
Thank you for that. We are just about out of time.
I have been trying to find a parallel to this situation and I hope that the councillors might be able to help me. I am thinking about the closure of other vital services such as rural schools. I know that the Western Isles has had to face such issues, but there is clear guidance, backed by legislation, that would impact on a council’s decision to close a rural school. Is that the type of guidance, perhaps backed by legislation, that you are looking for on PSOs? Would you welcome the Scottish Parliament delivering that so that you are not left in the situation that you are in just now?
Yes. There has to be an evaluation of how the application of public funds in one geographical area can be measured against the application of public funds somewhere else.
Local authorities cannot close a school on financial grounds alone. A number of other criteria have to be met before such closures. You are telling us that a PSO is being scrapped on financial grounds, despite the fact that, as part of its settlement, the council is receiving money to provide the service.
That is absolutely correct. Something is being withdrawn without any direct evaluation or reference to the purposes for which it was introduced.
This is an interesting and pertinent petition, so I thank the petitioners for bringing it to us. We were talking earlier about the road equivalent tariff and it occurred to me that we need to introduce an air equivalent tariff for PSOs. However, that might be for another day.
On what we should do, Councillor Manford’s final comment was pertinent. Where is the economic and social benefit analysis to support such action? It is not just an issue for the Government—the council has taken a position—but it is up to us to ask the Government a question and to have the Government ask the council for the details of its analysis.
As Councillor Manford said, our community is running quite a number of transport campaigns at the moment. We wonder how we can argue in favour of those campaigns while withdrawing the service. There is a campaign for a ferry between Lochboisdale and Mallaig, and we want to improve the times for the ferry between Stornoway and Ullapool. Could withdrawing the service undermine our campaign to secure a flight between Stornoway and Aberdeen through a PSO, or could it reduce ferry services by increasing the need for subsidies? In withdrawing one service, how can we argue for another? We are looking for guidance.
I am sure that you have not forgotten it, but I think that the fair fuels campaign should also be added to your list. We are out of time, so we must consider our next steps. My view is that this is a pertinent petition that we should continue. We should ask the Scottish Government for its views. We agreed to invite Alex Neil to speak to us in relation to the previous petition, and I suggest that we ask Keith Brown, the Minister for Transport and Veterans, to come to a future meeting to address some of the points that have been raised. Do members have a view on the suggestions?
I was also going to suggest that we write to the Scottish Government to seek its views on the issues that have been raised today. It might also be useful to write to other local authorities to ask how PSOs operate in their areas and whether they face any difficulties with them. We should get the responses to those inquiries before we decide whether to invite Keith Brown to a meeting.
I agree that we should wait for the responses before we decide to invite Keith Brown, but that is an option that should be kept in mind.
I will be contrary, convener. As I understand it, money has been provided for this purpose, and we are being asked to intervene on a matter that has been visited on the community by the council that it chose to elect. Its first remedy is to elect a different council. I am not quite sure what the obligation is that we are asking ministers to take a view on, given that there is a remedy open to the community to deal with the issue.
The huge potential that exists for communities such as this one demands action, and it means that people should not have to wait until the next election. The Scottish Government must be asked its interpretation of the situation. I would also like to see a full interpretation of the EU regulations, which apply to member states—of course, we are not yet one of those directly. We should also ask the Scottish Government to investigate the implications of state aid regulations regarding PSOs and provide us with a detailed analysis.
Orkney and Shetland are good examples of local authorities with PSOs, as is Argyll and Bute, which has the Campbeltown PSO. I obviously do not want to enter the constitutional debate but, the last time I checked, we were still a member of the EU.We do not normally have votes in this committee, but I believe that the majority view—with the exception of Jackson Carlaw—is that we should write to local authorities that have a PSO interest and the Scottish Government. Once we have assessed those responses, we will take a decision on whether to invite Keith Brown to a future meeting. I thank the three councillors for contributing to our deliberations. You have helped to inform our decision making on the issue. We will keep you up to date with developments. I will suspend the meeting to allow the witnesses to change over.15:23 Meeting suspended.
15:25 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Mar 2013 →- 14:00 Current Petition Petitions · 87
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 37
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 23
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.